Top 5 worst judges of all time? - Page 5

Originally posted by: oldblackjoe

Alka- good
javed- good
shankar - good
v/s - good when not judging kishore clones who sing rd burman songs.
bappi- bad
jatin- horrible
anu kapoor - bad
abhijeet - horrible
himesh - bad
lalit - bad
aadesh - bad
pritam - horrible
shreya - bad
kunal - bad/good
sonali -horrible
anu malik - bad
kailash kher - good/bad
kavita - bad
amit kumar - bad but good sumtimes
sudesh bhonsle -good
ismail - horrible
sukhi - bad
monty - horrible
farah - bad
sonu - good
kk- good
shaan -good
sanu -good
udit - bad

agree with all except Farah (I think she's horrible!) and Shreya.. I think she's pretty good (but I didn't watch the whole season of CU so maybe I missed something). And is Sanu really a good judge? lol, I didn't watch WP but I just assumed he would be a bad judge. I didn't like it in C2005 when he chose Twinkle over Himani.

Originally posted by: shehzaadi91

agree with all except Farah (I think she's horrible!) and Shreya.. I think she's pretty good (but I didn't watch the whole season of CU so maybe I missed something). And is Sanu really a good judge? lol, I didn't watch WP but I just assumed he would be a bad judge. I didn't like it in C2005 when he chose Twinkle over Himani.

hey atleast u dont think she's good lol!!

i wont forgive her for giving harshit ten for kal ho na ho.

hmmm

Originally posted by: preethi_p_r

hmmm

I would give

anu malik - Horrible .( he is too biased personality wise , in the audition round so many good singers where not selected because their looks dint please this man !)

Javed Aktar -Bad ( jumps to conclusions very quickly and thinks janta is dumb, also once when Raja hassan sang excellently he said it was bad 😲 I guess his ears are tuned to the below average singing on II )

yeah he think only the junta is wrong..

anu is a real case.