Can SK be alive????? A speculation :)

Page

Next Last

idonkno

@idonkno

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Sorry to bother you guys again with another craziest thought that crossed my mind (maybe because I am biotech post-graduate with interest in regulatory and corporate affairs). Now this maybe one of the scenarios I have not expected from reporters till now but it does seem logical based on the fact that SK's body has not been yet discovered from the crime scene mentioned. Can SK be alive?

I am saying this based on a case that happened with Ranbaxy few years back. One of the employees found out the data of the drugs submitted to the regulatory authorities had been falsified and also that the manufacturing process used was sloppy (i.e. GMP was not followed). His superiors did not pay any heed to his evidence and instead was accused of watching po*nography on his company computer and thus he had to resign from his job. Later, he made a complaint in US under the False Claims Act (as the company was selling drugs in US), also called whistleblower's law wherein any individual can file case against the government contractors for submitting fraudulent claims to the government. The company pleaded guilty and was fined a heavy sum of compensation. But as far as I know the information regarding where is he living was never ever disclosed...

So, SK might have called Kabir to disclose information about the wrongdoings of the company. He was indeed a whistleblower in this case. Most of these people generally end up being harassed, threatened, forced to resign or even murdered. So murder does seem a plausible option in this case. But, since his body has not been discovered so is there any chance that SK is alive but staying away from his family in order to protect them and maybe now working as anonymous health activist (because the whistleblower protection bill in India does not address corruption in private and corporate sector)? Plus, the pharma sponsor case is also there which I am pretty sure will land KKN in trouble ( let's assume it's about wrongful marketing of drugs) and we can hope SK's case to come forward when this happens.

There are mainly two reasons behind making this post -

First the logical me could not stop myself from relating the Ranbaxy's case to reporters as it came up in one of my conversation with a friend regarding the existing corruption in the pharma industry.

Secondly because the spoiler of Kabir being an eye-witness to SK murder and keeping quiet in order to protect him and his family was not going well with me (in my defence its just hard to believe). So, last night when the SK topic was brought up by Ananya I was actually scrutinizing his expressions hoping to see signs of guilt for not being able to deliver justice to an innocent man but I did not see any guilt on his face instead I found him to be only uncomfortable. Surprised not to see any guilt on his face I re-watched his conversation with Tarini and I cannot believe he was lying to her in any respect. He was genuinely saying the truth that he had told Ananya 'jo bhi woh jaanta tha'. Then it struck me what if he had really told her what he knew (what one would make out from the situation(the crime scene)) but hidden about 'jo woh maanta tha' regarding this case (maybe he suspects he was murdered or maybe he suspects that he might be alive). I feel that laden expression on his face was not because he had lied to her but because he was unable to share his doubt (or his version possibility) regarding the reality of SK's case. I don't think he himself is convinced that SK committed suicide but still he had no other choice than to agree when she herself brought up the topic of suicide (obvious reasons being to protect her as he suspects danger or lack of evidence in order to support his possibility/doubt). And then when he realised how deeply the Ananaya has been affected by the suicide revelation about the man she had idolized all her life and that too because she believed what he told her over what her heart really felt and how he helped her to look at the other side made my belief that he too isn't convinced that it was a suicide further compelling.

PS: A special thanks to Geetha for being the first one to read to this crazy speculation on her thread and encouraging me to make a separate post on this.

Edited by idonkno - 10 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

violette

@violette

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

I had similar dbt.. especially coz Kabir said thy wud marry same date as her parents got married. No man wud say tht to his girl whose father he witnessed murdered. It jst seems to cruel to me.. if u ask.. unless makers want to show some positive reason behind it!😳

Regarding Ranbaxy case.. bingo! Yes such law does exist.. in many serials I have seen this witness protection program.. I think thr r couple of films too on it.. where in sometimes the whole identity of a man is changed for his protection, bt nothing of tht sort is show in this serial. So I don't know how much we can relate it to the story of Reporters.

Bt I do agree SK being dad with KS's expressed did look a bit odd! Bt I gathered he might not have witnessed it himself and hence he was unsure abt it when he told Ananya abt her father (wanted to give him a benefit of dbt for lying!)

Bt thrs this possibility too.. tht he is working secretly on this case and wud soon bring justice to her father.. before thy get married.. wether SK is dead or not!😳

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

idonkno

@idonkno

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: violette
I had similar dbt.. especially coz Kabir said thy wud marry same date as her parents got married. No man wud say tht to his girl whose father he witnessed murdered. It jst seems to cruel to me.. if u ask.. unless makers want to show some positive reason behind it!😳
I second you on this one Violette 😊 But, we also need to be ready to expect the unexpected 😛

Regarding Ranbaxy case.. bingo! Yes such law does exist.. in many serials I have seen this witness protection program.. I think thr r couple of films too on it.. where in sometimes the whole identity of a man is changed for his protection, bt nothing of tht sort is show in this serial. So I don't know how much we can relate it to the story of Reporters.

Yes such law does exists and is strictly implemented in countries like US! In India such law is mainly meant for public sector but there is a need for its extension to the private sector because of the prevailing corruption in this country due to unholy nexus among politicians-bureaucrats-industrialists.Government and its functionaries are caught by the pincer of RTI and the whistleblower law but private sector is left severely alone because neither of these laws are applicable to it. If Reporters manages to deliver such a message to the commoner through SK's case I will surely be amazed !!

Bt I do agree SK being dad with KS's expressed did look a bit odd! Bt I gathered he might not have witnessed it himself and hence he was unsure abt it when he told Ananya abt her father (wanted to give him a benefit of dbt for lying!)

Haha! Same here!

Bt thrs this possibility too.. tht he is working secretly on this case and wud soon bring justice to her father.. before thy get married.. wether SK is dead or not!😳

Yes that is a possibility too and we all are expecting this to happen. I so want to see KaYa working on this one together

Edited by idonkno - 10 years ago

Quote

Rabzonedge

@rabzonedge

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

Yes dear... i had similar thoughts too that SK might be alive...
Its lovely reading your posts n thoughts keep making more...

Quote

IMAnam

@IMAnam

Explorer

Posted: 10 years ago

A very nice assumption it can be true

And there was no gulit on his face for sure just like you and SK being in witness protection can be a smart plot to be used apart from the episode when KS and AK followed those terrorist being the only silly protrayal till date I still am rooting for this show to give us the smart script that it has given us during the whole run and end up on a high note.

Witness protection part has been shown in various series and movies.

Quote

idonkno

@idonkno

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: rabzonedge
Yes dear... i had similar thoughts too that SK might be alive...
Its lovely reading your posts n thoughts keep making more...

Thank you dear 🤗!

Additional thank you for reading and liking this post on Geetha's thread as well! BTW I love reading your posts equally so you too keep making more 😃

Edited by idonkno - 10 years ago

Quote

idonkno

@idonkno

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: IMAnam
A very nice assumption it can be true
And there was no gulit on his face for sure just like you and SK being in witness protection can be a smart plot to be used apart from the episode when KS and AK followed those terrorist being the only silly protrayal till date I still am rooting for this show to give us the smart script that it has given us during the whole run and end up on a high note.
Witness protection part has been shown in various series and movies.

Thank you so much! I too expect a lot from this show and if they are planning on delivering such a twist (that has a message against the existing corruption and can also motivate commoners to act accordingly in order to bring amendments to the existing laws for the betterment of our country and protection of its citizens) then reporters will surely be a trendsetter series for the Indian television making it further unforgettable!

Edited by idonkno - 10 years ago

Quote

IAmNotActive

@IAmNotActive

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

Very very logical post and a plausible explanation..

I too don't believe in the spoilers about Kabir witnessing Sk's death, there is no guilt in him at all, only discomfiture.. And as Violette mentioned, I don't expect him to suggest to get married on the anniversary of her parents if he indeed witnessed SK'e death, but didn't bring the culprits to justice,

And I mentioned in another post, his talk with Tarini and aloe his friendship with Khurana (which started from this case) doesn't add up to this 'spoiler'.

But, there is something he is hiding. It is very obvious, as I said multiple times before, it is something he doubts/ suspects / speculates, not knows for sure, or atlesst not known to him for a long time, it is a very much a possibility that he is working secretly on the case from the time he revealed SK's death to Ananya.

Most probably, Ananya would be presented with a twisted truth and when she confronts Kabir about whether he knows / thinks her father is murdererd, he would be rendered speechless (as he indeed thinks SK is murdered) which would make Ananya furious and she may decline to listen to him further (for a day or two).

SK being alive, and keeping himself hidden for obvious reasons, would be a great twist, the actor playing SK is only seen on photos, he didn't even have a FB, would love to see him shoot few scenes with his onscreen family ;)

But, there are somethings doesn't add up here too, I thought Kabir said no one was prosecuted in this case, (I remember so, not sure) and the case is closed, if that is the case why SK as a whistle blower should keep himself hidden?

Edited by Geetha_R - 10 years ago

Quote

@Jhalak29

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

I am in agreement with you.. what I feel he only
Knows partial truth hence that's what he told Ananya
N tarini yet he suspects something bigger
also there is no guilt in him...
what I feel is like always Shreya will manuplicate the truth
in a way that will make him look like a culprit but
after the initial setback
they will go all the way to uncover full truth

I am aware of ranbaxy case n I think this can be similar
because reporters does pick revelant close of real life cases
N works around them

Quote

Mahi78

@Mahi78

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 10 years ago

#10

I always had this doubt that SK may be alive, I made posts time and again about it, but couldn't come up with the reason for it, your reasoning looks so apt to the situation.😊

I also got this doubt when for the first time Anita blamed her husband for leaving her alone in all this mess, when she came to know about Kabir's past. Then I reached all the episode where ever they mentioned SK and somehow I felt Kabir was hiding some truth but was guilty about it, which makes me feel that he is still alive,

But since Sherya doesn't know this fact she will tell the half truth of SK being murdered and Kabir being the witness of it, then I think Kabir will be forced to tell her the truth and then we will have a big case of the scandal Parida faash byKaYa😊

By the way very interesting plot to keep SK alive, why don't you forward this link to Sameer sir.😊

Quote

1 2

Can SK be alive????? A speculation :)

Related Topics

Explore Topics