Created

Last reply

Replies

41

Views

3.8k

Users

15

Frequent Posters

akanna thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: vireshdesi

i want asma to win because overall combo of singing and looks.she is the most cute and sexy.do you want ugly vaishali to become your idol.india does not have a singer who is good looking like asma.she can be compared to britney spears of india because she is 17 and good looking.she looks perfect for music videos.imagine vaishali in a hot music video. all contestants except asma are ugly and fat. if you vote for asma you can see her all your life in india and bollywood and maybe also in a bikini.

"Beauty lies in the eyes of the beholder" - and music is heard, not seen. We have umpteen excellent professional dancers in India who can dance with Vaishali's music on stage, and no one will bother how she looks. Her voice and talent are superb enough to make up for what she looks like. The same goes for the music videos too - it's not always the singers who act in them. Are all the cricket players handsome? Yet they are idols for India's younger generation - so it's not the looks but the talent is what matters. 😃
BTW, Asma isnt Indian and so she would not be representing India even if she wins. We have enough excellent singers who are truly Indian to be Britney Spears of India - she can be the BS of Middle East. And she is not as hot or sexy as Alka or many other pop singers in India. And no, thanks, I am not interested in seeing Asma in a bikini, not even in a morphed image!! Seeing like that all my life - is she going to stay like that for the rest of her life or what?! Prathibha is cuter than Asma and she isnt fat either. We also had Mitika who is hotter than Asma and better sweeter voice too. 😛 😆
akanna thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Summer3

Akkanaji pl take it easy with dec21.😆 Her birthday is next month I think.

😃 Some people need to do some research at least on the internet before saying things about our movie plus music industry. Indian movie industry is even in the guinness book of records, as the largest movie production in the world. 😃
I dont get it as to how Bollywood will be recognized globally by making Asma win, such that Americans and Chinese will start to watch Hindi movies and listen to Hindi songs?! It would not even appear in the local/regional media in these countries. And I dont think they are going to even care about it. If Miss India becomes Miss Universe/World, or if our actors or singers act or sing in Hollywood movies or music shows, or if our music composers and/or singers win the grammy, of if our movies win Oscar, then I understand how good it will be for Indian movie/music industry. What has Asma winning SRGMP got to do with it?!!
v12345 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: vireshdesi

i want asma to win because overall combo of singing and looks.she is the most cute and sexy.do you want ugly vaishali to become your idol.india does not have a singer who is good looking like asma.she can be compared to britney spears of india because she is 17 and good looking.she looks perfect for music videos.imagine vaishali in a hot music video. all contestants except asma are ugly and fat. if you vote for asma you can see her all your life in india and bollywood and maybe also in a bikini.


i agree with Akanna.
I think your watching a wrong family show. 😆
This show is a hunt for new talented singer and not model or super model or actress.😆 I dont think your from India and stop pretending Indian. India has many singer who are good looking and we dont want Asma who doesnt fit as bollywood singer yet.
Pratibha is cute and good looking and her image is as simple and humble girl this what we are looking for.




vireshdesi thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#24
you guys are racist to other countries that you dont want asma to win. by the way you nris all live in foreign countries like usa uk uae and when a foreigner comes to india you cant stand them winning and want fellow indians to win.you guys have no problem in participating in reality shows in foreign countries.imagine how you would felt when all contestants teased asma on 24th october if you were teased when living in a foreign country. when shilpa shetty was teased in uk all indians attacked uk and jade goody.there are 10 lakh indians living in oman and 1 crore indians in gulf of arabia .i myself am an indian living in switzerland but cant face these comments on asma. it is because of these gulf and foreign countries that gave indians excess of jobs in 80s and 90s when there was unemployment in india that india has money to start reality shows like saregamapa and produce 100 movies a year in bollywood and you cant see a foreigner who is trying hard to sing hindi songs even get a spot in the finals.it shows that you still have backward indian thinking even though we are living in 21st century.
apux thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#25
I could care less if Asma was from India, Korea, or Mars...The reason I don't want her to win is because she is not the best singer, in my opinion....I loved Amanat Ali in the last challenge and I wanted him to win because I thought he deserved to win....
akanna thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: apux

I could care less if Asma was from India, Korea, or Mars...The reason I don't want her to win is because she is not the best singer, in my opinion....I loved Amanat Ali in the last challenge and I wanted him to win because I thought he deserved to win....

Well said. 👏 I agree with you, and I oppose Asma being the winner for the same reason.
akanna thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: vireshdesi

you guys are racist to other countries that you dont want asma to win. by the way you nris all live in foreign countries like usa uk uae and when a foreigner comes to india you cant stand them winning and want fellow indians to win.you guys have no problem in participating in reality shows in foreign countries.imagine how you would felt when all contestants teased asma on 24th october if you were teased when living in a foreign country. when shilpa shetty was teased in uk all indians attacked uk and jade goody.there are 10 lakh indians living in oman and 1 crore indians in gulf of arabia .i myself am an indian living in switzerland but cant face these comments on asma. it is because of these gulf and foreign countries that gave indians excess of jobs in 80s and 90s when there was unemployment in india that india has money to start reality shows like saregamapa and produce 100 movies a year in bollywood and you cant see a foreigner who is trying hard to sing hindi songs even get a spot in the finals.it shows that you still have backward indian thinking even though we are living in 21st century.

When NRIs particiapte in reality shows in their resident nations, it is usually in Indian reality shows, like SRGMP USA or Middle East, and the like. Honestly Shilpa's case didnt bother me much, as bollywood actresses get teased and ridiculed in India too. None of us agree that it was right for other contestants to tease Asma about her family issues - if you look through the topics on that, you can see that even those who didnt like her singing did not support that.
I agree that Indians got employment opportunities in USA, UK, Middle East, etc. It was a mutual deal - they needed people and we needed jobs. But that should not be paid back by making Asma a winner. They didnt create jobs for Indians either, and Indians dont get any discounts - we compete with the locals unlike many other races who have concessions. We pay taxes and work towards the progress of those countries as well. BTW, India was producing hundreds of movies a year even before these jobs were given to NRIs. And more money came after International companies in US, Europe and all started to invest in India as part of offshoring and outsourcing.
If Asma should get a spot in the finals based on the point of being a foreigner trying to sing Hindi songs, then we should bring foreigners from all over the world into the show and there would be several others among those who would be way better than Asma. Indians are treated very badly in many places outside India, including Middle East. But did we treat her the same way in India - no. So how can you even compare the situation?!
Edited by akanna - 16 years ago
khan-hk thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: dec21

asma deserves to be in top 7.she got history for sufi and kawali rounds.sara and yashita got only superhit for both these rounds.asmas voice suits for these rounds because these are simlar to arab music.her voice is not that good for fast beats and melody.if she wins saregama she can record a sufi or kawali album .her father is a famous arab singer so music is not new to her. we need her to win as her victory will make bollywood and indian music a big global industry.bollywood is now only watched by indians and people of indian origin.there are few hindi speaking arabs and other foreigners like american,chinese outside india. if she wins more foreigners will watch bollywood and listen to indian muic.more foreigners will participate in indian reality shows and migrate to india.bollywood will become bigger than hollywood.

i totally agree with you..i dont think that aasma is that bad as ppl make it sound in here...her voice is good and it suits sufi and qawali songs...but yeah she is not that good for fast beats but i am sure she will learn it...she has improved trhough the show there is a huge difference in her voice 9if you see some of the first epi and compare them to now....
vireshdesi thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#29
ok so akkana you are saying that asma does not deserve to be in srgmp so how did shilpa shetty win uk big brother without completing a single task .you are saying that india treats foreigners nicely and are fair but why did indias biggest channel zee tv air footage of asma being teased by contestants when they could prevent it. if there was honesty in voting in india you would not put up this forum of results being rigged for asma by zee tv.the doubt of rigging exists in your backward indian mind because you cant accept that asma has got votes. asma has got the votes she deserved from india and middle east for people who love her innocence and truthfulness combined with singing and looks.she is perfect combo and can be an idol for india rather than yashita or sara who backstabbed their best freind asma by teasing her on srgmp 24th october but asma still forgived both of them.
v12345 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: vireshdesi

ok so akkana you are saying that asma does not deserve to be in srgmp so how did shilpa shetty win uk big brother without completing a single task .you are saying that india treats foreigners nicely and are fair but why did indias biggest channel zee tv air footage of asma being teased by contestants when they could prevent it. if there was honesty in voting in india you would not put up this forum of results being rigged for asma by zee tv.the doubt of rigging exists in your backward indian mind because you cant accept that asma has got votes. asma has got the votes she deserved from india and middle east for people who love her innocence and truthfulness combined with singing and looks.she is perfect combo and can be an idol for india rather than yashita or sara who backstabbed their best freind asma by teasing her on srgmp 24th october but asma still forgived both of them



First of all mind your language and second Stop pretending Indian and Please this forum is very peaceful place dont spoil it by bringing hatred over here. We dont want war.

People are not opposing Asma as a person, She is cute and bring charm to the show. Its about singing talent. It doesnt matter whether somebody from India, Pakistan, or even Oman wins, until he or she is a good singer. There is no doubt Asma is competiting against the best and hats off to her, but she has long way to go to be a winner.
About Asma controversy, Yashita and Sara expressed their feeling in better manner then other guys like Debo or Sujat on the show, there is no doubt who is the weakest contestant. Pratibha did not say anything to Asma. Its comes to individual who want to be highlighted on screen.

India treats foreigner nicely and those footage was shown to clear the misunderstanding or whatever its zee channel to think about.

India is still a safe and peaceful place where people from Pakistan still come to show talent irrespective of so many wars between them. India always treat foreigner with respect and you shouldnt have doubt in it if u were Indian. "Atithi devo bhava -Guest is alway treated as God in every house."

The most important thing Music has no religion and no boundaries.




Edited by v12345 - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".