Sara Raza Khan - coming up nicely - Page 2

Originally posted by: Martand

She was singing like she had Elaichi in her mouth and she was singing while chewing on it..

Originally posted by: Summer3

Thanks for the feedback on her singing. I did not hear the original before. Still I believe Sara can brush up after a few practise rounds and come in very strong.

Originally posted by: Megha25

In Kabhi Aar Kabhi Paar the energy was missing due to scale problems. In my opinion everything was sung in relatively the same loud pitch, this made the high notes barely distinguishable. If you hear the original you will notice that the main appeal of this song lies in its scale transitions.

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

Kabhi aar kabhi paar is sung by Shamshad Beghum, her voice suits this sort of peppy songs. MD here is O P Naiyyar and he was famous for his strong earthy rhythms, this song also has pretty good rhythm and then the lyrics are simply GREAT.
This song doesn't have too many chords/scale change.

Well in my opinioin this is not scale change, there are two basic chords only here and scale is same.

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

Well in my opinioin this is not scale change, there are two basic chords only here and scale is same.

Originally posted by: Megha25

Ok your entitled to your opinion but your misreading what I wrote and I don't like being misinterpretated 👎🏼.

Saying "scale is same" doesn't make much sense here because I was referring to the rising scale which repeats itself over and over again each time the mukra is sung. It occurs more than once throughout the song hence I used "scale transitions" not "SCALES transitions."

I also never said that the song Kabhi Aar Kabhi Paar was not a great song. Sara's rendition of it was not as great as it could have been.

Do read what I wrote correctly next time before jumping to any conclusions.

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

Even if what you are saying is correct this is not the kind of language I would use for any one, we should be sensitive to each other. I only politely disagreed and gave my POV why this song is great, not with intention to demean any one, any way I walk out of this thread, carry on.