Did Kabir hide Sudhir Kashyap murder to protect Ananya/Kashyaps??

_symphony thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Well I know guys there are speculations everywhere but we know our Mr. Sharma!! He can never do something so wrong. And I think after reading all this my first assumption about Kabir hiding Sudhirs murder, when Kabir came to tell the truth to Ananya is coming true.

So in SBS Rajeev told about hiding some truth from Ananya but what truth he didnt say. Acc to TC article, Ananya comes to know he knew Sudhirs case was not suicide but murder and he hid it to protect himself/his family. But I feel this is half truth or you can say twisted truth served to Ananya by Shreya. Quite psbl at some time Monu was at risk due to Kabirs truth and daring stand about Mr. Kashyap and it might have scared Kabir too. And thats why probably he readily parted from his family but continued investigating about the case. He did not want his nephew to be at risk because of him so he continued with his investigation behind the scenes and kept his family away from himself. And then when he came to know about Ananya being Sudhirs daughter it just scared him. He even kept that article with him remember. He knew if Ananya will come to know she wont be consolable and she will become hyper to dig out the truth thus endangering her as only he knows how dangerous those ppl are. So he lied to Ananya and let her beleive the half-truth so that he can tell her the truth when he is able to prove Mr. Kashyap innocent.

This was my first assumption abt this case and I think its coming true. Kabir has hidden but I feel its for the sake of ANanya's safety. He is still himself trying to punish the culprits behind everyone's back putting himself in danger but trying to keep all others safe. Just I hope Ananya u/stands this. Kabir will be totally broken if she breaks the engagement and here too Shreya will be successful in making him feel guilty about causing pain to Ananya. So not only will he be broken about engagement called off but also Ananyas trust being shaken.

Hope Ananya can see beyond the obvious.
Edited by Malika - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

3.9k

Users

15

Likes

78

Frequent Posters

BornHyper thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Excellent thoughts...
The only way Kabir's character can be redeemed in this case would be if he is able to solve it despite putting himself in danger.


crazy_rinks thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
If kabir hides something even after knowing fully, then it will be for Ananya and her family's good. his face must show some guilt ifhe hides something from Ananya. he was not shown like that. only after his talk with his brother he is little disturbed.

he also said to Tarini, he conveyed to Ananya what he knows about her father. I don't think it is a mistake in script.

second option, he actually not aware but came to know recently. through that new client. He is confused how to share this with Ananya.

Shreya using this as triumph card creating confusion in engagement.

resulting form of engagement is yet to be revealed. I don't believe this tc article fully.it may have been built by the word of sammeer sirs chatting with fans.

Sameer sir said villains will create problem in engagement. also he said only Kabir and Ananya can trust each other. every other character has their hidden characters.

ananya character is not so stupid to stop a engagement for SK case and give Mahan look to ONS.
Edited by rrinky17 - 10 years ago
Sagi97 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Yes, agreed with rrinky. If Kabir was hiding something about SK, that guilt would have shown.
Maybe it's the fact that the new stakeholder in KkN is the same pharma company where her father worked, Kabir is not able to tell. It doesn't directly concern Ananya, so that guilt never came in...
pomegranate thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
My entire opinion depends on what kabir actually knows. If he indeed witnessed SK's murder and did nothing, then that is unforgivable. fortunately, writers know where to draw the line and this bit either made up by shreya or the article got it wrong. whatever the case may be, I'm sure shreya played dirty somewhere. Before someone writes me off as a blind kabir fan, let me just say that there is something called writing flawed characters then there is character assasination. Kabir seeing SK's murder and doing nothing about it, then pursuing a relationship with ananya is called Character assasination. which I don't think writers will do, especially when they have taken great pains to write Kabir's character.

only thing plausible now is that kabir knows it was murder not suicide but chose to hide it from ananya because 1) for her safety 2) he does not have tangible proof to backup his claim, or he is not even sure 100%


if my above theory holds true then it doesn't make sense for ananya to call of the engagement unless of course, Shreya twisted everything. but ananya has faith in kabir so it will take a lot of effort to shake that faith. him hiding the truth is disappointing but not such a earth shattering revelation that she will break it off.


kaya needs to stand as a unit now more than ever because the vultures are closing in, so I was hoping that there will be no major misunderstandings. now thanks to this twist, will kaya take a break or work seperately towards the same goal(solving SK case) only 30 episodes left and now there will be a mini seperation? according to me, this twist should have been introduced a long time ago because it is a major plotpoint that is connected to the lead, but of course they waited till the last minute.

in addition, I just saw the 100 epi celebration. everyone is dressed up for kaya's engagement and now the engagement will be called off in front of them. I was hoping cv's would avoid such a public drama *sigh*
Edited by pomegranate - 10 years ago
_symphony thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Guys I think when he hid the article it was fishy for me. And if you clearly see where he told about suicide he indeed have some guilt on his face. But it was short lived may be because he knows he is doing it for the best. He is not guilt ridden for this because he knows one day he will tell the whole truth to Ananya once he proves her dad innocent w/o risking anyone. He never expected everything will happen so quickly so now he is a bit scared. I think we might get a monologue or some flashback before the engagement that tells why he is suddenly tensed. Lets wait and watch. But itna I am sure he will never hide a truth from Ananya until its for her good.
Edited by Malika - 10 years ago
BedouinMe thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
I had always found his Singapore trip followed by the merger, very fishy ! Even if he was not investigating the case since 8 yes but I feel he has been doing it, after he came to know he was Ananya's father.
sonyjknum thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Malika

Guys I think when he hid the article it was fishy for me. And if you clearly see where he told about suicide he indeed have some guilt on his face. But it was short lived may be because he knows he is doing it for the best. He is not guilt ridden for this because he knows one day he will tell the whole truth to Ananya once he proves her dad innocent w/o risking anyone. He never expected everything will happen so quickly so now he is a bit scared. I think we might get a monologue or some flashback before the engagement that tells why he is suddenly tensed. Lets wait and watch. But itna I am sure he will never hide a truth from Ananya until its for her good.

agree..I am very upset ppl are just so ready to point fingers at him...not liking...but yes all have their opinions..if Kabir has deliberate ly not told Anu..he must have reasons...and this is surely not the jhatka I am sure...Anu might be angry but he will tell her his reasong.could see his brother in engagement pics
idonkno thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
To be frank I am disappointed at this piece of information and still do not want to believe that he had hidden this gen from Ananya for so long now because it shakes the foundation of their relationship based on honesty and trustworthiness.

I so desperately want him to be framed here ( I would love this spoiler to be false as well but I think the chances of that is nearly zilch)..but like you said Kabir Sharma can never do anything wrong and I too believe in this..so I have to give in to the most plausible theory you have presented in this post here because we know he loves Ananya too much and whatever he does would be for her welfare indeed..So not doubting his intentions and accepting this!

High chances the what is revealed in front of Ananya would be a twisted story


PS: Ananya will definitely see beyond the obvious (it might take a while though but I trust her too like Kabir) and I want KaYa to solve this case together 😃

Edited by idonkno - 10 years ago
NandiniRaizadaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Rightly said Mallika
I guess Kabir will solve this on and redeem himself

Hopefully Ananya will join him

But I still can't fathom what is Shreya's role in the half truth

I am sure Ananya will recover abd see beyond the half truth.
Yeah his intention might have been to protect her but still it was about her father...

Let's see


Edited by NandiniRaizadaa - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".