.Dilwale. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#1

i came to the forum yesterday after almost a week and noticed some things bothering our new friends. basically the issues are;


1. Rasam are not being given good dialogues and enough screen time to perform.


Rasam Dialogues:

regarding the first issue. well, i honestly feel that it is true to some extent but not entirely. rahul may have OTT filmy dialogues but sam is given pretty good lines, the best amongst the newbies actually. so i don't necessarily think we can put the whole blame on the dialogues yaar.

Rasam Screen Time:

someone here said that priyanka and manish have not been given enough screen time. guys, aisa bilkul nahi hai! it's actually the complete opposite! mayanka ki entry ko 3 weeks hone waley hein. if you look at the episodes during these weeks, you'll find that priyanka and manish have in fact had the most screen space. if you don't believe me, please verify it yourselves.

Mayanka's Performance:

also yaar, everyone keeps saying that mayanka have not returned to their real potential yet because of this reason or because of that reason etc. i feel an actor needs to rise above all the flaws of a script and yet able to potray the scene with conviction. we can't really say that manish or priyanka will deliver but only;

if the dialogues are punchy.

the screenplay is perfect.

the director gives apt cues.

agar har waqt yeh cheezein poori hoon tu phir ek actor ka kya kaam reh jata hai? realistically apeaking, all these things are not always possible together in a scene especially in indian telly. an actor has to make do with what he or she is given and still deliver🤔


2. Shanak fans are biased and thus reluctant to accept Rasam.

i was kinda hurt to read that many of the new members feel that we are being unfair to rasam because of our love towards shanak. of'course it's natural to be biased towards one's favourite jodi but on this forum, i can proudly say that's not the case with most members.

in fact, we have always been the first ones to appreciate any good rasam scene and a good performance by manish or priyanka. you guys can come to the DT and CC and you'll see the same. as for our not being ardent fans of them as actors as yet, all i'll say is that they are improving but still need to make more of an effort. but that doesn't mean that we have tagged them as bad actors or that we only say such things regarding their performance.

i mean, have you guys ever noticed how much we scrutinize karan and yashashri regarding their expressions and acting. agar unka ek expression bhi idhar udhar ho jata hai tu we don't spare them at all. so compared to them, i feel we are giving rasam a lot of space. we are more appreciative than critical. i would say that we are hard on yasharan and not mayanka!😆

my darlings! most of us (shanak fans) have been blaming the dialouges and CVs for uninspiring rasam scenes. if we hated manish or priyanka, we would have outrightly said that they are not good actors. but we know that they have a lot of potential and can deliver so instead of targeting them, we have always blamed the CVs. please ab tu aap log aisa mat kaho k hum mayanka ko like nahi kartey and only side with shanak😊


P.S.

the purpose of this post is certainly and absolutely in no way to offend anyone. just clear up some misunderstandings that i see brewing at the forum. the new members who are mayanka fans don't know me but sehju and sid do. i know for sure that these two will take this post in the right spirit and explain my perspective to their friends.😳

it is also not a post for argumentative debate or camping. it's just a neutral opinion aimed at removing some misconceptions as they say, 'clear the air'. so please don't view it as something else. i beg you all!😆

would love to read all your views but let's try our best to keep the discussion healthy as in such topics there's always a chance of someone's feelings getting hurt!

Edited by zennnn - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

1.7k

Users

12

Likes

60

Frequent Posters

NinjaInPyjamas thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
Nice caption 😃
Everything that you've written here..I think you've summed it up really well..
I fully agree with you on the point that as ktdeewanis..😆😆 we've taken to manish pretty much nicely..he looks good, acts fine and hence is starting to slowly get incorporated in the show..😊 As for Priyanka..she is a bit inconsistent but there are days she has been good..esp in the flashback scenes..she acted poori weird and yet very likeable😆
I just hope that no comparison starts b/w kt and manish once their scenes come up...
_sana.Magic_ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Very nicely written...I truely agree with yr post
destinylove thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
@ zen very thoughful post well analysed I complelte agree with all said I have quite many times appreciated Rahuls looks and acting and even made threads though i am basically a shanak fan
or simple (yashu/kt)fan...
I have also appreciated priyanka...
However we have sometimes to say that we dont like certain things..
.it doesnot mean we are biased we only are interested in their onscreen
projection to be good that is all..
but having seen Shanak for such a long time one cannot expect us to give up our affinityor equalise with some one...However we do like Rahul./sam...no doubt on that...
we are hard on yashu/kt so many times..we are ruthless some times
but fully assure u this forum people are warm heartedand love everyone easily..
.so we defitely dont hate Rahul/sam and everyone is definitely warming upto them...some fastly some very slowly that is all...
395575 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
well when it comes to priyanka....i certainly disagree with everyone who says...tht she coudn't act at her best..
I accept the flaw of Cvs but that doesnt question the potential of priyanka bassi.....Why people forget she is an award winning actress and has been nominated for several times during LRL for best actress in both telly awards and ita awards....
i can purely understand tth she has entered a show...which is not up to her caliber...she deserves something much much better than this show.......I was never happy when i heard she is entering this show......but later i thought tht whatever happens...is for the good..
atleast she will be in the limelight and she can even get a good role in a lead show....and leave this asap.
As for manish....I have never seen him much before...so all i found him ok..
but yes i can sincerely rrequest to CV'S to get new ideas and finally wake up from the boring sleep..and develop somethin better😃
.Dilwale. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

@tanvi

tanvi! come now dear. kya hoa yaar? chalo bus ab chill ho jao!😳 i request you to read my post again because you seem to be raising the same issues which i have tried to address!😆

Edited by zennnn - 14 years ago
destinylove thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
yaar if anyone wants to have please have serious talks and differing opinions and
replies with critcal aspects at critics corner
This is a request and even moderator has told so that serious critcal talks better be restricted to one place...
.Dilwale. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

@shriya di

should i close this thread di?

Sid4TeamCanada thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: tweety_lovely

I accept the flaw of Cvs but that doesnt question the potential of priyanka bassi.....Why people forget she is an award winning actress and has been nominated for several times during LRL for best actress in both telly awards and ita awards....

well v have to also understand neetu that most ppl here have not seen lrl.. they have no idea who naina is... and thus they have no idea just how awesome PB is in acting.. for many rbo fans rbo was the FIRST time they ever saw pb... and to top it off - all pb's old fans (like me and sehj) had created such a hype abt her DAYS before she even entered... so we kind of raised the bar very high...., in such circumstances, where we have been wowing pb creating such a hype abt it.. for members who have never seen lrl wudn't know wht we meant until they saw/see TERRIFIC acting by pb..it makes sense na? if v were in their place, even v wud need some REAL TERRIFIC acting to seee ke haan bhai yeh sab hype is actor ke baare mein sahi hai the actor really is good! in order for the terrific acting - pb needs some WELL-WRITTEN TERRRIFIC bindaaas scenes! and that v have not been getting since her entry... there have been a few GOOD scenes.. but nothing extraordinary... the flashbacks have been AWESOME though... but other than that, they need to REALLY come up with some excellent scenes so pb cud show her splendid acting and PROVE to the fans who dod not know her from lrl that she indeed is a great actress😊
so my point is, most ppl r not FORGETTING that pb is award-winner, most ppl have just never seen her lrl to know how good she is... if i told u abt some actress u havent even heard the name of, and i start going crazy that she is award winning and all that - wud u accept that she is a splendid actress just based on the hype i create? no right.. ? infact becuz of all the excitement i create, u wud raise ur expectations too high for the "new" actress...
wht the prob here is, i still feel cv's need to handle sam well.. sam's entry scene: GREAT! it was TOO GOOD (well except for the cake snatching😕) PB's acting there in my opinion was reallly good! 😊and her later scenes when she meets with duck - that was too ggood as well.. but since the entry of rahul, she has been made all SERIOUS SOBRE by the cv's... she hardly says anything infront of rahul.. and i know that is becuz she is just too much hurt by him and she gets too lost in past to say anything - but i feel cv's need to bring back the bubblier side of sam.. the one we get to see in flashback.. becuz this way sam's character seems very inconsistent - and then for ppl who don't even know her, such scenes wuud not really help PB win their hearts, right?😳.. the fact that the girl who told shaan not to take tension abt anything is nowww taking rahul so seriously that she has become SOOOO QUIET... 😕 cv's need to REALLY pull up their socks andd handle sam's character well.. cuz it is a very difficult character! they need to balance out her fun side with her hurt side...😊
@zenn: awesome post yaar😃😃 .. and i agree that an actor has to shine regardless of punchlines and etc... per i still feel cv's are inconsistent with how they deal sam.. sometimes they handle her character very well.. while other times i feel they lose train of it... 🤔 for eg in the sam khanak scene: rather than trying to aboid khanak's looks.. sam shud've looked khanak straight in the eye, brought back that chiryp sarcastic attitude of hers, and in that attitude she shud have cross-confrronted khanak.. as to why she was questioning her like this... in a FIRM tone... this wud've eben wht i'd have expected from sam in such a scene... so i feel cv's need to be a bit more consistent in sam's case.....😳
Edited by Sid4TeamCanada - 14 years ago
Sid4TeamCanada thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
another factor here is also the fact that new actors need time to mould into their characters and the show - SPECIALLY if its an already running show that they e entering midway... when a new show starts with NEW ACTORS, for eg rbo, fans ususally have no expectations.. and the actors have it COMPARATIVELY EASY to make place in fans' hearts - becuz fans who watch the shows r ones who r interested in such storylines in the first place... but when new actors enter as MAJOR characters midway - they have to face fans' insecurities... for the first few weeks or even months they r probably dangling between the "we accept these characters" and "we do not accept these characters!" attitude amongst fans - we saw that rbo itself..! howevery1 was discussing the logic behind the new entries and whether they want the new entries to stay or not : so, cud v have expected PB to win so quickly over fans in such times?? ... and if the entering actors r already established actors like pb and mr, then they have their bars quiet highly raised by new and old fans... thus... it is comparatively much harder for them to easily make space in new fans' hearts......😊
Edited by Sid4TeamCanada - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".