How Fair Is It?

Page

Next Last

Megha1.1

@Megha1.1

Beginner

Posted: 8 years ago

Hi everybody..

I'm new to this forum. But following the show and this forum right from the beginning of the show.

I know few members of this forum as I'm reading their posts from the starting. Jenny, divya you both are jaan of this forum. And I enjoy reading your both comments. There are other members too. But these two girls are there from the starting. I know divya is upset by Adnan's elimination. But please divya don't disappear from the forum. I also read that Jenny would also quit the forum if shreyan goes. You both please dont leave the forum as the forum wont be same without you two.

Coming to the topic, Till now I was just reading the topics, but what made me open the account is Shreyan's absence again. I know here majority of people are shreyan's fan. And trust me even I like shreyan a lot. But just a question is it right to give break to shreyan in between the competition? I know because of extension contestants are falling sick. Still rest all contestants are performing in all episodes whereas shreyan is getting break to relax his voice. This concession given to shreyan I feel is unfair with other kids as they are giving stress to their voice every week. I think rules should be same to all contestants.

This is just my point of view.

I'm sorry if have said something wrong. I just thought to put up my point of view.

p.s.-This forum has amazing members. And i have enjoyed being silent reader here.

- Megha

Quote

Frequent Posters

altgr

@altgr

Stunner

+ 17

Posted: 8 years ago

Welcome megha. It will be great if you will also participate with us here. Actually I was thinking the same. I am a big big fan of Shreyan right from the beginning of the show and want him to win the show but giving him breaks like this is unfair. But I think there is something else going on which we viewers don't know. May be some problem between his parents and producers because of the extension.

Edited by altgr - 8 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

nice

@cool-boy_018

Voyager

Posted: 8 years ago

Yumna performed when she was sick. Why is Shreyan getting free breaks? I completely agree with you.

Quote

jyothi

@pjyo

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

yeah i have to agree rules should be same for all kids..yumna sang even with tonsils ,other kids too have sung being unwell ..Infact once even shreyan sang with high fever ...So maybe,something else is the issue here🤔 ,this unnecessary extension is creating problems for everyone, probably that's why judges r making exception this time..

Welcome to the forum megha😊..Hope jenny and divya will keep visiting the forum

Quote

Megha1.1

@Megha1.1

Beginner

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: altgr
Welcome megha. It will be great if you will also participate with us here. Actually I was thinking the same. I am a big big fan of Shreyan right from the beginning of the show and want him to win the show but giving him breaks like this is unfair. But I think there is something else going on which we viewers don't know. May be some problem between his parents and producers because of the extension.

Yes. This is possible that there might be some internal issues going on. But if his parents are having issue with extension, then he could quit the show. Shreyan is very talented as well as popular. So winning or not winning the show wont makes much difference to him in future. But this way not performing alternate weeks doesn't look proper for me. I feel Satyajit's dad took good decision of quitting the show at right time.

Again I would say this is just my opinion.

Quote

maheen hanif

@maheen55

Rocker

Posted: 8 years ago

hi Megha

welcome to the forum

i agree with u rules should b same for all as all are saying there is another issue due to extension if issues are not resolving then its better to quit but i am missing him

Edited by maheen55 - 8 years ago

Quote

Jenny

@jenny156

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

Aww thank you so much for appreciating our efforts Megha 🤗 That's so sweet of you 😳

And a warm welcome to the forum 😊 .. I am sure you will have a great time here.. Feels so good to see many new members creating an account to join this forum 😳 .. We have very few members, so the more the merrier 😳

Divya wrote in Shreyan AT that she is still in the forum because of Shreyan and if he leaves she will leave this forum then .. And maybe me too .. But I might still be here to troll the show and the judges 🤪

Now coming to Shreyan 😒 .. Ok it hurts to see him getting all the flak now .. I love this boy and everyone knows it. But I hate the makers for this unwanted extension 😡 .. I feared for Shreyan at that time that he would definitely lose interest and esp when his studies are more imp to him.. And after his dad posted his concern about it, I got the hint that this will lead to his downfall

And so it did, he started losing interest and fell sick causing him to skip some performances too!! Yes it is definitely unfair for the other contestants who have been performing still.. But only the makers know what is going on.. I feel there is a real issue between his parents and the makers which is causing this.. I can't blame the parents coz probably they signed the show for 3 months and did not expect it to be neverending like this.. Now they themselves are in a dilemma whether to let him compete here, when so many out there want to see him in finals, or leave the show!!

I don't think so sickness can be the real reason because he was sick before too but still performed and gave chartbusters.. He might have been sick last week, we even saw it in his monsoon special performance.. But now I don't think so he is sick.. It is something else bothering him.. and I am sure it is his studies.. I rather see him quit now instead of getting eliminated.. I cannot imagine what stress this little kid must be going through right now

Quote

Jenny

@jenny156

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: pjyo
yeah i have to agree rules should be same for all kids..yumna sang even with tonsils ,other kids too have sung being unwell ..Infact once even shreyan sang with high fever ...So maybe,something else is the issue here🤔 ,this unnecessary extension is creating problems for everyone, probably that's why judges r making exception this time..
Welcome to the forum megha😊..Hope jenny and divya will keep visiting the forum

Remember his Chupke Chupke performance? That was when he had high fever.. And he was amazing in it.. There is really something else that is going on now!!

You are right maybe the judges don't want him to leave hence giving him time to recover or sort out some issues.. Until the challengers come I guess they are letting it be.. Because there is no competition now anyway other than those so called badges..

Edited by jenny156 - 8 years ago

Quote

djoker

@djoker

Dazzler

Posted: 8 years ago

i think they dont want to ut pressure on kids anymore after the satyajeet fiasco and the current strom of banning kids shos ,look what happened when they put pressure on satyajeet when he was going through a voice change?? eventually they are kids and after a while they will fell pressure and break down
also think its an internal problem like you guys are saying cause shreyans dad openly said he had a problem with extension as both his and his mum were busy and may be cause these are just filler episodes zee though it was ok untill the competition is back up again ,untill the challengers arrive

Quote

djoker

@djoker

Dazzler

Posted: 8 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: jenny156
Aww thank you so much for appreciating our efforts Megha 🤗 That's so sweet of you 😳
And a warm welcome to the forum 😊 .. I am sure you will have a great time here.. Feels so good to see many new members creating an account to join this forum 😳 .. We have very few members, so the more the merrier 😳

Divya wrote in Shreyan AT that she is still in the forum because of Shreyan and if he leaves she will leave this forum then .. And maybe me too .. But I might still be here to troll the show and the judges 🤪

Now coming to Shreyan 😒 .. Ok it hurts to see him getting all the flak now .. I love this boy and everyone knows it. But I hate the makers for this unwanted extension 😡 .. I feared for Shreyan at that time that he would definitely lose interest and esp when his studies are more imp to him.. And after his dad posted his concern about it, I got the hint that this will lead to his downfall

And so it did, he started losing interest and fell sick causing him to skip some performances too!! Yes it is definitely unfair for the other contestants who have been performing still.. But only the makers know what is going on.. I feel there is a real issue between his parents and the makers which is causing this.. I can't blame the parents coz probably they signed the show for 3 months and did not expect it to be neverending like this.. Now they themselves are in a dilemma whether to let him compete here, when so many out there want to see him in finals, or leave the show!!

I don't think so sickness can be the real reason because he was sick before too but still performed and gave chartbusters.. He might have been sick last week, we even saw it in his monsoon special performance.. But now I don't think so he is sick.. It is something else bothering him.. and I am sure it is his studies.. I rather see him quit now instead of getting eliminated.. I cannot imagine what stress this little kid must be going through right now

jenny i think he had no choice but to sign winner or runner ups of srgm bangla have to appear definetly on seniors show its like a written rule in the seniors version kushal and shovan were winner of 2013 and both appeared shovan got eliminated in the early rounds and kushal won so shreyan had no choice i guess

Edited by djoker - 8 years ago

Quote

1 2 3

How Fair Is It?

Related Topics

Explore Topics