Does winning or losing really matter? - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

2.5k

Users

16

Likes

30

Frequent Posters

rudr_26 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: Awww

Rudr - where were you when the controversy queen was starting topics putting Raja down? Funny - you turn blind eye to certain topics.


By the way, this topic was to discuss does it matter one wins or loses....obviously it didn't matter that in C2007 Raja did not win the challenge, because his talent shined.

This reminds me of what Aamir Khan said from movie 3 idiots..."success ke peeche mat bhagoo......"

Anyway...wishing Aneek the very best. Hoping to see him shine in 10 years...ameen to your prayers in true sense.



Its funny of you that you did not see that who start comparing first. Mine was just a reaction of it as I am strictly against this comparison. If some persons doesnt understand straight way, then we have to show the crooked way to shut them off.

You also categorically overlooked where I said that " it takes more to be a playback singer,just not winning competition".. so dont jump on to guns before reading all.


I don't START comparing singers and success who are not in same scale or situation in their life. but if someone invites it, then you gotta respond. BTW, there is more Raja praising thread than bashing, and I dont mind the praise.. He deserves that if his fans believe that. But dnt bring othrs down for it.

We ca pray or do whtevr but its up to them to do it.. so lets wait and watch.. for both of them..
rudr_26 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#32

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka

Aisa thore hai ke sirf Aneek ki hi umar badhegi, 10 saal baad bhi Raja Aneek se 10 saal bara hoga. Phir kahoge abhi 10 saal baad Aneek Raja tak pahunchega. That is what I am saying, Aneek needs at least 10 years, but dont know the result. Mere hisaab se to Aneek abhi bachcha hai.



you did not get me, offcourse raja will be always older,😆 but, considering the age for avg playback singers, we can safely say he needs 6-7 yrs to grow older (Raja is already in that age).. let wait for at least that and then we jump to conclusion that who is doing better.. 😊
Purrrfect thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: rudr_26



Its funny of you that you did not see that who start comparing first. Mine was just a reaction of it as I am strictly against this comparison. If some persons doesnt understand straight way, then we have to show the crooked way to shut them off.


You also categorically overlooked where I said that " it takes more to be a playback singer,just not winning competition".. so dont jump on to guns before reading all.


I don't START comparing singers and success who are not in same scale or situation in their life. but if someone invites it, then you gotta respond. BTW, there is more Raja praising thread than bashing, and I dont mind the praise.. He deserves that if his fans believe that. But dnt bring othrs down for it.

We ca pray or do whtevr but its up to them to do it.. so lets wait and watch.. for both of them..

Rudr, I understand that you are supporting your favourite and are just reacting to the comments made here.
My question is, I wonder why Zee would allow children to compete in adult competition? They should have seperate competition - because once you are in a game, age does not matter.
Yes there has been more Raja Praising threads due to raja fans and not due to non raja fans.
By the way, If one fans take pride in Aneek doing shows - than I am happy for his fans.
I request Mods to kindly close this topic as this topic's intent is certainly no to compare the two.
Edited by Awww - 14 years ago
rudr_26 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: Awww

Rudr, I understand that you are supporting your favourite and are just reacting to the comments made here.
My question is, I wonder why Zee would allow children to compete in adult competition? They should have seperate competition - because once you are in a game, age does not matter.
Yes there has been more Raja Praising threads due to raja fans and not due to non raja fans.
By the way, If one fans take pride in Aneek doing shows - than I am happy for his fans.
I request Mods to kindly close this topic as this topic's intent is certainly no to compare the two.



the question was how one is after the show, not in the show(thats where the comparison began). So, one can be a part in a show at 16 yrs of age but it will be stupidity to compare a 30 yrs old singer and 18 yrs old in playback industry scenario (specially male), due to vocal constraints and different priorities in life.

Can you expect same life scenario/condition at 18 and 30? i bet not..

SRGMP was the similar platform for all of them, u just have to perform better not thinking much about voice or PR skills for example... but does play back industry is the same platform? strictly no... it takes lot to do playback simply bcoz of the dynamism of the industry..

I simply put all these singer in one category who are "struggling" to make of their own. everyone has to battle of his own.. some make it sooner, some later, some could not.. Show has nothing to do with it in long term..
rajucole thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#35

after aneek and raja, now dipanvita & rini v/s sniti, sugandhha and abhilasha. why the preceeding two were eliminated before public voting even tthey were also in top ten. this is not to pave way for winning of the later three female contestants!!!!!!!!! if winning really doesnot matter then why this partiality to show the preceeding two as mediore singers and the latters even having problems of some kind very talented???????? again controversial

music-a-muse thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: rajucole

after aneek and raja, now dipanvita & rini v/s sniti, sugandhha and abhilasha. why the preceeding two were eliminated before public voting even tthey were also in top ten. this is not to pave way for winning of the later three female contestants!!!!!!!!! if winning really doesnot matter then why this partiality to show the preceeding two as mediore singers and the latters even having problems of some kind very talented???????? again controversial


Raju bhayya,

Please rini aur sniti ko compare mat karo ek hi saans mein, two totally extreme ends of a spectrum😳
rajucole thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: musicmuse


Raju bhayya,

Please rini aur sniti ko compare mat karo ek hi saans mein, two totally extreme ends of a spectrum😳

where rini and sniti came!!!!!!!!! i am comparing preceeding two v/s present three. it ws judges decision not public decision when they were eliminated they were in top ten and were eliminated before pubic voting started to show clear pave the way for the present three so there should not be any female competitors.
Edited by rajucole - 14 years ago
music-a-muse thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: rajucole

where rini and sniti came!!!!!!!!! i am comparing preceeding two v/s present three. it ws judges decision not public decision when they were eliminated they were in top ten and were eliminated before pubic voting started to show clear pave the way for the present three so there should not be any female competitors.


ah ok ok!

my fault, sorry, i misunderstood😃
rajucole thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: musicmuse

ah ok ok! my fault, sorry, i misunderstood😃

it seems that from the very staring, channel made up their mind to keep the latters three so that one of them should win. most probably abhilasha or sniti.😊😊
Edited by rajucole - 14 years ago
biswita thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: Awww

I am reading all the comments of who should win and who should lose and ofcourse we'll always get lots of answers to that question as each one has their own taste for music. Everyone will write their favourites name in winning list....Personally I feel that winning and losing has never been a factor for one's success in music world. Personally I'd like to see Kamal and Sniti to win the tittle, but again I am not gonna stress myself out trying to justify why they should be winning as I know at the end of the day, what matters is talent being recognized by MD to help the singers get ahead.

You are right, it seldom matters who wins. These singers are treated as shadow/ghost singers to try out new songs for composers that are then recorded by established names. Zee uses them as cash cows to mint money with shows in US high school auditoriums. Welcome to Bolywood.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".