MY TWO CENTS ON YESTERDAY'S EPISODE. - Page 4

Originally posted by: baadsha

Musicpulse,

Although a very active viewer of IF posts I am compelled to post my reply today

Yalgar Ho!!!!
👏

Thank you, I am honoured. God Bless ID!👏👏👏

Originally posted by: sree's sree

easily the best
and for my taste
very GUTSY
Keep this up Sir

maam actually😉

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

👏 Hats off to you, Sir. Written without a single bias. And written in the true spirit of music. I agree wholeheartedly with you except for one point.

You said debu should've been given 8+1 for his performance. I say, he should've been given 10+1+a chumma for his guts and sheer intensity and determination. 😃

Thank you very much. Well, I said from point of performance, he lacked that one point,(remember this is supposed to be much more than a music contest). Since you are a jankar, I would like to tell you the only solo taans in the qawalis, ie the taans completely sung by one singer only, to that did Debo not do justice? And look at the speed or rhythm of the song, mindblowing man! All hats off to the great Roshan Saab, and ofcourse, Mannada, RAfi Saab and Ashaji.You can even hear slight fumblings in the original song, that is why it is ajramar. It captured the chaos that goes on in qawali competitions. It really captured the essence.

What do taans translate to in English? 😕

Originally posted by: MysticaMagic

What do taans translate to in English? 😕

Good question, thinking about it, will let you know when the enlightenment happens.😊

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

True, true. See, Qawwalis originated as singing competition between singers in a court. It branched off from the rigourous bonds of classical influence around Akbar's time. Actually, the Qawwali was invented by Amir Khusrao, as a form of poetry woven into rythymic singing. And yes, the chaos of a qawwali is perfectly captured, true. And debo did full justice to the taans. He's a class apart.

Roshan Saab ke kya kehne...main ek hin gana suggest karunga - Laga Chunrai Mein Daag. 😃

My favourite is Meine shayad tumhe pehle bhi kahin dekha hai. What lilting melody, slight use of instruments and what vocals. Thats what great singers are made of. ONe for Rafi Saab. Tang aa chuke hai kashmakashe jindagi se hum. Absolutely withiut music to back him up, form Pyasa.👏

to ur reply of saying hems body language has changed i do not agree .did u see how debu behaved stamping his feet gritting his teeth and so agressive.he is always playing the sympathy card.

Hi! here is my enlightenment too 😊

to ur reply of saying hems body language has changed i do not agree .did u see how debu behaved stamping his feet gritting his teeth and so agressive.he is always playing the sympathy card.

Excellent post. We were missing superb singer Nihira.