Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

2.4k

Users

9

Likes

19

Frequent Posters

Megha1.1 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#21
So Shreyan is having his exams so he didn't perform this week too. Its good that he is balancing his studies too.
But still its doesn't change the fact that he is not performing in the show which he is still part of while other contestants are still performing. From coming week when voting will start, everyone would think before voting that should they vote for him. Because when other kids were performing, Shreyan was not there.
In earlier time reality shows when somebody used to not perform for any xyz reasons their score used to be zero. Which has resulted in elimination of many good contestants in many reality show. If one is part of any competition then they should follow the rules of the competition.
If we think from Shreyan's point of view, I agree that this kid is facing lot of pressure. And is working very hard to manage both show wand studies.
But then think of other contestants too, they have left everything along with their studies and are giving 100% to the show. So it is unfair with them.
I follow this show from the beginning and I love all kids equally. I remember in starting of the show everybody said they all kids are amazing and everyone loves all kids equally. So we should think of other kids too who have given everything to this competition..
jenny156 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#22
Shreyan has reduced his chances of winning anyway!! So please stop blaming on the kid!! It is the show that has messed up with the extension & yes it is unfair for other kids but what is his fault in here? It won't be unfair for other kids anyway coz he won't be winning after these breaks.. Maybe call it unfair if he even does win!! That's all I have to say for now!!
jenny156 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#23
Same question was raised in Shreyan's page by a fan and Shreyan's dad replied this.. Translating from bengali:

"Do you know when is the finale of this show? It is on 20 Sept.. That is why we brought him back home for few days to give his exams as that is also an important duty for us. Hence we are very thankful to the channel for giving him the break. We don't know what other parents are deciding for their kids it is upto them what they want to decide."

Now say what is wrong if his parents brought him home to give his exams? If the finale has now almost 2 more months to go and exams are in between then should they make him fail? It is unfair for other kids because they are still participating but who knows what if someone else has exams later and takes the break? Then blame that kid too? Now the channel is not mentioning about this because then their extension will be blamed!! That is why they are quiet.

And if voters decide not to vote for him because he has been away or he gets less number of badges, nothing can be done.. Or even if he gets criticized for this, because according to me his parents did nothing wrong !!

Also lastly, someone tell me which kid even showed any improvement in Shreyan's absence? Other than getting the badges? I can only see improvement in Sonakshi and Riya.. Adnan too but he was unfairly axed out !! Otherwise it is all the same whether Shreyan is there or not. Everyone is singing in their zone with only exception of Riya, and Sonakshi who is trying new styles and difficult songs.. There is no competition now anyway, yes the kids are working hard which will be beneficial for them in the competition!! So just let it be!!
Edited by jenny156 - 8 years ago
jenny156 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: divya17.8

So there is lot of discussion going around due to shreyan's absence.

I feel that this absence is definitely going to affect him. We all are there in this forum and on social networking sites so we know the reason about shreyan's absence. We know he is having exams. But think about the people who are not aware of social media. How will they know the reason of his absence. They would interpret it according to their thinking. Many would think shreyan is being given additional exemption. While others are working hard every week shreyan is being given breaks in between. Different people will interpret it differently.
It's channel duty to mention reason if one of the contestant is not performing. I hope they mention it when he will return.


Exactly and the channel will not mention it because then their extension will get blamed!!
People will say kids need to take breaks to give exams due to the extension!! So they are quiet !!
jenny156 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Megha1.1

So Shreyan is having his exams so he didn't perform this week too. Its good that he is balancing his studies too.

But still its doesn't change the fact that he is not performing in the show which he is still part of while other contestants are still performing. From coming week when voting will start, everyone would think before voting that should they vote for him. Because when other kids were performing, Shreyan was not there.
In earlier time reality shows when somebody used to not perform for any xyz reasons their score used to be zero. Which has resulted in elimination of many good contestants in many reality show. If one is part of any competition then they should follow the rules of the competition.
If we think from Shreyan's point of view, I agree that this kid is facing lot of pressure. And is working very hard to manage both show wand studies.
But then think of other contestants too, they have left everything along with their studies and are giving 100% to the show. So it is unfair with them.
I follow this show from the beginning and I love all kids equally. I remember in starting of the show everybody said they all kids are amazing and everyone loves all kids equally. So we should think of other kids too who have given everything to this competition..


If other kids gave their everything to the competition then Shreyan is no less.. He has been the most consistent from the very beginning!! Here he is managing two things together.. And how can we know how much every kid is working hard backstage? We cannot judge just by seeing what is shown.. And it is upto every kid and his/her parent what they want to do.. Just because he goes away for few days, he is being ridiculed!!
jenny156 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#26
Copy pasting from the chat thread..

So Shreyan's dad replied to the question raised on Shreyan's absence being unfair for other kids.. He said that the show was supposed to be for 3 months, but now it is upto 7-8 months which has really created problems in our schedules.. Since these episodes were not important, we requested the channel to give him the break so that he could give his exams.. And Shreyan is not the only one taking a break.. Other kids too got breaks.. Only that Shreyan got few days more.. Now since challenger episodes will be shown, the current kids are taking a break and enjoying their holidays.. Anyways, his full family including Shreyan was hurt by such a comment..

So I think now there is no doubt left.. It is not being unfair for any of the kids now.. Good that they are getting their much deserved break !!
Edited by jenny156 - 8 years ago
naq5 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#27
i don think it is fair to blame shreyan if he has exams. he may be having early exams than the rest so needed a break earlier. anyway the other kids will take a break when challengers come.
and its not shreyans fault if he decides to give his studies importance too & praise others if they want to give more importance to the show. he is anyway MIA n will not be in the sight of people to vote for him. longer break & he will have to start all over again & sing exceptionally well to get more votes. he has decided to take the risk for his studies & i still believe the show lacks lusture without him. im quite bored with yumna and smps performance. droon too is in only one zone. the show needs shreyan
jenny156 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: naq5

i don think it is fair to blame shreyan if he has exams. he may be having early exams than the rest so needed a break earlier. anyway the other kids will take a break when challengers come.

and its not shreyans fault if he decides to give his studies importance too & praise others if they want to give more importance to the show. he is anyway MIA n will not be in the sight of people to vote for him. longer break & he will have to start all over again & sing exceptionally well to get more votes. he has decided to take the risk for his studies & i still believe the show lacks lusture without him. im quite bored with yumna and smps performance. droon too is in only one zone. the show needs shreyan


Yes you are right, the show definitely needs Shreyan!! It is incomplete without him!! I also feel he will not have to start all over again to sing very well.. He is already excellent.. In fact, I feel he needed the break to get back in form.. For the past some episodes we could see how tired he got with the competition and his sickness which affected his performances.. Also, the audience is badly waiting to see him perform again so he will surely not have less votes either 😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".