Ujjaini made indirect attack on Himesh - Page 4

Originally posted by: Devil_in_Heaven

Sujalfan

You are missing a point over here . Why should a mentor support a person who is not all that talented like " ujjani " ?

According to you..are Vinit and Ujjani of the same calibre ?

HR is supporting Vinit becoz of his talent not becoz of any other reason

Same goes for ID ...who gives " chumma " to Debojet ..when he sings well..and says " achi koshish thi " ..when he sings bad

I believe only quality singer should be supported ..to make sure ..they get the credit for their calibre...and a bad performace shouldnt be supported by anyone including his/her mentor !!

Devil_in_Heaven,
What everyone is saying here is that HR as the mentor should not show favoritism towards one single member of his gharana. Ye tou wahi baat ho gayi ki parents apne ek bacche ko public school aur doosre ko govt. school mein daal rahe hain.
Even if he feels that Vinit is a better singer (which he is), he should not promote him at the expense of ignoring others.
This is something I've been saying all along. HR has definitely changed ever since he got Brahmastra (or maybe he's showing his true colors). Earlier, his only reaction used to be "excellent, superb, fantastic, mindblowing" for all contestants. And now, he usually has a sullen look on his face and hardly has anything good to say about anyone except Vinit.

Originally posted by: bunbutt_too

Ujjaini deserves to be commended not only for her singing ability but for her maturity even at such a tender age. HR and his preference for males has been obvious from "sweet sweet Nanu" to "mera Aishwaria" and now raining & showering on "aashiq Vinit" Is this what a mentor is supposed to be? laanat ho aise mentors or show peh!

This whole Brahmastra business was a farce. Ujjaini or for that matter Paresh have got as far as they have with or without HR and should be congratulated for their achievements. Vinit has not sung a single song that came any where close to Ujjaini's "koi sheheri babu" or Paresh's "na tum jano na hum." The song from "tera jadoo chalgaya" that Vinit sang was not deserving of the 10 points or the 50 rupee bill that ID gave to him. ID lost his astuteness as a mentor and became what HR has been from day one!

Sorry Nihira, Hemu, Debu, & Himani, but I strongly feel that at this stage they should just give the award to Shaan since he is the only person that has been fair and simply excellent in every sense of the word in this Challenge 2005 experiment. If GS plans on another such show he needs to write up the rules and post them publicly. The rules should not be continuously evolving. They should get an independent outside accounting firm to tabulate results. More important the professional mentors should maintain a modicum of dignity. If cheap publicity and TRP ratings was the only goal of this show then I congratulate you on your success GS. However if you really wanted to be a class act over all other such shows then learn from the tender aged Ujjaini! Ameen!

Especially on:'the 50 rupee bill that ID gave to him'. I, in ID's place, after having committed the sin to lose my most prized possession to a nerd, and realising the value he puts on it, would have given the duffer a tight slap and snatched the note back from him -- the loony kept gnarling like a chimp (or HR) does upon seeing similarity in a mirror. The slum-dweller already acts beyond his age. He is already a star man!!! Hats off to the moron. Sorry!! Topi's off to the moron gharana......😡

seriously even vinit should have been in another gharana.poor kid-he himself must be feeling cloistered with HR.HR is too immature.how old is he?

Bravo UJJAINI for speaking up.IT must have been demoralising to put up with stepfatherly treatment-being told 'you can never be my VINIT'.

that is so true. i like the way vinit sings but the other two were no less. if they had his support the way vinit did i bet she wouldnt be out. i think the hamesh dude is a good music director but not a good mentor.what i like about the other mentors is that they are really suppotive about their singers but the hamesh dude makes me made 😡

************* SORRY IF I OFFENDED ANY ONE IN ANY WAY*****

Originally posted by: sujalfan

We are not mentors so can take sides. But a mentor being partial to his own gharana students.... well thats wrong. And yesterday Himeshji was completely quiet after Ujjaini's outburst. His face showed that he knew he has been cornered this time. Throughout the whole programe he was always taking Vinit's side and never actually helped his other two contestants that much.

It is not that who brought these two in the Brahmastra round. What I meant to say was after you take someone as your pupil why should you diffentiate between them. Someone can be your favourite. No problem with that. But encourage others too. Thats where Himeshji failed.

HR's bias towards his students is like the mother of a twin pair suckling her beloved one evertime the other cries and thus ending up:'the poor lady once had two kids; the other one was just like the one in her lap'....how sad!!!😭

I think in addition to blaming HR for all this... we shud blame Zee / Sarega... / Gaj for all the maniac antics we see in the show. Gaj doesnot have the guts to ask HR to stop... Every show we see the Topi wala story and now HR started the GirlFriend wala story ... what crap !!! HR says ... "Vinit sach much bohut pyar kartahai .. aur aplog vote deke uske sapne ko sakar kijiye ! 😡 WHAT !!! Whats going on !! Why can this not be edited out !! When Debojit got a lot of praise for a song .. HR says .. Topi ka credit hain ... from next day dont wear the topi !! And ID commands Debojit.. Bolo topi utar dunga !! As if HR patented the topi ...

HR is so so rude ... he sits there with a serious face .. doesnot comment on anything other than his contestants..

When the game is on ... ID shud play it too... hes the most stupid (read good hearted) mentor... he is generous to all the contestants .. while the other 2 are playing the game.

Himesh is soo soo shrewed and go to any length to get what he wants. And I doubt if he will allow Zee to eliminate Vinit if he gets the lowest.

Vinit on the other hand is not an undeservng singer.Hes good but I think all the hype and stories atleast are creating some hatred unwantedly. Vinit is lucky to get a mentor like HR .. he already got more than 4-5 songs while ID's contestants didnot get a single song from him !!

Sometimes when they talk of Vinits romance ... and in the love round.. HR said ... jis din Vinit apna girl friend ka naam bata dega mein bhi mera romance ke bare ke baare mein bata dunga !! So who knows HR may be in LOVE with Vineet ... ;) kidding 😳

Whatever Himesh is doing....shouldnt be something to be held against vinit

Whatz Vinit's fault ?

Originally posted by: Devil_in_Heaven

There is a saying

" You hate , when u know , someonez better than you "

This goes for HR and Vinit ...some ppl hate them ..becoz they know at the back of their mindz that Vinit will win C 2005 !!

What's the corollary of u'r saying ?

"You love when u know, u'r better than someone "

Is that it ? Good .... now I know why so many people all over the world are fans of Aishwarya Rai and like her / her beauty .... Because they are better than her in every way !!!

😆 😆 😆

The wisdom of the quote and it's corollary is so funny !!!

😉 😉 😉

Originally posted by: Devil_in_Heaven

Whatever Himesh is doing....shouldnt be something to be held against vinit

Whatz Vinit's fault ?

Vineet (may be because he can't measure the wiliness of his mentor) is party to all the misdemeanours of HR. The devil has turned the kid into a hauty dud. When it is the age of learning (which off course stands true with HR also) he has started behaving as if he is a winner already. Much like Arindam Choudhary, who predicted his 'rok sako' to be a record breaker blockbuster and saw even free harleys couldn't save the failure--brought forward by his hautiness. He is virtually applying disc brakes to the smooth learning movement (yet to set off and continue for a fairly long period -- there are no shortcuts only evasions) of the kid. Poor vinit. He has to pay for his mentor's deeds, much like meghnad had to because of ravana's 😭

ID had made correct rmearks and I would say HR really needs to support his contestants, I mean if he doesnt like them why did he call them back? I don't think Vinit has anything to do with this but the constant comments HR gives to Vinit is pissing me off now and its time he learnt how to support his team.