Ali Sher - Friday episode - Performance of Seasion

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

shekharfan

@shekharfan

Beginner

Posted: 14 years ago

#11

The Tiger stole the show! He was superb, I just love the passion and guts he shows.
He is the Nadal of srgmp - gifted with the energy of a street fighter😛, (Kamal is like Federer - smooth and stylish).
He also showed a subtle touch and range in his voice. Perhaps he needs more fine tuning, but I like my tiger wild 😉

Edited by shekharfan - 14 years ago

Quote

Ankit

@ankit_nyc

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: shekharfan
The Tiger stole the show! He was superb, I just love the passion and guts he shows.
He is the Nadal of srgmp - gifted with the energy of a street fighter😛, (Kamal is like Federer - smooth and stylish).
He also showed a subtle touch and range in his voice. Perhaps he needs more fine tuning, but I like my tiger wild 😉

Comparing Sher Ali to Nadal? 😃 In case you missed it, Nadal has won a bunch of championships and has proven himself already........Can Sher Ali win something and prove himself before we start comparing him to winners? 😕 The guy has not been near the top in any of the weeks.....In fact he has always been on the bottom week in and week out........😊

PS --- I don't remember seeing guts at all.....Stage pein jaakar to sab gaate hein....oos mein guts ki baat kaha aayi? 😊

Edited by ankit_nyc - 14 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

shekharfan

@shekharfan

Beginner

Posted: 14 years ago

#13

Think u missed the point. was talking about his energy and spirit which has won me over, not championships😕. Gotta give the guy credit where it's due👏 it was a bravura performance and there's no harm in appreciating. Try it, u might like it😉

Quote

Aaliyah

@-Aaliyah-

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#14

I don't think it was performance of the week material 🤔

Quote

citanuzuki16

@citanuzuki16

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#15

@ all
Ali Sher is the most underrated singer right now...
And all of you don't even realize his potential..
First of all, you all are saying that this season is bad...I think it better than Saregamapa 2007...Am talking upon a pure musical base that the contestants this year are better..
But the thing is that we have heard the likes of Raja, Amanat, Mussarat, Poonam and that Aneek way too much that its extremely difficult to get them out of our heads...But please do it...I'd like 2 talk about Ali Sher's 29th October performance and will like to tell you what things he performed which were sooo difficult to manage..
In the Alaap when he sung.. Kamli Kar Ke Chhadd Gyaan Maahiyaa...
The variation of the pitch there and the way he has given vibrato in the high notes...

The Sargam...which seemed quite easy to us...The singers here please give it a try once..U'll get know those surs are xtremely difficult....

The Antara which was the best part....The harkats there were Mindblowing..
The way he has recited Lammiaan Judaaiaan Sehke both the times...Its fantastic

And the way he has been playing with the Layam of the song...Woh nai suna kisi ne...
Par is bande ka Tadap Tadap ke zarur suna...
The way he played with the beat cycle with those variations is just fantastic...
Although we cant say that it was the performance of the season...

Quote

433796

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: citanuzuki16
@ all
Ali Sher is the most underrated singer right now...
And all of you don't even realize his potential..
First of all, you all are saying that this season is bad...I think it better than Saregamapa 2007...Am talking upon a pure musical base that the contestants this year are better..
But the thing is that we have heard the likes of Raja, Amanat, Mussarat, Poonam and that Aneek way too much that its extremely difficult to get them out of our heads...But please do it...I'd like 2 talk about Ali Sher's 29th October performance and will like to tell you what things he performed which were sooo difficult to manage..
In the Alaap when he sung.. Kamli Kar Ke Chhadd Gyaan Maahiyaa...
The variation of the pitch there and the way he has given vibrato in the high notes...

The Sargam...which seemed quite easy to us...The singers here please give it a try once..U'll get know those surs are xtremely difficult....

The Antara which was the best part....The harkats there were Mindblowing..
The way he has recited Lammiaan Judaaiaan Sehke both the times...Its fantastic

And the way he has been playing with the Layam of the song...Woh nai suna kisi ne...
Par is bande ka Tadap Tadap ke zarur suna...
The way he played with the beat cycle with those variations is just fantastic...
Although we cant say that it was the performance of the season...

I dont know all musical aspects, I even do not understand punjabi. But I observer all these harkatein, bareekiya etc, all those seems perfect to me. When I listen I try to catch if singer goes flat, besura, not clear, missing soul etc at tough part. I did not find a single moment where he went out of way.

Quote

Padmajaan

@Padmajaan

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#17

I totally agree. His singing is pure bliss and his rendition on this sufi number difficult to execute to perfection was simply breathtaking.

I really do not want him to be eliminated. His is the only truly hatke out of the ordinary and mundane voice and singing style this season. I love kamal also but ali sher can be pure sheer genious and also go horribly wrong. I like this about him.

Wish him all the success and I like his raw voice which can go completely crazy!!

Padma

Quote

music-a-muse

@music-a-muse

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#18

This may not be THE performance of the season, it is definitely ONE of the best of this season😊

There is something in his singing this song which just touched your heart, when you heard it the first time and you want to hear it again and again and again😃

Like i heard it about 50 times till now and don't mind hearing more of it😃

I definitely would not like him to leave the show soon, when we have had singers being consistently average in sur at least, and no one felt the need to comment on them😃 and they have been around since the beginning of the show😆

Quote

Ankit

@ankit_nyc

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: musicmuse
This may not be THE performance of the season, it is definitely ONE of the best of this season😊

There is something in his singing this song which just touched your heart, when you heard it the first time and you want to hear it again and again and again😃

Like i heard it about 50 times till now and don't mind hearing more of it😃

I definitely would not like him to leave the show soon, when we have had singers being consistently average in sur at least, and no one felt the need to comment on them😃 and they have been around since the beginning of the show😆

😕 If a whole lot of people felt the need to hear his song over and over again like you do then he wouldn't be in the bottom every week..........😕 The fact that he is in the bottom clearly shows how many people like to listen to him sing......Itna acha gaata hota to surely bottom mein nahin aata every week......Just because some people like a contestant doesn't make him the best......

Contest hein, jo jeeta wohi sikander.........If he is as good as you say let's see him do well in the show and also in the industry once he is out of the show..........tab jaake kuch prove hoga........