My reaction to tonight's (U.S.) episode..

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

mamta_nayak

@mamta_nayak

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#21

Excellent observation Sandepa, Good job. I agree with everything you said. 👏 👏 👏

Quote

maya

@nutan

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#22

It seems to me that the better thing Z could have done was to out Rajiv instead of making this whole tie thing between Nihira and Hema. This way it would have been more believable because all three had yellow cards and the difference in the votes between them was not much.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

thespian

@thespian

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: riddler100

- 40 million votes and 2 singers with the exact same votes (comeon, what are the odds)

Actually, simple mathematics suggests that with 9.053% out of 40 lacs
(it's not 40 million), even if the difference
between their number of votes is 40, they will get the same % (to 3rd
decimal point). I mean if they got 9.0531 or 9.0534 and they rounded
off to the 3rd decimal point.

I find it really funny they are claiming they have the same number of
votes. Instead, They could have told about the rounding off to the 3rd
decimal point and sounded more credible.

Quote

usfan

@usfan

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#24

I too didn't like tonight's episode that much. Rajiv really messed up in group as well as solo. He was singing all mistakes...even Shaan has mentioned that he was not focusing much. I don't understand why they are dragging it more and more breaking the show rules. About Nihira & Hemachandra getting equal votes was just faked up completely (its nothing but a stunt put on). Even the whole show was completely planned just to drag it. I think a lot of people are voting with lack of any music knowledge and just with favoritism. The real good singers don't have to beg for votes at all. I liked Twinkle, Himani, Ujjaini, Debo & Paresh in yesterday's episode because they did some shaadi ka dance moves. All rest did nothing but simple singing I mean without realising that it was a shaadi ka sangeet episode. Nihira was just walking around in circles not lively at all...I didn't even like that. One thing I hated about Rajiv was holding the dholak and didn't even play (ofcourse it was a pre-recorded song but atleast while performing he should play it properly), but still he is getting lots of votes...from where God knows!! If anybody should have been eliminated yesterday it should have been Rajiv. He himself was shocked that he got more votes...he is been declaring that he is not a well trained singer...but just a cook and sings for fun...just like any of us...then why he himself not dropping out...is my question. In one episode even Twinkle (Twinkle is a very versatile singer and she should continue singing Asha Bhosle's songs than Narula's songs) mentioned that if she gets yellow one more time she had decided to leave on her own, why Rajiv is not doing that? He is not doing that because he has public votes in his favor but public is not realizing that their favoritism is making the elimination of good singers. Another thing if you have all noticed that Paresh & Ujjaini were originally eliminated in judges' rounds, they came back in Brahamastra, now they are getting greens in almost every episode since they came under HR's team and surviving very well (point to be noted)where as Sharib & Swananda who were good & music learned singers and voted by great judges have been eliminated already (public is doing this). My opinion is Gajendraji should bring superior judges to supercede the public votes. Vinit is a kid but getting lot of support from HR more than what he deserves. I am getting sick of the topi business too. Too much is too bad...hope HR will realize that before it is too late. Awaiting to see what happens tonight.

Quote

scorpion_king

@scorpion_king

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#25

Can someone upload the episode......

Thanks in advance

Edited by scorpion_king - 19 years ago

Quote

nonny

@nonny

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#26

Well yesterday's "Shaadi" episode was a total washout...simply failed to capture the festive flair & ambience of it 🤢.It was scripted to begin with courtsey the mighty "Gajraj"....whose musical rhapsody is fast losing its feet to the world of piracy & plagiarism 😡.The master manipulator always makes sure it's "His"way or the "High"way to be precise 😒to the ZEE channel.

The mentors are setting a new paradigm for museum exhibits 😆 HR treating Vinit as an image of "GOODWILL" reincarnated 😃 decked up in his fancy second hand attire....it might lead to our small wonder Vinit finally going "The Emperor's new clothes" way being left with nothing but his mentor HR's lucky "Underwear" 😆.So much for a new wardrobe!!Alas!HR has hit an alltime low with his histrionics! ,Lord help us for that.
Adesh was a bit restrained than usual but deliberate in his attempt to shun Himani whose perf was pretty average btw.ID was also aware of the outcome well in advance & his actions did not speak otherwise as intended (the way he lashed out at the public)...it was oh so predictable.

Overall the episode left a sour taste in the mouth & an uncontrollable urge to gulp down a whole bottle of "Tums"ta tum tum tum antacids 😆 at best.

Edited by nonny - 19 years ago

Quote

rausa

@rausa

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#27

Agreed...Votes were manipulated. But I don't mind, public is voting without listening, so one of the two best singers would have been out.

Of course, HR has gone crazy over Vinit. Now the public should be able to see the real HR. I guess he thinks he is just a mentor for Vinit, other two seem to be figuring out by themselves. Vinit is a good singer, but he is certainly not the end of the world.

The show overall was definitely low key, Twinkle & Rajeev as usual were horrible. The rest were all good. Though it seems some of them are getting tired. They need to get their energy back.

Quote

Sandeepa

@Naivedya

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 19 years ago

#28

Originally posted by: vidyaah
Iam also in US....so got to see the episode today...Was it my imagination or did anyone else also feel that the mentors looked really detached???

I have never seen AS so lost..I thk that they were informed abt the nihira, hem fixup before and were not to happy abt it...and as usual HR was there with his love for vinit...someday i hope HR will get down on his knees to propose to vinit...Gaj shd not...that wld make awesome reality show 😛

Tne entire show was dull even though it was supp to be shaadi theme...Twinkle started well, but she got lost very soon. Paresh, Vinit, Ujjaini were all ok. Nihira was good. Himani chose a beautiful song and did justice to it...Esp the line..ankhon main asoo aayee 😊 was done well. But the person who stole the show was Hemchandra.... SO much energy and cool in his voice even after getting yellow... 👏

Poor Rajeev....This is Shaan's first time to comment on a singers performance 😆 . Rajeev was horrible...Wtg to see the episode when he is out...

I agree with you 100% and love the comment about HR proposing! 😛

Quote

Maanas

@maanas

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#29

I guess if Nihira would have been voted out, Adesh and Ismail had planned to walk out of the show. Again this is just "Kahi suni batein" it may not be authentic. She is clearly one of the best participants and deserves to be in final 2.

Himesh continues his gimmicks of "Topi" episode after edisode and someone should tell him to just stop. Enough of Topi Tamasha.

I think he is trying to promote Vinit since he is aware he might get axed sometime in future. Hemachandra and Debojit and even Paresh are doing better than Vinit. It's not that Vinit is not a good singer but he is not mature enough to handle certain situations.

As far as Nihira is concerned, it would be totally unfortunate if she gets voted out. She is absolutely beyond comparison. Himani is good but again the clarity in voice and the knowledge of music....that's Nihira.

Cheers

Quote

Sandeepa

@Naivedya

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 19 years ago

#30

Originally posted by: nonny
Well yesterday's "Shaadi" episode was a total washout...simply failed to capture the festive flair & ambience 🤢.It was scripted to begin with courtsey the mighty "Gajraj"....whose musical rhapsody is fast losing its feet to the world of piracy & plagiarism 😡.The master manipulator makes sure it's "His"way or the "High"way to be precise 😒to the ZEE channel.

The mentors are setting a new paradigm for museum exhibits 😆 HR treating Vinit as an image of "GOODWILL" reincarnated 😃 decked up with his fancy second hand attire....it might lead to our small wonder Vinit finally going "The Emperor's new clothes" way being left with nothing but his mentor HR's "Underwear" 😆.So much for a new wardrobe!!Alas!HR has hit an alltime low with his histrionics! ,Lord help us!

Adesh was a bit restrained but deliberate in his attempt to shun Himani whose perf was pretty average btw.ID was also aware of the outcome well in advance & his actions did not speak otherwise as intended (the way he lashed out at the public)...it was oh so predictable.

Overall the episode left a sour taste in the mouth & an uncotrollable urge to gulp down a whole bottle of "Tums"ta tum tum tum antacids 😆 at best.

I agree with all your comments and love you sarcastic review 😆 however, the only thing I disagreed with was that Himani sang average. I thought she and Hema gave the best performances.

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6

My reaction to tonight's (U.S.) episode.. - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics