SNITI Super Singing - Page 4

Originally posted by: Summer3

Yep, anyway Vishal ji has toned down but I did not like the way he whacked Sher Ali.

Fortunately this week he made up for it again.

Originally posted by: Truemusiclover

When I listen scores of hindi songs I hardly remember lyrics of all of them. I get pleasure from the tune of the songs and the singer's execution of the songs and voice.. For scores of average listeners like me this is what matter. But for some people sh, s, z, h, etc. matter . When Sniti sings I can clearly listen and also write what words she says. But pronunciation can vary if one's mother tongue is not hindi. Like Westerners can listen to our English pronunciation and say we have diction problem of English.

Originally posted by: SunBright

@bold: Since I bought that up, Yes it does matter to me - here's why interchanging akshar is a problem because for me the feel and mood of the song comes with the lyrics and if a singer is singing a writing by say Gulzar and cannot do justice then ....😭😭😭

The same word said in many ways can change the meaning completely

S ehar : Means Dawn

Sh ehar : Means City/town

Z ehar : Means Venom

Originally posted by: SunBright

The same word said in many ways can change the meaning completely

S ehar : Means Dawn

Sh ehar : Means City/town

Z ehar : Means Venom

Originally posted by: Truemusiclover

I agree what you say here. But what I heard from Sniti there is no such major problem. She pronounces Shikwa as shikwa and not zikwa or any other word and difference between s and sh are very minor for non-hindi speaking people.

But I respect individual opinions.

Originally posted by: SlumGOD

Where is the difference?

Originally posted by: Truemusiclover

What difference ? Probably you misunderstood me My two sentences ". She pronounces Shikwa as shikwa and not zikwa or any other word" and " difference between s and sh are very minor for non-hindi speaking people. " are in different context and in reponse to Sunbright's explanation of S, sh & z

Actually the matter is " hum sab fans dussrein constestants ke khamiyan nikalne ke liye majboor hai Dusre nicha nahin dikhenge to apna favourite upar kaise dikhega"

Originally posted by: SlumGOD

You mean she does not have lisp? Or you mean she does have lisp but does not matter much as its a minor issue (s or sh)?

This issue has been discussed umpteen times..some people find problems, others dont..Whats the point in arguing abt that?? Whoever finds a problem, they have other favorites and we Sniti fans prefer Sniti's (lisped/not-lisped) singing to other singers who dont have lisp yet they fail to impress us.