Disappointing winner (what a joke) - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

5k

Users

13

Likes

66

Frequent Posters

skar1984 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: nileshni679


I totally agree with you even if we look at Isis she was much better than Gagan. Ridham is the best ⭐️



My heart goes out to Ridham - he is very talented and from what little I understand his singing is pretty crisp and neat - WAY neater than Gagan.

I have to agree though with the song selection and judges commentary for Ridham - I don't know how they pick/assign songs but I feel like Ridham wasn't always given good songs to show case his range/versatility - not like how Keshav, Aishwarya, Antra, Arunita were - i feel like those kids were given more variety of songs to show case their versatility.

Another thing I noticed is when judges/maha guru gave comments - they all said good things but I don't feel like they connected with him to the point where they would motivate/critique his songs to help him grow as a singer. For example there was an episode a few weeks ago where Keshav sang well but he had no energy/expression and Shaan called him out on it and took it as a coaching opportunity to say - u can sing a song and hit the notes but unless u put feelings or energy it sounds flat. I don't recall any such instance with Ridham - obviously they don't think he's perfect coz if he was he would have gotten more "karak kakram kakris".

I really feel for Ridham - for those of you who may not know - he was also apart of Voice of Punjab's chota champ competition where also he made it to top 5 but then did not make it to top 3. I was hoping he'd at least place in top 3 (he is very much deserving of it) on Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Li'l Champs.

I don't feel THAT bad for Arunita becoz she actually won the Zee Bangla Sa Re Ga Ma Pa li'l champ 2013/2014. So i'm not terribly sad that she didn't win 1rst place but I am surprised that both the top 2 talented kids Arunita and Ridham didn't place in top 3.

In the 3 that did make it to the top - Aishwariya, Keshav and Gagan - i think Aishwarya should have one the title between those 3, then Keshav then Gagan.

I'm inclinded to think that the whole results were fixed - I don't have a good motive for them to place the kids in this order other than political reasons.
Arunita and Aishwarya are both from bengal - Shaan, Monali are both bengali and Alka is from Calcutta originally - alot of past season winners were girls from Bengal - Anamika Choudhury, SAncheyeta, Sreya etc AND Arunita already won the regional title - so Arunita got skipped.
RIdham - somehow didn't seem to connect or create a soft spot with the judges - side note I actually don't like how they made fun of his english - kid wants to learn - but they'd make him speak in broken english and laugh - that's mean.
Keshav somehow was Alka's favorite - or I should say she saw talent in him and wanted him to hone in on it - being Bihari Zee got more views/ TRP from Bihar?
Gagan winning - going by my theory - being south indian - it could have been a political strategy to get more viewership from the south?

OR the other theory is (assuming the votes were counted properly and no fixing/cheating took place) that Gagan won on sympathy votes - everyone knows Arunita and Ridham are good - top contenders so a lot of ppl voted for Keshav/Gagan assuming everyone else was voting for Arunita and Ridham?

Who knows - either way the results are truly disappointing.
Edited by skar1984 - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".