article on saregama vs fame gurukul

lalit1 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

TELE SCOPE
Singing along in their fifteen minutes
The media does not confer just two minutes of fame on unsuspecting people like us. It's far more generous



Whoever said it was dreadfully mistaken. The media does not confer just two minutes of fame on unsuspecting people like us. It's far more generous: you can bask in its camera lights for hours, days, even months. And it does not discriminate against the poor, the old, the infirm, colour, caste, creed or gender. Ask old Kunjilal of Betul, Madhya Pradesh, who held the media spellbound for several hours with a fake death threat; ask Karisma Kapoor who can be within a few kilometres of husband Sunjay (like she was last week at a polo ground) or hundreds of miles away (like in Mumbai) and the media records the distance her marriage has travelled; ask Qazi from Kashmir who endeared himself to the media (and viewers) ever since he first sauntered into Fame Gurukul last June with that thing under one eye.

No sooner had Kunjilal faded from the screen than Qazi — along with the other Gurukul winner Rooprekha — replaced him. First, the two were declared Jodi No.1 on Sony's singing talent hunt contest, next they were a duet on Aaj Tak in what seemed like a never-ending love song. To say nothing of sporting loser Rex, who, although looked like he would like to burst into tears and tear Qazi away from Rooprekha's side, instead sang Kal Ho Na Ho for Roop and something patriotic for the nation in that hoodwinking style popularised by Rajesh Khanna during the seventies.

< name="mail_to" value="shailajabajpai@expressindia.com" ="">< value="Singing along in their fifteen minutes" name="subject" ="">< method="post" ="http://community.expressindia.com/mail/colu mnist_feedback. php" target="feedback" name="mail_">
Send your comments to the columnist
Name
< name="name" size="15" ="text">
Your E-Mail
< name="email" size="15" ="text">
Your Comments
< name="message" cols="15" rows="10">
It needs to be said that while Rooprekha sounds like she knows how to sing if not speak Hindi, Qazi and Rex and many others chasing Fame at Gurukul, were a little superior to bathroom singers. Sorry, but the performances on Indian Idol and Fame Gurukul have been off key. Nothing to crow about, if you see what we mean.

There's plenty of drama on these shows but it is, as Rex once said, actually about singing and Sony's producers should take a crash course from Zee which features contestants who literally know their Sa Re Ga Ma and Pa.

One man who does not like to sing for the media is Saddam Hussein. He stared malevolently into the camera during last week's televised trial as though he was looking straight at President Bush. Frankly? He reminded one of Kunjilal: more dead than alive, more alive than living.

Varun Gandhi did not look entirely comfortable giving Stephen Sackur stare for stare during Hard Talk (BBC World). He was expressionless as though the effort to concentrate on his studiously-careful replies robbed him of all motor responses. It might happen to you too, if you had to make statements such as ''My father (Sanjay Gandhi) had nothing to do with the Emergency''. Varun was asked about Sonia's foreign issue, his relationship with cousins Priyanka and Rahul, his father, his grandmother and each reply left you none the wiser about his genuine opinion on any of these individuals. Would have liked to hear more about his thoughts on BJP and the merry leadership dance or Advani's Jinnah remark but Sackur appeared interested only in Varun's Gandhi DNA. More's the pity.

Rahul Gandhi cropped up again when P.Chidambaram appeared on the show. He was asked about Rahul as Prime Minister to which he gave an enigmatic Mona Lisa smile and said Rahul belonged to the next generation - of what? Prime Ministers?

The Bihar elections' first round of polling did not excite much enthusiasm in the newsrooms. That's curious; normally, elections are an occasion for maximum TV coverage. Maybe Laloo Yadav's charm (unlike those sturdy vests he wears) has worn thin. The one channel to display boundless energy for the race to Patna was, believe it or not, DD News. Bihar Ka Faisla was a special on the polling and the trends. DD took Laloo seriously enough to employ independent broadcasters - former Sahara hands, Shireen and Aroop - to anchor the proceedings. However, it was a DD News' correspondent (think his name is Subodh) whose lucid, informative reports enlivened the long telecasts. Goes to show, you don't always need outside help.

Edited by lalit1 - 19 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

2

Views

1k

Users

3

Frequent Posters

Aries23 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: Trafalgar

very well said ... i watched the last 2 episodes of FG ... (its only recently i got the access to sony in UK) ... it was awful ... overly dramatic in its content ... and utterly disappointing ... quality of singers ... less said the better ... i dont understand what was all the hoopla about FG ... if its cacophony for the sake of it ... thumbs up ... if its to create a few talented singers ... thumbs down ... and if one expectes this fame jodi to last longer than an album (produced by soni) and longer than an year ... welcome to bet with me !!! what say

very well said 👏

ykohli thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3

I agree with you.FG stands nowhere close to sare ga ma pa.i just happened to see a few episodes of FG & was really disgusted at the contents,constant fights,back bitting,low quality of singing shown in the serial.

sare ga ma pa is so soothing to ears..no politics,no childish ego clashes..just pure sweet music..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".