Yun hota toh kya hota?

Agar Kabir ne Ananya ko pura sach bata diya hota toh kya hota?
Ananya would have cried her heart out and kept quiet? Is that what we expect ? A BIG NO ! Right at the next moment, she would have called up Tinnu and started off with her investigations on a case of a drug scandal which had been so dangerous and serious that the main accused got murdered ! Not just that, the eye witness (as per the spoiler) was threatened and also his family members harmed. Would a junior reporter have met a different fate? Specially one like Ananya who is straightforward, impulsive, unapologetic and at times even foolishly driven by emotions? I don't think so ! She would have been at the same place where Mr. Kashyap is ! The Kashyap family would automatically be ruined!

Let's just assume that the spoilers are 100% true! Though I doubt. Why was it wrong on Kabir's part if he didn't care to expose the real culprits of the murder of an apparently innocent stranger to protect his own family? Don't we say, charity should always begin at home? What would he have gained by killing his own family to give justice to an outsider? That too at a time when his own life had enough of turmoil brought by his ex wife!
Isn't this practical? A rationale we all would consider in such a situation unless we are some great martyr, of course!

Now, coming to the issue of hiding it from Ananya. Considering the story so far and the spoiler, it has become clear that Kabir's family has distanced from him only bcoz of his strive to bring the truth out for which his family had to pay. He just didn't want another person, his dearest one, to pay for it again. He just wanted Ananya to be safe! And its not that he had planned or murdered Mr. Kashyap, then why should he feel guilty for dating or proposing Ananya? Rather I feel he was just trying make up for the void left by Mr. Kashyap by showering Ananya with all the love he could give ! How does this demean the purity of the emotions he has for Ananya, when all he did was actually to protect her, guard her from the demons of the world !
His thought may not have been right, but does this really raise a question on the man himself ?

May be I am the only one who feels this way ! OK, now I am putting my shield on to face the tamatars and chappals coming my way ;)

Originally posted by: BedouinMe

Agar Kabir ne Ananya ko pura sach bata diya hota toh kya hota?
Ananya would have cried her heart out and kept quiet? Is that what we expect ? A BIG NO ! Right at the next moment, she would have called up Tinnu and started off with her investigations on a case of a drug scandal which had been so dangerous and serious that the main accused got murdered ! Not just that, the eye witness (as per the spoiler) was threatened and also his family members harmed. Would a junior reporter have met a different fate? Specially one like Ananya who is straightforward, impulsive, unapologetic and at times even foolishly driven by emotions? I don't think so ! She would have been at the same place where Mr. Kashyap is ! The Kashyap family would automatically be ruined!

Let's just assume that the spoilers are 100% true! Though I doubt. Why was it wrong on Kabir's part if he didn't care to expose the real culprits of the murder of an apparently innocent stranger to protect his own family? Don't we say, charity should always begin at home? What would he have gained by killing his own family to give justice to an outsider? That too at a time when his own life had enough of turmoil brought by his ex wife!
Isn't this practical? A rationale we all would consider in such a situation unless we are some great martyr, of course!

Now, coming to the issue of hiding it from Ananya. Considering the story so far and the spoiler, it has become clear that Kabir's family has distanced from him only bcoz of his strive to bring the truth out for which his family had to pay. He just didn't want another person, his dearest one, to pay for it again. He just wanted Ananya to be safe! And its not that he had planned or murdered Mr. Kashyap, then why should he feel guilty for dating or proposing Ananya? Rather I feel he was just trying make up for the void left by Mr. Kashyap by showering Ananya with all the love he could give ! How does this demean the purity of the emotions he has for Ananya, when all he did was actually to protect her, guard her from the demons of the world !
His thought may not have been right, but does this really raise a question on the man himself ?

May be I am the only one who feels this way ! OK, now I am putting my shield on to face the tamatars and chappals coming my way ;)

👏 I hav to applaud you for contradicting yourself in every new post. Hota hain! 🤣 Because you hav given us so many scenarios. Kabir ka Maha-Fan...woh jo bhi kare sab maaf hain! 👏 Even if he had killed Mr Kashyap, then he would hav been defended. Wah... 👏 Fan ho toh aisa! The serial should hav been called,"Kabir ki Dastaan".
Too much of speculation is also injurious to health. Lets wait and watch!


-Rekha

Originally posted by: Danseuse

👏 I hav to applaud you for contradicting yourself in every new post. Hota hain! 🤣 Because you hav given us so many scenarios. Kabir ka Maha-Fan...woh jo bhi kare sab maaf hain! 👏 Even if he had killed Mr Kashyap, then he would hav been defended. Wah... 👏 Fan ho toh aisa! The serial should hav been called,"Kabir ki Dastaan".
Too much of speculation is also injurious to health. Lets wait and watch!


-Rekha

I am quite surprised to see, there's someone on the forum who can speculate my reactions ! Oh I am a terminal case of Kabiritis, you see ! I would have supported Kabir even if he had murdered Mr. Kashyap ! Nice speculation. I should consider. BTW, take care of your health tto, dear ! :)

Precisely my point. Why are we blaming Kabir here ? He did not plan and murder Mr. Kashyap and for that matter he might not even know he was murdered. As per his story, he was called to some remote place by Sudhir Kashyap and when he reached there all he found was a wallet which was probably Mr. Kashyap's. He concluded that the man would have committed suicide because of whatsoever reasons. From Kabir's POV, that is it. He probably knows nothing more, nothing less. And he told this all to Ananya at a time when they had no feelings for each other. Obviously no reason to hide if he indeed was a witness to a gruesome murder. He had nothing to lose.
Secondly when he confessed about his past to Ananya that night, I sincerely feel that if you can speak about your ONS with your girl-friend then there is nothing that you should hide. He confessed to all his weaknesses then why on earth would he hide this ?

I totally agree!! But knowing what a great soul Mr. Sharma is banda would hv never kept himself away from the case. I am sure he is still investigating. But not telling to anyone. Remember wo sach ke liye quayamat tak ja sakta hai...aur Ananya ko dukh dena woh bardasht nahin kar sakta...agar Ananya ko taqleef hui to woh khud toot jayega!!

Ahh so much positivity !! Agreeing to what all u said but still Ananya will tell him that there was no point hiding such a thing, It will come out sooner or later or he didnt trust her or her immense strength to tackle this.

Originally posted by: BedouinMe

Agar Kabir ne Ananya ko pura sach bata diya hota toh kya hota?
Ananya would have cried her heart out and kept quiet? Is that what we expect ? A BIG NO ! Right at the next moment, she would have called up Tinnu and started off with her investigations on a case of a drug scandal which had been so dangerous and serious that the main accused got murdered ! Not just that, the eye witness (as per the spoiler) was threatened and also his family members harmed. Would a junior reporter have met a different fate? Specially one like Ananya who is straightforward, impulsive, unapologetic and at times even foolishly driven by emotions? I don't think so ! She would have been at the same place where Mr. Kashyap is ! The Kashyap family would automatically be ruined!

Let's just assume that the spoilers are 100% true! Though I doubt. Why was it wrong on Kabir's part if he didn't care to expose the real culprits of the murder of an apparently innocent stranger to protect his own family? Don't we say, charity should always begin at home? What would he have gained by killing his own family to give justice to an outsider? That too at a time when his own life had enough of turmoil brought by his ex wife!
Isn't this practical? A rationale we all would consider in such a situation unless we are some great martyr, of course!

Now, coming to the issue of hiding it from Ananya. Considering the story so far and the spoiler, it has become clear that Kabir's family has distanced from him only bcoz of his strive to bring the truth out for which his family had to pay. He just didn't want another person, his dearest one, to pay for it again. He just wanted Ananya to be safe! And its not that he had planned or murdered Mr. Kashyap, then why should he feel guilty for dating or proposing Ananya? Rather I feel he was just trying make up for the void left by Mr. Kashyap by showering Ananya with all the love he could give ! How does this demean the purity of the emotions he has for Ananya, when all he did was actually to protect her, guard her from the demons of the world !
His thought may not have been right, but does this really raise a question on the man himself ?

May be I am the only one who feels this way ! OK, now I am putting my shield on to face the tamatars and chappals coming my way ;)

I agree with most of what you have mentioned, most importantly I agree with your logic of why Kabir might have hidden the whole truth from Annaya.