like GH said, change the channel if you dont like it [DT Note - Pg 3] - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

6k

Users

11

Likes

118

Frequent Posters

persadian thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: ttt1

every body works hard , not just people in entertainment business , sadly the praises and criticism is dependent on the end product in every field

and as far as i know nobody in the forum is issuing a legal notice to the makers , it is just simple opinions as loyal viewers who spend '20 mins' watching the show
i am not indebted to the makers for making this show means i wont buy everything so wont the majority of the viewers

so a maker would be more than eager to know what people disliked than what they like , cos that improves the work , that is the way it has to be

it is only people who blame it on cv's hard work to strongly oppose different opinion

how is it a discouragement i fail to understand
i find this extreme denial of another opinion other than ones own not healthy in a discussion site

nothing will happen if a episode is critiqued , it only gets better , or in simple words the makers know to handle criticism , it is their job ,



The purpose of watching tv is escapism, to experience something, not experienced before, even though rang rasiya is following saas bahu formula, at the same time, they are not, the twists in this show is what keeps us tuned in, the few who feel that the show is not staying true to the tried and tested same old boring formula are not broadening their horizon, just because paro seems amiable in a few episodes, then they are obviously butchering her character, she is being portrayed as a doormat, she has no spine, etc.

Discouraging, as in when you read a post bashing the show and its like did we just watch the same thing and thats all you could grasp...


sapphireblue thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: arishma108

I enjoyed the episode, I always do, I hope they portray him far more worse before showing them realise how they feel for each other, and becomes a joru ka ghulam, I always find the journey much more exciting than the destination, from all these sagas on tv, I prefer to watch rangrasiya, why, because the intensity is gripping.

Nowhere in the world do we all live the same way, watching a program means you get to experience something you havent been exposed to,

judging a fictional character: feminist or not, all women at the end of the day still have to go home, go into the kitchen and cook food, basic nature, going postal on a show written for a demographic largely based in these conditions is something we should accept, because it is harsh reality... dont complain about the weather if you are not going to do anything about it. These shows actually have an end result, where all learn something from them. And if this is a platform that is trying to teach something, to understand it, I would think the point needs to get across first.

Not all of our 5 fingers are the same, how do we expect to have the same brain, just because you believe in something, dont expect the next person to feel the same way, duh, even paro and rudra have spelt it out for us.

On an end note...I wish to see a very dark n dangerous rudra, because you know what, women actually do fall for men like that, I would actually like to know why, so show me, Im ready to watch anything these cv's throw at us viewers.

So if you dont like what you see, quite simple, change the channel and SUMO (shut up & move on) stop telling us about it, because we all lived thru' the last time viewers dictated how a show should be and see how well that turned out


Well said! Yes, as a viewer I've always liked the journey as opposed to the reaching the destination. Out of curiosity - which is the show that prompted you to comment "because we all lived thru' the last time viewers dictated how a show should be and see how well that turned out "?
tttttt1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: arishma108


The purpose of watching tv is escapism, to experience something, not experienced before, even though rang rasiya is following saas bahu formula, at the same time, they are not, the twists in this show is what keeps us tuned in, the few who feel that the show is not staying true to the tried and tested same old boring formula are not broadening their horizon, just because paro seems amiable in a few episodes, then they are obviously butchering her character, she is being portrayed as a doormat, she has no spine, etc.

Discouraging, as in when you read a post bashing the show and its like did we just watch the same thing and thats all you could grasp...


that is their honest opinion after watching the show ,just like what you wrote about your opinion both are not forced hence both are very significant

i didnot even say whether i liked the episode or not , i may or may not agree with the characters which are fictional , but bashing people asking them to shut up is uncalled for
and reasoning it by saying cvs work hard , i dont get it
as i said i will requote
makers spend lakhs in market research to get unadulterated opinion and here people are asking to skew the opinion and post only nice things that is ironic !

PS i generally dont post in thread that have a diagonally different opinion so that i dont spoil their fun , but because this post is directed at all and says to shut up and change the channel i replied

Edited by tttttt1 - 11 years ago
persadian thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: sapphireblue


Well said! Yes, as a viewer I've always liked the journey as opposed to the reaching the destination. Out of curiosity - which is the show that prompted you to comment "because we all lived thru' the last time viewers dictated how a show should be and see how well that turned out "?


I think they now tagged it "ek baar phir"
Swap-Arhi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#15
I enjoyed today's episode. Fultu entertainment! I am waiting for 8 vachans of Rudra to be broken by Paro bhaisa and it will be fun to see their journey of love.
flamingoAK thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Easter Egg Contest Winner (2022) Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Exprimere

If you have an opinion on the epi, please do express.


I'd not appreciate someone telling me to have a certain opinion of the episode, while at the same time telling me to accept differing opinion.

If you enjoyed the episode, please discuss it. There may be others who want to question it. The point of a "forum" is discussion, and all views have a room here.

I'd also say, please don't dismiss feminism with an "at the end of the day..." There are people out there working real hard to put an end to such "at the end of the day" suffering. And if these are fictional characters, then maybe you should be least bothered about the negativity and judgments happening on the forum, too?

And if the show does teach anything, it is even more important that the passivity of a character is questioned.

I know I own a remote, I shall make my own decision. Thanks.


Very good response!
-himu- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#17
i completely agree wid i enjoyed the episode so so much
chintu123 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Exprimere

If you have an opinion on the epi, please do express.


I'd not appreciate someone telling me to have a certain opinion of the episode, while at the same time telling me to accept differing opinion.

If you enjoyed the episode, please discuss it. There may be others who want to question it. The point of a "forum" is discussion, and all views have a room here.

I'd also say, please don't dismiss feminism with an "at the end of the day..." There are people out there working real hard to put an end to such "at the end of the day" suffering. And if these are fictional characters, then maybe you should be least bothered about the negativity and judgments happening on the forum, too?

And if the show does teach anything, it is even more important that the passivity of a character is questioned.

I know I own a remote, I shall make my own decision. Thanks.


Fully agree here. This dekhna hai to dekho seems to be the refrain of those who cannot argue thier points or take criticism like GH. A forum is meant for discussion and for putting forth different points view.

souro thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#19
Reiterating what I had said in a recent thread.
Trying to shut people up by just because their viewpoint does not match yours, won't be tolerated.
If you disagree with someone, argue logically without personally attacking or bashing the member. Everyone has equal rights to post here, whether it be to express their likes or dislikes. One group can't ask the other to shut up and move on. That's rude, against the forum COC and against the basic right of freedom of expression.

Just as we don't allow bashing (which is different from rational criticism) a show, celebrity, etc., similarly we don't allow bashing of members as well. Opposing viewpoints make for a healthy and stimulating discussion. Forcing everyone to have a single viewpoint is akin to having North Korea like society - very drab and delusional.
souro thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: arishma108


Imposing the reason for dislike of the episode, and judging the creatives who actually put the effort to entertain you for 20 minutes, which might not seem long enough to the viewer, but takes hard work for everyone involved, I find rude, we saw the darkness of this show, in the very 1st promo, we got hooked, now everyone wants to become the writer and change the plot as they wish. No, watch the show because you enjoy it, experience it because you want to understand it , dont discourage the rest of us because you are outraged because it hasnt gone your way...and when I say you, I actually mean whomever, not actually you, but if the cap fits...

Let's use your own logic and see if you understand.

You have bought a pack of X biscuit and it costed you 5 bucks. Unfortunately you didn't like the taste of X biscuit. So, you decide to tell your friends about your experience, that you tried X biscuit but didn't like it. Your friend tells you, it's just 5 bucks to you but the biscuit company had to put in lots of hard work to manufacture that pack of biscuit, so you should just shut up and buy another pack of biscuit if you didn't like it. How will you feel?

It's the same here. The viewer just invested 30 minutes of his or her time to watch that show. 30 minutes may not look long enough to you, but the viewer had to forego something to spend that 30 minutes watching the show. It's none of his/ her concern how hard the production house worked to make that 30 minute show. To the viewer what is of concern is the 30 minutes spent and whether he/she got entertained in return, just as in the previous scenario what would've been of concern to you is the 5 bucks you spent and whether you got good quality biscuit in return. In fact, in the case of a TV serial it does not remain constrained to just 30 minutes of a single day, it builds up to a much larger amount because you invest 30 minutes everyday; and when the storyline goes bad, you feel you've been cheated out of the whole time that you have invested till then in following the story. It's just like buying a 1000 page novel, and after reading 600 pages, you suddenly realise that the author is taking the storyline to a tangent that is entirely unpalatable to you.

As soon as someone decides to sell their product or puts it up for public scrutiny, the consumers have every right to criticise it if they don't like it (just as they have the right to praise it if they like it). Here the production house is selling a product in the form of a TV show and the viewer is buying it by spending 30 minutes of his/ her time. That makes the viewer (the consumer) perfectly eligible to criticise it and you can't tell him/ her to just shut up and change the channel.
Edited by souro - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".