Update Thursday 15 Dec 2005 - Page 2

And for me Vinit/Nihira are best, though I like Himani too.

Originally posted by: lalit1

hi sherley
i agree that hema is not given good songs or publicity
for me hema/nihira are the best

Me too! Hema/Nihira are my favourites, along with Debojit.

Regarding the song selection, who chooses the song, are the contestants given a theme for the day and they select the song or are the mentors choosing it for them. Except for the SLB round, where he picked songs for the contestants I do not see a clear idea of how they are given the songs.

But where are the comments from the judges?
And do you think guys,that Paresh will be out
next week? 😭 😭 😭

i think the participants r not given chance to select their songs. they might b giving their choice of songs for the theme. but if the mentors r selecting the songs AS shud b quick in selecting songs for his participants. hema is also not given publicity. in shahid kapoor and amritha rao's episode everybody except hema got comments from amritha. y is that so.....? y r they ignoring hema like this? y is vinit given so much of hype even though he have a unmatured n baccha kinda voice? gaj ji pls make a note and give hema also equal kinda publicity.

Originally posted by: sherley

i think the participants r not given chance to select their songs. they might b giving their choice of songs for the theme. but if the mentors r selecting the songs AS shud b quick in selecting songs for his participants. hema is also not given publicity. in shahid kapoor and amritha rao's episode everybody except hema got comments from amritha. y is that so.....? y r they ignoring hema like this? y is vinit given so much of hype even though he have a unmatured n baccha kinda voice? gaj ji pls make a note and give hema also equal kinda publicity.

According to posts in another thread, actually Amrita was impressed with Hema's singing and asked him to sing another song. It was edited, I think that the producers are editing the show to suit the masses need. Maybe they feel Hema do not have the pull factor like others do, so he gets the short end of the stick, which is a shame.

I also agree with you that AS(if he is the one selecting the song) should pick good songs for Hema which showcases his talent. Now that Rajiv is out he will have more time to concentrate on Hema and make him a winner.

Originally posted by: shika

But where are the comments from the judges?
............

Hi Shika,

Well on the Elimination days the judges dont comment much about performances..... Yesterday AS was very happy bout Himani's performance n came up to congratulate her n bless her. For Rajeev(after he was eliminated),AS had encouraging words...."Tum Challenge 2005 se bahar ho rahe ho..lekin janta ke dilon se nahi".

HR consoled Ujjaini when she got yellow n said his gut feeling was "Aaj tum bahar nahi jaogi".

ID was tensed bout the results n even asked Shaan if we could have the results first b4 any furthr performances.

Thats all I remember bout the judges comments!!!😊

@lalit,
Heyy thanx for the updates!! U did a good job!! Am still away on that trip n my return got delayed...but I think I'll b back in time to post the updates of 22nd.

But gr8 job in the mean time.

Thank you very much for the updates.

Thanks for the update Lalit. I agree with u all that given the potential Hemchandra has, he should have been where Vineet is today, in terms of hype and he would have been if he had HR for mentor. Its Vineet's good luck that HR fights for him the way he does and makes everyone else look like bad guys. Vineet does sing very well but so do Hemchandra and Debojit.