Bigg Boss 19: Daily Discussion Thread - 2nd Oct 2025
HEY JINDAGI 2.10
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Oct 2, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Oct 3, 2025 Episode Discussion Thread
BAAT KARO NA 3.10
Gen 5 News article Mila
Bingo Blitz - The Ultimate Showdown (Sign-up)
SRK Enters Billionaire Club
🏏India vs West Indies,1st Test: N M Stadium, Ahmedabad, Day 2🏏
Sunny Sanskari Ki Tulsi Kumari opens well!!
🎉 New Fun Quizzes Are Live on India Forums! 🎉
How saiyara became hit
The Manuscript Marauders Bingo Challenge Thread
Abhishek Seeks Legal Action On Salman Ash AI Generated Videos
Literary Looters 💰🤑 Book Bingo Discussions | October 2025 BTRC
What do you folks think about this???
The Literary Looters 💰 | Book Talk Reading Challenge October 2025
To everyone disliking Amaal, Baseer, et al…
Originally posted by: tvpankha
I agree too many loop holes. ..lot of unanswered questions
I seem to miss the astute kabir sharma...too much importance given to the proposali agree that the cases n sting op has lost its zing n romanch...hopefully the creative team thinks throughI almost laughed at khurana while he talked to kabir about not getting hold of the suspect at dhaba...looked like khurana is the only cop left in city n had only kabir n ananya to help him...he looked as if he could cry anytime. ..khurana not questioning baby is ridiculous. ...in any case he should be...kabir is eic of a news channel n not a copeverything is getting mushy too romantic. ..n add to that shreya just wants kabir back...I mean come on...even if ananya dumps him...why on earth he would consider going back to her...what is this woman thinking or mayb not thinking at allsomewhere I read that the flow of story is not that good...which makes sense. ...too many tracks happening n none are concluded well..mI think it happens coz of 5 episodes a week...n the constant pressure to come up with something new...for a season f2f ormat ...this show should be aired only 1-2 a week withv total episodes not more than 40 or so...then it could be very crispcurrently the show is losing it edge...n going no where. ...its like 130 episodes tak kuch to dikhana banta hai...
LizzieOriginally posted by: LizzieBennett
Hi Geetha. I've been disillusioned ever since the revelation of Shreya's true face hence not been posting much. Still been watching though.
But I'm just not able to wrap my mind around these loopholes some of them holes in the story and others just my personal opinion, but ones I feel could have been handled differently
1. The whole Anita giving Kabir the ultimatum to get engaged to Ananya and he promptly doing so. It feels like their relationship is forced. I mean that Kabir and Ananya should have gotten engaged because they were both ready and wanted it and not because Anita or anyone was holding a sword over their heads and making them do it. Not saying Anita did precisely that, her plan of finding a means to make Kabir withdraw backfired, but it still leaves me with a vague feeling of discontent that the engagement was someone else's idea and not their own.
2. Ditto for the proposal. Everything looked choreographed and not natural (except for Ananya's reaction). It wasn't heartfelt. And I disagree that the proposal wasn't important. After the confession, I think it should have been the most important moment in their life as a couple. But it wasn't. It was forced, unnatural and the thing that got to me the most was that everyone knew but Ananya. It may be a romantic gesture to some but not to me.
3. Shreya's character: I have said enough about this. Don't want to say more and rain on anyone's parade. Whatever signs there may have been of Shreya being a narcissist or whatever she is right from the beginning, I still feel that as a writer you are finally responsible for how you present your character. My only question is whether it was necessary to paint Shreya as this completely OTT character who will stop at nothing to get Kabir back into her life just so that the viewer's sympathies are completely with the heroes (in this case Kabir and Ananya)?? Did they want that whatever little backlash Kabir may have faced or whatever little he may have been judged by some sections of the audience should also be completely wiped out and he should emerge as this pure, unblemished person? Is this why they even made Anita completely overlook his wrongdoings and accept him with open arms? And today they tried to tell us Shreya "used" the ONS as an excuse to "dump" Kabir! Really?
4. Anita's whole-hearted acceptance of Kabir. He may have gone over to her place and convinced her or told her his side of the story, but how is she so willing to accept his version suddenly when she was not even ready to ask him earlier? She actually went to Shreya to hear of their past and left her place with her sympathies lying entirely with her! Then how was Kabir able to convince her and why were we not shown it? Is it that she agreed just for her daughter's happiness? *scoffs*
5. The Baby track. This was sooo all-important yesterday with Kabir giving her a task to do and yet today we see no mention of it? Its baffling! And today we had the shifty-eyed peon of KKN! Wheels within wheels! I'm afraid they're not going to close any track satisfactorily and leave a lot of loose ends with only 35 episodes to go. Unless they intend to leave them open for a season 2.
6. Taarini and Kabir: It is hard for us as audience to understand the importance of Taarini's presence in Kabir's life, so much so that Kabir got her to choose the ring! (This still irks me!) How does Anita or even Ananya understand? How is Kabir even able to maintain a healthy relationship with her despite the burden of guilt he obviously carries? And like you said, why is she not even in the picture? Why hasn't she met with Ananya or Anita? How can she remain happily nonchalant and unconcerned when a sordid truth about her past is being dissected and discussed by so many people? How does she not show the slightest bit of discomfort that now everyone knows the truth about her and Kabir? Its unreal.
7. And now they introduce another complication in the form of Monu. Don't know what Kabir did or didn't do to Monu that has affected his relationship with his bhabhi, but whatever it is, I'm sure it will be overlooked cause hasn't his brother already forgiven him? So his bhabhi is obviously overreacting! In fact, whenever Kabir or Ananya have gone wrong its usually someone else's fault. isn't it? How convenient!
I'm sure I'm going to get a lot of hate and jootas and chappals for this post, but my dissatisfaction was just waiting to come out! Sorry to use your thread for it!
Originally posted by: ...Lata...
Good to have you back Geetha
Yes the proposal as all pointed out was a kinda forced one...somehow something is amiss since the time of the revelation...hope the makers look into this and make it more realistic...now Shreya's character though as we all guessed is turning out to be a total negative vampish one and ridiculous the business head is out to ruin her own channel for her own personal interests...But I would not give up on the show still as I love watching Kabir and Ananya...good to see Kabir has still the same attitude and arrogance when it comes to his EIC post..Ananya's chirpy self...Rajeev's presence...his charisma and Kritika too and the rest of the actors still makes it worth watching...but I only hope they don't ruin the story further...
Bang on Liz!! Ok, so I agree with you on some fronts (quoted above). After the so called major twist, I have been so disappointed that I am not looking forward to watch the episodes..(And I am angry at myself for this I feel I am doing some ghaddari towards Reporters😆) I cant believe I found myself looking forward to watching a 'supernatural' show on Zee than the more logical Reporters 😕😆😆 I had read a post abt narcissism personality by Koyel..and I get it. Ok, Shreya is a narcissist. But it doesn't explain the OTT behavior. Oh come on, it seems she came from the mental asylumDuring the proposal, Ankita did the part so well..even till climbing the stairs..But in the room, that was a let down for me - by the actor & director. The same "psychotic" behaviour could have been shown in a more subdued manner...than the usual throwing stuff!!🥱 Jeez, I so wanted Anita & Kabir encounter before the proposal..Was expecting a flashback at least.😕 I could relate to Anita going hyper & giving an ultimatum to Ananya to choose between the two. I don't buy into the whole "giving in to Ananya's happiness". I have had this complaint against Kabir from the start..It was his responsibility to put all the cards on the table. You cant ask sumone to simply trust you without explaining urself!! I feel if they had shown yesterday's Anita-Kabir scene as a flashback, I wouldn't have been this disappointed!!! Coming to the most important Tarini angle- even after knowing Tarini still plays an integral role in his role, Ananya or her mother haven't shown any interest in knowing further (or even meeting Tarini)😕...Speaking of which, they haven't asked anything abt his family!!!This is one major flaw I see in the storytelling..Just for the sake of bringing in a dhamaka, they are dragging crucial stuff. So I don't find Tarini-Kabir friendship weird (even if they really crossed the limits)..I have witnessed the same in real life too. I had really enjoyed the twist that Kabir had a ONS with Tarini...But now it seems as if it was the vamp's doing.Sighhh...placing the hero on the pedestal again.Everything is the vamp's faults🤢🥱Originally posted by: LizzieBennett
I've been disillusioned ever since the revelation of Shreya's true face hence not been posting much. Still been watching though.
3. Shreya's character: I have said enough about this. Don't want to say more and rain on anyone's parade. Whatever signs there may have been of Shreya being a narcissist or whatever she is right from the beginning, I still feel that as a writer you are finally responsible for how you present your character. My only question is whether it was necessary to paint Shreya as this completely OTT character who will stop at nothing to get Kabir back into her life just so that the viewer's sympathies are completely with the heroes (in this case Kabir and Ananya)?? Did they want that whatever little backlash Kabir may have faced or whatever little he may have been judged by some sections of the audience should also be completely wiped out and he should emerge as this pure, unblemished person? Is this why they even made Anita completely overlook his wrongdoings and accept him with open arms? And today they tried to tell us Shreya "used" the ONS as an excuse to "dump" Kabir! Really?
4. Anita's whole-hearted acceptance of Kabir. He may have gone over to her place and convinced her or told her his side of the story, but how is she so willing to accept his version suddenly when she was not even ready to ask him earlier? She actually went to Shreya to hear of their past and left her place with her sympathies lying entirely with her! Then how was Kabir able to convince her and why were we not shown it? Is it that she agreed just for her daughter's happiness? *scoffs*
6. Taarini and Kabir: It is hard for us as audience to understand the importance of Taarini's presence in Kabir's life, so much so that Kabir got her to choose the ring! (This still irks me!) How does Anita or even Ananya understand? How is Kabir even able to maintain a healthy relationship with her despite the burden of guilt he obviously carries? And like you said, why is she not even in the picture? Why hasn't she met with Ananya or Anita? How can she remain happily nonchalant and unconcerned when a sordid truth about her past is being dissected and discussed by so many people? How does she not show the slightest bit of discomfort that now everyone knows the truth about her and Kabir? Its unreal.
7. And now they introduce another complication in the form of Monu. Don't know what Kabir did or didn't do to Monu that has affected his relationship with his bhabhi, but whatever it is, I'm sure it will be overlooked cause hasn't his brother already forgiven him? So his bhabhi is obviously overreacting! In fact, whenever Kabir or Ananya have gone wrong its usually someone else's fault. isn't it? How convenient!