Did Kabir hide Sudhir Kashyap murder to protect Ananya/Kashyaps?? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

3.9k

Users

15

Likes

78

Frequent Posters

NandiniRaizadaa thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: idonkno

To be frank I am disappointed at this piece of information and still do not want to believe that he had hidden this gen from Ananya for so long now because it shakes the foundation of their relationship based on honesty and trustworthiness.


I so desperately want him to be framed here ( I would love this spoiler to be false as well but I think the chances of that is nearly zilch)..but like you said Kabir Sharma can never do anything wrong and I too believe in this..so I have to give in to the most plausible theory you have presented in this post here because we know he loves Ananya too much and whatever he does would be for her welfare indeed..So not doubting his intentions and accepting this!

High chances the what is revealed in front of Ananya would be a twisted story


PS: Ananya will definitely see beyond the obvious (it might take a while though but I trust her too like Kabir) and I want KaYa to solve this case together 😃


Yes even I am slightly disappointed

Personally I feel this is worse then the ONS because ONS was in the past abd had nothing to to do with Ananya . But this is about her father

She had a right to know .

Still let's wait and watch
-sharada- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#12

Bottomline, Miss. Kashyap doesn't want to know anything about her past too. She has been least bothered about what happened to her dad. Never made any attempt of her own to find out in the 8 years since he went missing. She accepted what her mom told her.

She asked Kabir to help her either as a junior or friend to reach her manzil and forgot all about it soon after she said those words. She accepted what Kabir told her.

Now, when she gets to know something from SB, she wants to ditch Kabir for not telling her? seriously????
_symphony thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#13
@Idonkno (Dear may I pls know ur good name) and Gitanjali
I ustand u guys being disappointed a bit but honestly I am not (if this is the cause of his hiding) because this was my my first speculation when I saw that scene between KaYa where Kabir said Mr. Kashyap did suicide. He was visibly guilty and somehow he wanted Ananya to believe that her dad committed suicide. As per me his only mistake is that he made Ananya believe that indeed his dad was weak. He could have told her the truth but that too must have been very risky knowing Ananya.

Later I forgot about this because Sammeer sir said this case wont cause any harm to KaYa. But now that it has resurfaced, and we know that Monu was severely endangered and probably Anurag crippled because of this, I can understand his fear. Somehow he has seen what a danger these people can be. No doubt Ananya wont have stayed calm after this and if they came to know about her trying to dig them out, the Kashyaps would be destroyed. Kabirs fears were very genuine. Honestly I had given this benefit of doubt to him the day the epi aired. This seemed the most plausible problem fro KaYa to me in future.

And I am sure gradually Ananya too will forgive him. His intentions were very genuine.
Edited by Malika - 10 years ago
_symphony thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#14
@sharda - I agree somewhere Ananya too has been at fault. Why do we always expect Kabir to be the most mahaan. The truth is no human being is perfect. We all have our weaknesses. Specially when we are in love. We get scared. Sometimes we even get over confident. May be Kabir thought Ananya being so understanding will give his actions a benefit of doubt. And thats why he is now scared/guilty because Ananya said now there are no secrets between them.
But it cannot be denied that even Ananya faltered sometimes. I am sure Kabir is following that case till now...undoubtedly his such close rleations with Khurana indicate they have been in constant touch and how Khurana trusts Kabir, I am sure he knows how much Kabir has been involved in the Sudhir Kashyap case. So Kabir not being a family was so involved then we expected even Ananya to be involved in the case. But again she is a human. She had her share of responsibilities and limitations. She was just a junior reporter.

We ought to accept our characters as flawed.
Shweta13 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Malika

@Idonkno (Dear may I pls know ur good name) and Gitanjali

I ustand u guys being disappointed a bit but honestly I am not (if this is the cause of his hiding) because this was my my first speculation when I saw that scene between KaYa where Kabir said Mr. Kashyap did suicide. He was visibly guilty and somehow he wanted Ananya to believe that her dad committed suicide. As per me his only mistake is that he made Ananya believe that indeed his dad was weak. He could have told her the truth but that too must have been very risky knowing Ananya.

Later I forgot about this because Sammeer sir said this case wont cause any harm to KaYa. But now that it has resurfaced, and we know that Monu was severely endangered and probably Anurag crippled because of this, I can understand his fear. Somehow he has seen what a danger these people can be. No doubt Ananya wont have stayed calm after this and if they came to know about her trying to dig them out, the Kashyaps would be destroyed. Kabirs fears were very genuine. Honestly I had given this benefit of doubt to him the day the epi aired. This seemed the most plausible problem fro KaYa to me in future.

And I am sure gradually Ananya too will forgive him. His intentions were very genuine.


Malika I differ a bit here ... first dialogue when he spoke to tarini was " Kya rishta hai mera sach ke saath. .. kyun hamesha mere saamne aake khada hojata hai, mein jitna door jana chahtq hun utnna something... sach janana chahti thi woh, bata diya maine use sach poora sach jitna mein janta tha .."

After this if he knows something is disaappointing and I really want some deep twist in the tale to redeem his character or else he should be unaware of all of it.
saurdeep thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Malika

Guys I think when he hid the article it was fishy for me. And if you clearly see where he told about suicide he indeed have some guilt on his face. But it was short lived may be because he knows he is doing it for the best. He is not guilt ridden for this because he knows one day he will tell the whole truth to Ananya once he proves her dad innocent w/o risking anyone. He never expected everything will happen so quickly so now he is a bit scared. I think we might get a monologue or some flashback before the engagement that tells why he is suddenly tensed. Lets wait and watch. But itna I am sure he will never hide a truth from Ananya until its for her good.











Yes,Malika,I remember that scene where Kabir hided the article from Ananya and did not even return her when he came to her house for SK's suicide revelation,dat time I also thought,Y is he still hiding dat article? Bt,when Kabir said to Tarini dat whatever truth he knew about SK,he shared with Ananya,now that is really confusing for me.
christina.g thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#17
I feel that this is jhatka that sammeer sir was talking about. Which shreya would be giving ananya. She would come up with the half truth and will make ananya believe that kabir voluntarily kept quite even after knowing her father's truth.. And in the peak of the moment ananya will break the engagement with kabir but to keep her family's respect anita would ask Ronnie to get engaged to ananya and he would do accordingly.. and after all the heart break. Ananya will realize that shreya lied to her and used her. And then ananya will realize her mistake.
koyelbasu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#18
Kabir positively has some solid reason to lie about Sudhir Kashyap murder. But, Ananya is not wrong in reacting this way, after all it is about her father's murder. So, both of them are not wrong from their side but the situation is wrong.
rabzonedge thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#19
I agree monu might b reason kabeer hid the fact plus usse laga hoga ananya seh nhi payegi... but kabeer ka dialogue ki sab sach bata diya n now Sudhir kashyap case resurfacing is confusing me...
Shreya twisted truth ko present karegi...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".