Dramatism in the most undramatic way.. - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

52

Views

3.7k

Users

18

Likes

128

Frequent Posters

meenu0527 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#41
Thanks God, in her broken and shocking state Ananya didn't go to her best friend and dont have ons with him ! She is the most strongest person.
pomegranate thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: -sharada-


I agree with all that you say in terms of this show being a trendsetter of sorts to provide quality material on Indian TV. Nothing was exaggerated. Everything was done perfectly in terms of planning by the producers and writers and execution by the brilliant actors. This show could connect with the viewers in a short time, which is a big achievement for all the people associated with it.
That said, I do wish they had a tight script. Just because the serial was extended from 120 episodes to 130, they seem to have added this totally unnecessary twist. This is a twist for the sake of a twist.

Ananya was already quite angry with Shreya on her engagement. She could see through her. So there was no need for another MU track to get her to see the evil behind Shreya's sugary sweetness. Now that they have only 126 episodes, I hope they quickly get back to their original story.


writers had a plan to bring back the SK case, but perhaps not in this way.


My wish to see Kaya as one unit during the last leg of this journey because they are the strongest when they are together. so, I want them to sort out their differences by next tuesday because there is hardly any time.
IAmNotActive thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: -RegalVintage-



Kabir is a thinker 😆.. Geee...i don't know. It just crossed my mind, maybe he was waiting in his car and needed to collect himself before he came in and faced the people who matter the most to him now. 😳

The JSP was really good, thoughtful and hopeful.. The talk about nazro mein gir na and gir k fir uthna. Waiting for him to win them over again!


I agree, the JSP of yesterday was very meaningful.. Looking forward to Kabir's never-say-die sprit in gaining back the respect & trust.
Edited by Geetha_R - 9 years ago
IAmNotActive thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: kayafan1

That is why I love this programme its soo realistic...no over acting


👍🏼
IAmNotActive thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: ...Lata...

so true...they kept it natural...no melodrama...just the powerful dialogues and the brilliant expressions once again by Rajeev and Kritika...Rajeev's eyes speaking volumes...the pathos and the agony Kabir Sharma is going through that only Rajeev could potray..

But the Slap just left me gobsmacked...was shocked to say the least...never expected Ananya to slap Kabir...but it had a powerful impact though I did not like it...

What irked me was Ananya giving an ultimatum to Kabir to just reply yes or no...comeon this is the matter of their whole life ahead and you cannot just tell it in one word...but yes knowing Ananya should not be surprised...she had the habit of taking abrupt decisions on the spur of the moment...but yes from Ananya's point of view can't blame her too this time...remains to be seen how Kabir ressurects and comes out a winner in this situation too...

as of Shreya less said about her the better...


The slap was spontaneous, the heartbreak of a daughter. Let's not forget her love for Kabir started as hero worship due to his support of her father. I can so understand what was going on in her mind, it is as if she lost the most precious thing in the world, the man she idolised never even exist.. Their love has come a long way, it is not just idolisation anymore, it is a mutual relationship, but somewhere inaide Ananya, kabir remains the hero of her troubled teenage. Taking it off from her, is like the ground slipping off her under her feet..

But this is not the end, their most balanced phase starts now, them as equals, not one as a protector, another as eternal damsel in distress..

Most people in the forum think the relationship is unbalanced, in that way Kabir is in gratitude for Ananya (for accepting him with flawed past), but for me it is imbalanced in the other way, Kabir always had been a hero with Ananya before they met and after they had fallen in love too, he was the one who saved her more than once, who eased all the hurdles in their relationship. Inspite of exposing his vulnerabilities w.r.t. his past, Kabir still remained a hero because the Kabir Ananya seen is the man who survived despite the past struggles, a survivor. But the Kabir Ananya now sees is not a hero, but a very ordinary man. if Annaya can still love him, the relationship will be the most balanced.
Edited by Geetha_R - 9 years ago
IAmNotActive thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: Malika

I have to say I so agree Geetha! I feel so sad that these days I am not able to see the epis live and have to rely on LUs because it does spoil the thrill. I am sure had I seen this epi live I would have been much more shaken than I already am! Having said that I still have to say that Rajeev and Kritika just owned that scene!! I did not know about they reading the mail together and when I saw that scene...that change in Kabir's expression and the terror in his eyes...It gave me goosebumps!! You know I have seen both KTH and LRL and Rajeev has always been great with emotional scenes irrespective of how much he had to cry but the truth is that a man crying so magnanimously is just not real. What he portrays as Kabir is the most subtle, real yet the most powerful ways of emoting. Those teary eyes, the shaking voice, the submissive body language...The MAN just out does himself in every frame.

Oh, so sad Malika, it does take the initial impact away when you watch it after reading the update, you can still enjoy the performances, but somewhere the emotional connect is lessened. I haven't watched any of the other shows, probably I would never, because I invariably gets disappointed when I watch a show for an actor. But what we had seen yesterday (and many times before, including the kerchief burning scene, bomb diffusal scene, etc) is a perfect portrayal of man who is torn, who wants to cry out, but holding onto his control by a wisp of a thread. Instead of crying, he made us want to cry for him, that's is the power of the performance..

As per story perspective I am happiest than ever. Some of the things to rejoice are that Kabir is not even 1% guilt-ridden. I always maintained this since the day he and Tarini began talking about the SK case and tonight his reaction when Ananya said "even you are a culprit"...It just made me so sure that he is not at all guilty. I am sure he has a very strong reason that forced him to lie. Yes he was wrong but he had his valid reasons. So all in all its gonna be very hard for him and we will see him in a lot of pain but surely all of it will be worth it. Tomorrow Ananya and Anita might say nasty things to him and he will be shattered, specially with Ananya breaking the engagement but this is gonna be one beautiful ride we will always cherish...and If RaTika have planned to give us such performances every day, I am dying for this track to unfold.

I am not going to speculate at this point, nothing comes out of speculations, there are some obvious bloopers ofcourse, but I am rooting for writers compensating the bloopers by giving us an awesome end. From the spoilers it look like my wishes will be granted, the wish of seeing a stoic Kabir in the zenith of facing the biggest struggle of his life, the possibility of losing the love of his life, he isn't going to breakdown, he isn't going to be a wimp, but he is is going to gather his troops and fight agiant the odds, and I am more more than eager to see that.

One more thing I am loving is that in this whole scenario basically Shreya is not the culprit till now. In most of the shows the vamp does all the shit and the leads suffer but here this problem is because of Kabir's baggage...its because of the communication gaps between KaYa...its because of the li'l flaws yet to be bridged in their relationship. So even now its not about Shreya but KaYa because ultimately Shreya didnt distort any info. She just used facts to break KaYa and sadly shes succesfull. So at the end, its KaYa who have to learn to identify their weak links and work on them.

I agree, she is just the opportunist, till now she twisted the facts, but not lied out rightly. This is the test by fire for KaYa, and if they pass the test, they would have learnt some valuable lessons and will emerge stronger

All in all, a brilliantly conceived, directed and acted epi. I have never seen something so hard-hitting with such subtle treatment...even bollywood doesnt get this close!! Having to see this on tv is something surreal.

👍🏼

IAmNotActive thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: Rinu08

I fully agree with you but feeling more bad for Kabir.


Yes, we can't help, but feel for his situation..

But, I have full hopes on him for remaining strong and fight for what is important to him..
IAmNotActive thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: pomegranate

I did not watch the episode so I can't say but what possessed Kabir to get into a relationship with Ananya given what he knows? this is such a last minute twist, with glaring bloopers.



to clarify, i'm quite leniant with bloopers and unrealism. I have looked past all the loopholes because imo, the story is still good but this twist just does not seem well thought out.


This track is certainly an after thought, about why Kabir got into the relationship, let's see whether they give us explanations, Even if they don't, we can assume that he couldn't help himself falling for her...

But the most obvious bloopers are, his talk with Tarini after his partial exposure of truth to Annaya, and then Shreya not noticing SK's pic in her first visit to kahsyap house. These two cannot be explained anymore.

As I said few times before, most stories brings out a short spell of separation / victory for villain camp before they leads finally get togtether, here the makers doesn't know how to bring that separation track.. I am still hoping that handling of the track would compensate for the initial bloopers.. Let's see

tingding thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: Geetha_R



The slap was spontaneous, the heartbreak of a daughter. Let's not forget her love for Kabir started as hero worship due to his support of her father. I can so understand what was going on in her mind, it is as if she lost the most precious thing in the world, the man she idolised never even exist.. Their love has come a long way, it is not just idolisation anymore, it is a mutual relationship, but somewhere inaide Ananya, kabir remains the hero of her troubled teenage. Taking it off from her, is like the ground slipping off her under her feet..

But this is not the end, their most balanced phase starts now, them as equals, not one as a protector, another as eternal damsel in distress..

Most people in the forum think the relationship is unbalanced, in that way Kabir is in gratitude for Ananya (for accepting him with flawed past), but for me it is imbalanced in the other way, Kabir always had been a hero with Ananya before they met and after they had fallen in love too, he was the one who saved her more than once, who eased all the hurdles in their relationship. Inspite of exposing his vulnerabilities w.r.t. his past, Kabir still remained a hero because the Kabir Ananya seen is the man who survived despite the past struggles, a survivor. But the Kabir Ananya now sees is not a hero, but a very ordinary man. if Annaya can still love him, the relationship will be the most balanced.



Must say you have a super positive and amazing attitude to life and that reflects in your posts. While most ppl, including me are busy complaining about the writer and the new twist, You are able to look beyond that to positives. Love reading your posts, for me this forum is not only about the serial discussion, but about meeting and learning from new ppl. And ur one of the ppl I've loved meeting virtually:). Keep up the awesome writing please, KAbir is indeed your soul brother.
Edited by tingding - 9 years ago
IAmNotActive thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: -sharada-


I agree with all that you say in terms of this show being a trendsetter of sorts to provide quality material on Indian TV. Nothing was exaggerated. Everything was done perfectly in terms of planning by the producers and writers and execution by the brilliant actors. This show could connect with the viewers in a short time, which is a big achievement for all the people associated with it.
That said, I do wish they had a tight script. Just because the serial was extended from 120 episodes to 130, they seem to have added this totally unnecessary twist. This is a twist for the sake of a twist.

Ananya was already quite angry with Shreya on her engagement. She could see through her. So there was no need for another MU track to get her to see the evil behind Shreya's sugary sweetness. Now that they have only 126 episodes, I hope they quickly get back to their original story.



I don't think this track is brought to expose Shreya's evil machinations to Ananya,.. In my opinion, this track is needed for an entirely different reason.. I was always uneasy whenever Ananya mentions that she loves Kabir for the past 8 years, that can't be love, that is plain heroworship, and if that blossomed into love, that is not an ideal foundation for love.. The Kabir she adored as a teenager is a perfect dream, one can't base their future on such dreams, for a real love, you need to see the person in their best AND thier worst. The Kabir now Ananya sees, is not so heroic, a man who is weak, who had given in to pressure (for whatever reasons). No man is ever perfect, and this is the imperfect side of Kabir, can Ananya love this imperfect, non heroic Kabir?
Edited by Geetha_R - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".