Those three should be disqualified!! - Page 3

Those who said that it's the voice of India, not Assam should remember that Ujjaini and Hemachandra have always got the majority of their votes from their regions. Going by the same logic, shouldn't they be DQ'ed as well?

What do you expect - the home region NOT voting for their contestant?

I AM FROM TORONTO, CANADA. I WATCHED THE SHOW YESTERDAY AND WAS REALLY DISGUSTED AT VINIT, HEMA AND HIMANI. I HAD SO MUCH RESPECT FOR THEM BUT THAT'S ALL HISTORY. INSTEAD OF SUPPORTING DEBU, THEIR FACES TURNED SOUR AND WHEN THEY WERE HOLDING HANDS, I FELT SOMETHING IS GOING TO HAPPEN. THEY HAVE LOST ALL THEIR RESPECT. TILL THIS HAPPEND, I HAD SO MUCH RESPECT FOR ALL THREE AND THEIR FAMILIES. BUT THEY DID NOT EVEN RESPECT THEIR PARENTS WHO WERE IN THE AUDIENCE. THEY ARE NOT EVEN STARS AS YET AND THEY ARE ACTING SO HIGH UP THERE.
DEBU IS SO SINCERE AND HE IS THE BEST. MY SUPPORT GOES FOR HIM AND HIM ONLY.
I DONT HAVE ANYTHING TO SAY ABOUT THE MENTORS.
REKHA LADVA
TORONTO, CANADA

I AM FROM TORONTO, CANADA. I WATCHED THE SHOW YESTERDAY AND WAS REALLY DISGUSTED AT VINIT, HEMA AND HIMANI. I HAD SO MUCH RESPECT FOR THEM BUT THAT'S ALL HISTORY. INSTEAD OF SUPPORTING DEBU, THEIR FACES TURNED SOUR AND WHEN THEY WERE HOLDING HANDS, I FELT SOMETHING IS GOING TO HAPPEN. THEY HAVE LOST ALL THEIR RESPECT. TILL THIS HAPPEND, I HAD SO MUCH RESPECT FOR ALL THREE AND THEIR FAMILIES. BUT THEY DID NOT EVEN RESPECT THEIR PARENTS WHO WERE IN THE AUDIENCE. THEY ARE NOT EVEN STARS AS YET AND THEY ARE ACTING SO HIGH UP THERE.
DEBU IS SO SINCERE AND HE IS THE BEST. MY SUPPORT GOES FOR HIM AND HIM ONLY.
I DONT HAVE ANYTHING TO SAY ABOUT THE MENTORS.
REKHA LADVA
TORONTO, CANADA

I am really upset at the fact that only the 3 OF THEM made this so-called decision to quit the show.
I was truly shocked. And I don't think they should be disqualified. They should sing and see how many less votes they will get because of their selfish actions.

I am from USA and i wathced the show yesterday , i was very upset by what these 3 did ..... It was a foolish and immature decision on their part to have worked soo hard for 7 months and then to walk out , because apparently they think that only them 3 are the best top 3 !! Only they deserve to get the highest votes!They disrespected the people who have been watching this show , who have been spending their money voting for these contestants the people who gave them this opportunity to be on the show . They crushed the faith of the people who belived that they could win . It took them 7 months of hardwork to be where they are today , it only took them a second to blow it !! until that walk out everyone knew them as the best singers , now they will be known as "oh himani, vinit and hemachandra those 3 who walked out of sa re ga ma challenge 2005" Its a shame !!!For me they are history !! I dont have words for Himani ,in the begining of the show shaan asked her how do you feel about one person leaving today ? she says i just hope that i dont get have an ego !! The next minute they all show their egos on their faces when they hear debojit gets the highest votes . Vinit what a liar , when ID asks when did you decide this he says we 3 decided it yesterday ?????? If they decided it yesterday then where was debojit ?????? I am sure the one person who would have gotten the most hurt after nihiras exit is debojit not himani , hema and vinit...... she was their thereat . what a lame excuse to give and what a lie on national TV . Vinit who sat there saying we also know a little bit about music. Yeah just cos he gets a 10 10 10 every time doesnt mean he is the BEST doesnt mean he has the right to sit ther and judge his fellow contestants ! I give it up fpr debojit who sang the toughest kawali and did an awesome job . I saw how hurt debojit was when all this was going on , but whats his fault in that . Hema chandra , followed these 2 , he should have had his own mind and decision . All i can say is a very wrong act has been commited . i hope and wish that debojit tunrs a winner in all this , although if he does i know most of the contesatants will not like this .

Originally posted by: Iron

Guys chill and put youself in their position. I highly doublt they meant to go against Debo...If they had guts to go on stage to walk out..they would have said they are against Debo. And if the mentors and (Audience toO) Think Assam is not a part of India then how can we blame kids?// I think it is our fault

You should read post fairness and Justification of walk

Iron , if i put myself in their position 1stly i would ask myslef 100 times before i take the action they took . This was no joke !! it was a hugeeee decision... even people who are in love and who run away with their lovers think over 100 times before they leave their houses . This is national TV where millions of people are watching do you not think they would have thought about the consequences that would arise for doing what they did ? Y would they have the gutts to say they are against Debo ????? Tell me wouldnt that put their image on stake here ??? No one isd openly gonna say what the real reason behind this is . Any way i dont want to put too much into this they had their reasons and whatever happens will happen for the best . May the truth win !

I agree. "Jo hota hai wo acche ke liye hi hota hai"

When one person in the audience was talking about home ground,AS directed to the lady- who said "it is India's voice".Could it be coincidence NO It is a setup.
Set up by HR and/OR AS.
"Has anyone seen the face of same lady-after Himani eliminated from the challenge?"
I have watched on the downloaded episode-Today it is going to be aired in US. It has been confirmed setup
Watch it carefully-everything is clear.

I agree too.

Of course when u come to this stage u r naturally left with good singers and it hurts if any of them are gone, but let us face the truth...there can be only one #1

Iron , we dont really know what really happened and what was going through these contestants minds , but lets not say that because they are teenagers they are kids ! No at their age everyone has a sense of what is right and what is wrong. If these contestants really had a problem , they should have sorted it out before the show started and not done so during the show .They are all old enough to find different alternatives to sort out what was bothering them. Y they created a scene during the show is beyond me! who knows what the truth is right iron ? Although , i still dont think they did the right thing ....i wouldnt feel this way if all 4 would have walked out but the fact that Debojit was not included in this makes me think that there was something fishy going on....