adults on this show need to behave better.. - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

3.3k

Users

14

Likes

19

Frequent Posters

sahichal thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
Azmat in matches is better than Nitin.Niladri is complete singer. Nitin is weakest in four.
In competition , Although versatility is positive pointyet, singer can sing his favorite songs which
will be negative point during jugalbandi or judges choice round.
In whole song of nitin, while ignoring all mistakes, his song was ok when he added one or two heart touching harkatein or burkiyan. Now public is confused and they followed judges comments who had no dare to point out any mistake from song of nitin. It is not only against competition rules but also against progress of kid.

when Nitin sang out of his genre, following problems came:
1. Imraan could not enjoy the song
2. Only one time, Javed could dare to say that Nitin could sing better as range was low.
3. Jatin felt the harkatein as FLAT AT VERY IMPORTANT PLACE.
4. His song was declared best only twice. 5. He was eliminated.
6. He sings in low range and almost all songs were from his comfort zone.
Simultaneously , Javed always pointed out that niladri is singing songs of manna dey which is absolutely wrong. Only Niladri sang all types of songs beautifully. I am fan of azmat so, I do not try to note mistakes and I just enjoy.
Edited by sahichal - 13 years ago
JasToronto thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: sahichal

Azmat in matches is better than Nitin.Niladri is complete singer. Nitin is weakest in four.
In competition , Although versatility is positive pointyet, singer can sing his favorite songs which
will be negative point during jugalbandi or judges choice round.
In whole song of nitin, while ignoring all mistakes, his song was ok when he added one or two heart touching harkatein or burkiyan. Now public is confused and they followed judges comments who had no dare to point out any mistake from song of nitin. It is not only against competition rules but also against progress of kid.

when Nitin sang out of his genre, following problems came:
1. Imraan could not enjoy the song
2. Only one time, Javed could dare to say that Nitin could sing better as range was low.
3. Jatin felt the harkatein as FLAT AT VERY IMPORTANT PLACE.
4. His song was declared best only twice. 5. He was eliminated.
6. He sings in low range and almost all songs were from his comfort zone.
Simultaneously , Javed always pointed out that niladri is singing songs of manna dey which is absolutely wrong. Only Niladri sang all types of songs beautifully. I am fan of azmat so, I do not try to note mistakes and I just enjoy.

Good day sahichal,
You are one of the biggest fan of Azmat.😊
Unfortunately I don't agree with your point of view. Niladri is a nice kid and very good singer but he needs to develop his own style. Its okay to sing Manna Day sahab's songs but he sounds like his Xerox copy which goes agaist him.
Nitin started his srgmp journey singing Sukhvinder Sing's songs but when Alkaji pointed out, he immideately changed his style.
In my view, Nitin is one of the best singers we have on the show this year. His lower notes as well as higher notes are perfect and he always sings in original scale which is Sonne pe Suhaga.
Azmat is an another cute little boy and he is very good in his age group. I'm sure that he will become a great future singer but at this point in time he is little too weaker than Salman and Nitin but it does't mean that Azmat can't win this competition.
san2471 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: sahichal

Azmat in matches is better than Nitin.Niladri is complete singer. Nitin is weakest in four.
In competition , Although versatility is positive pointyet, singer can sing his favorite songs which
will be negative point during jugalbandi or judges choice round.
In whole song of nitin, while ignoring all mistakes, his song was ok when he added one or two heart touching harkatein or burkiyan. Now public is confused and they followed judges comments who had no dare to point out any mistake from song of nitin. It is not only against competition rules but also against progress of kid.

when Nitin sang out of his genre, following problems came:
1. Imraan could not enjoy the song
2. Only one time, Javed could dare to say that Nitin could sing better as range was low.
3. Jatin felt the harkatein as FLAT AT VERY IMPORTANT PLACE.
4. His song was declared best only twice. 5. He was eliminated.
6. He sings in low range and almost all songs were from his comfort zone.
Simultaneously , Javed always pointed out that niladri is singing songs of manna dey which is absolutely wrong. Only Niladri sang all types of songs beautifully. I am fan of azmat so, I do not try to note mistakes and I just enjoy.

You have the right to your opinion and you can be anyone's fan, that is your personal choice but going on a tirade against a kid participant is not a great thing to do. Concentrate on the positives of whoever you like and dont waste time trying to figure out the others.
I completely disagree with you. Jatin did not find his song flat, all he said was Niladri's touched his heart. He has been the most consistent throughout, complete singer, everyone has said that he is ready for playback at 14 years which is an achievement by itself. The fact is that he is comfortable with all the songs. I did not know that Sukhvinder Singh's songs are at low range...hope you heard it properly. Imran can hardly act and who cares for his opinion on music anyway and if you remember Shahid Kapoor wanted to modify the Mausam song to add the parts Nitin sang.
san2471 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: pinkcarnation

Just because KK didn't agree with Jatin's decision does not mean that Jatin can go on a tirade. The reason they're called judges is so they can say their opinions. I was very happy with KK calling out the other judges on being diplomatic. Why do that? Just say who sung better. It's really not that hard.

BTW, Nitin sung those songs much better than Niladri or Azmat. He deserved to win the matches.
Also, versatility is overrated. Who cares??? Every artist has their niche and many artists make their money by singing a particular type of song. Salman can earn a name by singing his type of songs, he doesn't need to go out of his way to change.
Just my two cents.

Absolutely, you hit the nail on the head
..ashu thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15
yes, Jatin took wrong decision while eliminating niladri instead of Nitin. KK was right on that day. Nitin is weakest.
san2471 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: ..ashu

yes, Jatin took wrong decision while eliminating niladri instead of Nitin. KK was right on that day. Nitin is weakest.

Sorry...Nitin is the strongest
..ashu thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#17
IRYO
but
I am still.
Let us c whch way d wind blows.
urvash thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18
I admire KK for fighting for standing up to these people. They were good in their days - good for them. They do not have an inkling on how to respond to children, they treated them as grown up professionals. Its not about the competition, its about helping these children make it big some day. I remember Ashaji on one of the SAREGAMA's - she was so humble - she cried with the contestants. If someone as big as her can be so humble - they others should do the same. KK is an international star - I wish him all the best.
vickosh thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#19
Adults unfortunately come with egos and issues with other adults on the show. They really come just for themselves and not for what they are actulaly asked to come for. They are there to teach the children music. They are not there to tell others how great they are. Why are you taking about yourself in the first place??? Dont tell one child her is way better than another child who is on the stage. I felt very sad for Nitin on that day. Jatin took Niladari in the front of the stage to say that he is so much better than Nitin. These things should not happen. Even if Nitin is older by a few years he is still a kid and does not need this treatment. Azmet looked very upset the whole show. He just could not handle being compared with others. That I think is because they praise him too much. He is good but has a lot of shortcomings and if he was corrected all the time he would have by now known that he also needs to improve and is not perfect. But her is told that he is way too good all the time when in fact her needs to know that he is not perfect.
The bottom line is that the kids are abused on this show...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".