MY TWO CENTS ON YESTERDAY'S EPISODE.

musicpulse thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

It was a dare bare day yesterday. The only threat to everybody, Nihira was out, and it was very difficult for everyone to keep their emotions under wraps, I am sorry they did not even try! With a heavy heart, I watched the demons of human nature, popping their heads up time and again in yesterday's qawali round. ID was completely dejected and simmering inside. Understandable. His heart was not in the show. He was badly trying to comprehend, how could the public vote out Nihira in favor of all these. He was cynically doling out 10 after 10, as a challenge to AS and HR , to do the same for Debo. And boy, did they bite the bait, and how!!!As we know, AS has not tasted success in a long time, so yesterday was his big day. His comparatively untrained Himani had beaten ID's superbly trained and talented Nihira. He had that tremendous glow of self-satisfaction and mostly a smirk directed towards ID. His going down on his knee and suro ki rani was to spite ID. HR, I must say I have come to like him over AS, is the most consistent person on the show. He never surprises you nor does he let you down. All eyes, all ears for Vinit only. Now about the contestants. Guys, Hema's body language has changed. Gone is the humble please-vote-for-me stance. What has replaced is vote-for-me-I-am-the-best. Himani was having a field day. Well, the mice tend to play when the cat is away. Her jhatkas and matkas in aye meri zohara jabi.. were totally uncalled for. But her performance was good. Vinit, like HR is completely predictable. His parda hai would have brought down the house in any college annual function, but honestly, not up to mark. Not bcz he could not copy the inimitable Rafi Saab, but bcz on its own it was sometimes besur. Coming to Debo, my heart goes out to him. He and his mentor, both are simpletons as compared to other shanas that are afflicting this show. Everybody has a very condescending way of looking at him. His coming from small town of Assam, his regional vote bank are much hyped. It's a psychological battle. The complete disbelief with which AS and HR look, when Debo is performing, says, "how has this guy come so far?" Then they dole out their patronizing 4s, 6s, and 7s. AS's Debo is not a bura singer, was pathetic rather than cheap. Please hear what we have to say about you, Mr. As. ID is fantabulous, HR is successful, what are you? As for Debo's performance, well, his voice cracked at places, but singing this qawali is not a joke. The original has been sung by at least 5 main singers simultaneously, so it is multilayered, with a continuous chorus to back it up. Amongst all things, Debo took, 3 very difficult tans perfectly, in tandem with the speed, in an unhalting rhythm. And he was in sur all the time. His performance demanded a 8, plus one for his courage. But we know, HR and especially AS lack this very same courage. It takes guts to praise somebody from a different gharana. ID had that. I could just imagine Nihira singing Asha's magnificent nigahen milane ko ji chahata hai. Debo getting highest number of votes this week does not come as a surprise. But if his big moment is being tainted with references to terrorism, I am sorry to say, the rest of them were never the winners as it is, but they are neither graceful losers!!!!!

Edited by musicpulse - 19 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

4.1k

Users

17

Frequent Posters

N Sinha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
I'll trust your observation ..............
N Sinha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
most shameful is AS's attitude to give easy & within genre songs to his chelas, he hardly ever let Himani go out, at this point he is giving songs like tumse milke dil ka hai jo haal..... to Hema which has nothing to offer.........
SHAMEFUL ....................AS keep on wasting your chela, just like you wasted your youth yearning for success which you never got.........
musicpulse thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: N Sinha

most shameful is AS's attitude to give easy & within genre songs to his chelas, he hardly ever let Himani go out, at this point he is giving songs like tumse milke dil ka hai jo haal..... to Hema which has nothing to offer.........
SHAMEFUL ....................AS keep on wasting your chela, just like you wasted your youth yearning for success which you never got.........

yes, niraj i agree. We do not know actually who pick up the songs.

saregama thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: musicpulse

It was a dare bare day yesterday. The only threat to everybody, Nihira was out, and it was very difficult for everyone to keep their emotions under wraps, I am sorry they did not even try! With a heavy heart, I watched the demons of human nature, popping their heads up time and again in yesterday's qawali round. ID was completely dejected and simmering inside. Understandable. His heart was not in the show. He was badly trying to comprehend, how could the public vote out Nihira in favor of all these. He was cynically doling out 10 after 10, as a challenge to AS and HR , to do the same for Debo. And boy, did they bite the bait, and how!!!As we know, AS has not tasted success in a long time, so yesterday was his big day. His comparatively untrained Himani had beaten ID's superbly trained and talented Nihira. He had that tremendous glow of self-satisfaction and mostly a smirk directed towards ID. His going down on his knee and suro ki rani was to spite ID. HR, I must say I have come to like him over AS, is the most consistent person on the show. He never surprises you nor does he let you down. All eyes, all ears for Vinit only. Now about the contestants. Guys, Hema's body language has changed. Gone is the humble please-vote-for-me stance. What has replaced is vote-for-me-I-am-the-best. Himani was having a field day. Well, the mice tend to play when the cat is away. Her jhatkas and matkas in aye meri zohara jabi.. were totally uncalled for. But her performance was good. Vinit, like HR is completely predictable. His parda hai would have brought down the house in any college annual function, but honestly, not up to mark. Not bcz he could not copy the inimitable Rafi Saab, but bcz on its own it was sometimes besur. Coming to Debo, my heart goes out to him. He and his mentor, both are simpletons as compared to other shanas that are afflicting this show. Everybody has a very condescending way of looking at him. His coming from small town of Assam, his regional vote bank are much hyped. It's a psychological battle. The complete disbelief with which AS and HR look, when Debo is performing, says, "how has this guy come so far?" Then they dole out their patronizing 4s, 6s, and 7s. AS's Debo is not a bura singer, was pathetic rather than cheap. Please hear what we have to say about you, Mr. As. ID is fantabulous, HR is successful, what are you? As for Debo's performance, well, his voice cracked at places, but singing this qawali is not a joke. The original has been sung by at least 5 main singers simultaneously, so it is multilayered, with a continuous chorus to back it up. Amongst all things, Debo took, 3 very difficult tans perfectly, in tandem with the speed, in an unhalting rhythm. And he was in sur all the time. His performance demanded a 8, plus one for his courage. But we know, HR and especially AS lack this very same courage. It takes guts to praise somebody from a different gharana. ID had that. I could just imagine Nihira singing Asha's magnificent nigahen milane ko ji chahata hai. Debo getting highest number of votes this week does not come as a surprise. But if his big moment is being tainted with references to terrorism, I am sorry to say, the rest of them were never the winners as it is, but they are neither graceful losers!!!!!

You think very practical it seems. This is the best post and I completely agree with you.

N Sinha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
MP
plz try to make large alphabets small, even normal size..........
musicpulse thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
Thank you to everyone who has responded.
Saskatonian thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
Excellent post - I completely agree with you. I watched the show yesterday in Canada where Ismail Darbar walked off the set. Some of the postings under other threads have enraged me - the ones that claim that the only reason for ID walkout was the fact that Nihira was voted out and he does not have enough sportsmanship to accept the decision. If you are blind, deaf and stupid enough to think that ID walked out *only because* Nihira was voted out then I don't know where to begin with you. Adesh Shrivastav is an A-hole and has been taunting ID and treating Nihira and Debojit unfairly for the longest time. There is only so much abuse a person can take (especially from a sore nobody like Adesh) and there is only so much injustice a person can tolerate- I support ID for walking out on an idiot like Adesh S and not putting up with his Bull Shit anymore. And then there is the shameless promotion of Vinit and his so called "real love" by his mentor Himesh - I think HR wants to keep vinit in the forefront just to stroke his own ego - he gave Debo, Himani and Hem less marks for flawless singing while gave his own contest a 10. I am glad someone is speaking up against injustice - Well done ID!!! I MISS NIHIRA - she was the most talented of the bunch and the shows standard has been lowered with her being ousted.
uknaik99 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#9
GOOD POST.. I agree with you..

ID was not all interested thru out the show.. his experessions showed it all...and his walkout looked like a Drama...

Hemu,Vinit,Himani were not up to mark and Debo tried his best to sing difficult song..

I am sorry to say that SRGMP is not worth watching now 🤢 🤢

Ps: can someone pls ask Debo's wife not to cry in every episode.. looks so pathetic.. Ravi in II2 is also doing the samething emotionally blackkmailing Janata with his poor background and family speach...
musicpulse thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: uknaik99

GOOD POST.. I agree with you..

ID was not all interested thru out the show.. his experessions showed it all...and his walkout looked like a Drama...

Hemu,Vinit,Himani were not up to mark and Debo tried his best to sing difficult song..

I am sorry to say that SRGMP is not worth watching now 🤢 🤢

Ps: can someone pls ask Debo's wife not to cry in every episode.. looks so pathetic.. Ravi in II2 is also doing the samething emotionally blackkmailing Janata with his poor background and family speach...

How true, if only we could stop watching this show. But I guess we are addicted.😭

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".