Disappointed....Rudra was SO not in character - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

4.3k

Users

17

Likes

82

Frequent Posters

slyther_in thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#11
Im a Zaya fan but I too felt the mahasangham as an episode of Bi itself, Parud had no importance
Ammu1369 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: pancakes

zain aliya just confess their love so thats why they were behaving like that.

and totally agree the energy scene and kuch kuch hota hai was too much it was not needed

the whole point of maha sangram was total waist just to cure rudra hand this could have been done on monday at their place too what was the need to come all over mumbai.

also lastly It was so unrealistic that the moment rudra was able to open the window zain at the same time broke the one


Yeah... Those scene's weren't necessary.

When Rudra opened the window and Zain broke the glass, it was quite unrealistic, but they have keep the fans of both the shows glad right? 😛

But the way Rudra opened the window was sooo good... Very heroic 😃

slyther_in thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Ammu1369


Yeah... Those scene's weren't necessary.

When Rudra opened the window and Zain broke the glass, it was quite unrealistic, but they have keep the fans of both the shows glad right? 😛

But the way Rudra opened the window was sooo good... Very heroic 😃

Yes its difficult to merge 2 shows at to extremes and show justice to Parud n Zaya fans
pancakes thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Ammu1369


Yeah... Those scene's weren't necessary.

When Rudra opened the window and Zain broke the glass, it was quite unrealistic, but they have keep the fans of both the shows glad right? 😛

But the way Rudra opened the window was sooo good... Very heroic 😃


yah true they need to make both fans happy and as I watch both the show it was good one hour for me😊


Tiangka thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#15
MORAL OF THE MAHASANGHAM FOR COLOURS,:
NEVER EVER DO A MAHASANGHAM OF ANY TWO SERIALS,
EQUAL RESPECT SHOULD BE GIVEN TO BOTH SERIALS,
PLEASE DEFINITELY DO GIVE US MAHA ONE HOUR EPISODES OF BI AND RR,
THEY ARE BOTH YOUR BABIES (COLOURS), SO PLEASE TAKE CARE OF BOTH WITH LOVE BUT SEPARATELY PLEASE, AS NO TWO SIBLINGS ARE ALIKE, BOTH ARE INDIVIDUALS WITH OWN STRENGTHS SO SHOULD BE TREATED AS INDIVIDUALS.

We audience at the end of a very exhausting working day or school day or housework day, just wish to relax and enjoy a drama which will make us feel more relaxed not tensed. So those who enjoy BI, THEN WATCH BI, those who enjoy RR, THEN WATCH RR, and if some of us enjoy both THEN WATCH BOTH YAR!

DRAMAS ARE SUPPOSE TO ENTERTAIN US, NOT VICE VERSA! ANYWAY BOTH BI AND RR ARE NOT CLASHING WITH EACH OTHER ON TIME, THEY ARE SHOWN ONE AFTER ANOTHER, SO WE CAN CHOOSE ONE OR THE OTHER OR BOTH. NO NEED TO INCREASE OUR BP BY COMPARING THEM.

LETS ALL CHILL AND ENJOY OUR DRAMAS WHICH EVER IT MIGHT BE,

BY THE WAY I WATCH RR AS IT IS MY FAVOURITE HINDI DRAMA AT PRESENT, I STOPPED WATCHING BI AFTER SECOND EPISODE, BUT OBVIOUSLY IT IS FAVOURITE DRAMA OF MANY IF NOT THEY WOULD NOT BE DEFENDING BI, I RESPECT THAT.

LETS JUST ENJOY WHAT IS OUR CUP OF TEA , WITHOUT BREAKING EACH OTHERS' CUPS!😉


..Zainab.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#16
Believe or not I am a fan of both but my problem is making ZAYA look OTT and ridiculously stupid just to force upon another a realization on Parud,,,DID it help?
Zaya arent a PDA couple at all, that I could sure since some of you havent seen the show before and that is why a lot of the fans are ticked off as well.

Honestly there is absolutely no logic, so even bother going there?

In my opinion Zaya were more butchered looked even more ridiculous then Parud did

Because there could be explanations behind Parud's behaviors in some scenes but Zaya were totally out of character.
Edited by _Littles12_ - 11 years ago
-Sush- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#17
Thanks for the full review Shy!
I think, I am better off skipping this one...
Edited by -Sush- - 11 years ago
khushisinghr thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#18
DO not Agree To Your Post
Plz don't judge their efforts for some small reasons
After all it's fiction !!
puglet thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: st03im


Paro and Rudra on the beach was the only part of the episode that I enjoyed and that was in character for both of them. As usual, he says no right away when she asks to go to the beach. But as expected, he follows her like her shadow. Being away from Paro, not able to watch after her, or protect her, is against his very instinct. And so he will follow her, not letting her out of his sight. And Paro too, is getting more comfortable around him. She's starting to be herself around him, letting go and just enjoying moments. We saw this when she fussed with him about the eye drops in her eyes, when she let him feed her, when she climbed through the window so that she could stitch his button, and when she's trying to decide what gola she wants. And here, she frolics in the water. Her faith in him is rock solid. She knows he'd never let her drown and so she plays. Even when she slips, she knows he'd be there to catch her. That simple self-assurance in him, in her faith in him, is what makes Paro so special, and so different. And continuing the trend we have been seeing with them, they have a comfort with each other. The share pieces of themselves with each other, solidifying the trust that they've been building. Today we learn that Rudra won a medal in swimming. He learns she likes the beach. Sigh, if only the whole episode was this moment alone. But too soon, it ends.

This is the couple I expected. Two very opposite people that never have the need to step out of their personality but fully depend on the other to feel comfortable/function. At this point, after the crossover episode, I am at a loss over the leads and now consider both to be lost causes.
.
I am just going to quote this section and agree with every single aspect of your critical opinion.
.
.
.
Edited by puglet - 11 years ago
napstermonster thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#20
Look, I don't want to start a fight or have some BI fans who are currently hanging out here at our forum (Kamma ganna baisas! Have a lassi!) I have seen a few of them quite seriously and sternly examining every mention of their couple, but I just have to say--I found the interaction of Paro and Rudra ludicrously watered down at the dargah scene, AND the other in-love couple giving them marrage advice stuck i my craw--not because it was being given by the but because it would NEVER have been accepted by parud, no matter who did the advising.

I was actually fully prepared to nod violently when Rudra found his patni, at the Dargah and started to yell. I hoped she'd tell him--this unknown lady said if you loved me, you'd find me via dargah sponosed GPS, so i ran away with her to an indisclosed location trusting you to find me in Delhi via telepathic love. I looked forward to the Major then going ballistic on Paro for being an idiot. For not just for LITERALLY disappearing from a stalled Taxi, but mainly for the whole leaving with a pretty stranger bit. But then he...gives her a day off to run around with people they've just met because she wants to?


I found Paro doing that to be hugely anti-character too. She is much more wary, much more timid, and would NOT impose on two new friends this way, she would be shy as all hell, hiding behind Rudra.

I know BI fans will jump in and assure us that Aliya is simply that convincing a woman and Zain a master of male emotions or something, and that Paro and Rudra just go swept into confessions that they haven't made in the past 5 months with themselves, much less to strangers. But I dont watch your show, and I watch my own. So no. I'm not commenting on the BI couple (but one comment, banta hai---OH MY GOD the PDA...I understand the BI fans are going nuts with how out of character it was for these two with khullam khulla stuff, but it was especially off-putting for new viewers like myself. Sorry)


But to go on with what I DO know-- Rudra does not accept advice from a man he literally just met, as the TM mentioned in her fantastic post. But I would add: Paro does not disregard her major's feelings and concerns for her this brazenly, either. I don't care if the Dargah was glinting with gold leaf and rainbows, she would not walk out of her car and literally dissaparate into thin air with a women shes just met, when she is already with her Major inside that car.


She does everything with him glued to her side, and she likes it that way, frankly. More importantly, she would appreciate how insane her little walk-about would leave Rudra. She knows when it comes her, he has literally a complex about losing her and about ensuring her safety. He cant bear letting her leave their hotel room to go down one flight of stairs to see his commanding officer, and he's going to fine with her wandering through Delhi?


Also, finally--- I dont want to have ten people respond to my post as i am attacking BI or its main leads. I am not. I dont watch them, I dont plan to, so please don't be aggressive and say stuff like..don't watch don't comment (since obviously I watched the Mahasangam and saw what BI wanted me to see as well as RR's scenes). You don't know me,so Id appreciate some distance. RR ladies ..thoughts?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".