When Evil isn't shown Evil: Shaad

Intuitive thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1

Good and Evil- these are two things I am always unsure of! Sometimes I believe there isn't anything called evil and good- just a game of fate. The World is Big- I don't believe so. Everything that happens has a reason and that is written in our fate. The Evil is just influenced by the Maya(Illusion) to be Evil, everyone is good. But, there are times I am forced to think otherwise. However, I come to the conclusion that a person influenced by Maya(Illusion) turns evil and then he becomes evil for which he has to pay price, be it this life or the Seven Janamas as believed by some.

Thinking, why I am making this post and just ranting? The so called Qubool Hai show has had so many negative and positive characters. However, every character was clear and shown what the character was. No doubts in distinguishing if it was Evil or Good. But, I wish they had shown why Tanveer was cruel and other negative characters were cruel like Shashi Kapoor, Nayi Sanam and Faiz was shown. But, these are just some of the loopholes of this serial and lets leave it aside. The question now is- Shaad?

Who is he? Good or Evil?

He is shown like a good person, kind-hearted and what not. But, let me come down to what he is.

1. He came out as a savior of an unknown woman and told she is his wife!

Conclusions derived will be he is a good guy who has just done something in order to save her. So, he is selfless.

Second conclusion: He saved her because she was struggling because of his army men or whatever. Point of selfless, is gone.

What if it was a girl out of nowhere coming with any relevance to him and asks him help. Leave it- that's again up to him.

What would he have done if they told she was the one who witnessed the crime? He would have somehow forced her to answer. Fine, that's an army issue. Leave it.

Out of the first action, I don't know if he is good or bad?

I doubt if he told Biwi, because she clinged to him.

2. He continued the lie

He could have told she has lost her memory and he found her on the way, and they could have started searching the her identity and also carried on the Shashi Kapoor issue. But, he had to continue it. Why? He didn't think of her? Take the responsibility that comes along with having an amnesic woman in front of you and he is an Army Major? Deceived a bride because of his own selfish reasons using an amnesic woman.

3. Behaving Like A Husband:

When you know somebody isn't your wife and you are just acting, how can you behave like a real husband, touching her, caressing her?

4. Closed The Missing File:

This is the biggest question of his righteousness. He didn't take up the responsibility of finding her, until she told and again he closed it.

5.Restricting her feelings, her choice:

Right from when everything started, he hasn't spared about Jannat, he thinks of Meri Jannat.

So, how the hell is he not negative? And does he have a dark past? If so, the cvs didn't show it. Now, he is selfish or no? He is evil or no? So, why not he bear the fruit of it. He isn't mentally unbalanced but just selfish and on the top of it he is an ARMY MAJOR'.

Have the cvs even shown reaction to at least one of these actions above. Instead, they whitewashed him by spoiling other character. Whoever thinks Shaad is still not negative, I don't understand you. If the same happened with you, what would be your reaction.I feel disgusted that still some consider him positive. Shaad is the worst character I have ever seen. He isn't even a character, just characterless. He is plain evil, who can do anything for what he wants.

I ranted all this, so that from now I don't bother about Mr.Shaad, get frustrated. So, I close his chapter.

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

1.9k

Users

9

Likes

94

Frequent Posters

simran_singh_24 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
This devil wears uniform and the Satan worshipping Cvs love him.
The way they see him is very different from how we see him and he is shown.
As long as the Cvs don't understand or refuse to see the gravity of his so called "mistakes" and actions inspired by "love", he 'll never be shown evil.
In their attempts to make him good, they'll bring down all the other characters.
this show is currently unwatchable for me as all my favourite characters are ruined beyond recognition to prop up this one character.
Edited by simran_singh_24 - 10 years ago
Intuitive thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Sim, I'll reply later. Gotta go
Edited by darlingpinks - 10 years ago
MrDarcyfan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Pinks - We have ranted for the past 3.5 months that Shaad's behavior is not reflective of a positive character. But CV's want to pretend that falling in love absolves him of ALL responsibilities he has as a human being with truth and decency. "All is fair in love and war" is a cliched and cheesy line used to excuse any number of immoral / unacceptable behaviors.


One letter does not absolve him of what he did for 3 months. They always showed him as selfish and obsessed. That is what he is. As for his character? I think we have been shown time and again through his actions, just what sort of character he is. The irony is that CV's themselves are now trying to pretend he is something else! They have ruined all the characters we loved to make HIM look good. In the process this show is now an unpalatable mess! I hope the CV's are happy with their efforts. They have managed to drive away even the loyal fans who stuck to this show for nearly 3 years, all to prop up this one "dubious" character.


I wont speak for anyone who finds his behavior acceptable. Not my problem. I personally do not find his behavior acceptable, or his actions "Gentlemanly". If he was in fact a gentlemen, he would have maintained a distance from a women who was only letting him close, coz she thought he had a "relationship" with her that gave him that authority. But he always continued to cross the line. He would have told the truth a lot earlier and done his duty as an Officer of the armed forces towards a displaced and lost individual. But he did not! It was always about him! His case, his obsession, his love, etc etc. It's ALL about Shaad! Therefore, in my eyes, he is neither a good person, nor is he a gentlemen! I know many good people, and many gentlemen, and neither behave the way Shaad has! Enough said.
Edited by MrDarcyfan - 10 years ago
--Aishwarya-- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Good post!!

I have been mentioning this same nonsense along with other fellow members as well...

I am a SaHil shipper comes secondary...even if Sanam was an unmarried woman, what Shaad is doing is NOT acceptable...who is he to decide how she should live the rest of her life?? First you continued with the lie because you wanted to track Shashi Kapoor through her - SELFISHNESS

Next you suddenly developed be-intehaa mohabbat for her and due to that without a second thought you closed her missing person file, without even thinking she has to know her past and must be safely returned to her family who must be frantically searching for her and must be living with the perception that she is dead...you wanted her in your life, so you gave no heed to that - SELFISHNESS

Next you lost all your family and had no one in the world, but your Jannat...fine, you lose all your family members at a single moment is so heartbreaking, but that doesn't mean you will capture an unknown woman with you and wish to keep her by your side your whole life...in that case all such persons losing their loved ones can go and bring some random person and keep with them, telling I lost everyone, now I want you to be with me - SELFISHNESS

First when Aahil requested them to come with him to Bhopal, while at Dharamsala promising good treatment for Sanam, he refused. But as soon as he got to know Shashi Kapoor is in Bhopal, he nodded a yes. So its because of Shashi Kapoor you agreed, if for Jannat its not required - SELFISHNESS

You wanted to marry her...that too according to you, second marriage...first of all, how can you even think of marrying an amnesiac person dude?? Don't you know its a crime and even getting any legal activities done with a mentally unstable woman is illegal?? And you are supposed to an army officer...holiness!! So, what if one day after marriage, she gains her memory and asks you who are you...you would tell I am the Be Intehaa lover of you who married you while you were under Amnesia?? Her feelings and her life has no importance here - SELFISHNESS

And yes...all these selfish activities will disappear in thin air with a letter and even in that you apologize and expect her to accept your love, but still you don't feel its necessary for her to know who she is...she is your Jannat and you can't live without her is all that matters!! And you are the so called disciplined army officer in "love" according to CVs!!!

Coming to the PDA, Shaad just finds opportunities to get all touchy with her...the fact that she is not his wife doesn't seem to knock his brain only...right now mahaan Shaad has denied from entering into the marital relationship, and gave even mahaanta filled reasons only, instead of the truth...but after this illogical nikaah of theirs, they are planning to enter the marital world...in short an amnesiac woman would be physically harassed and used, with the man knowing she is an amnesiac...

And this man is supposed to be a gentleman and a man in love!!!!
muskaan17rocks thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Amazing post
well this can surely be the topic of discussion and surely the discussion can go on and on
shaad's character is really a mixture of good and evil or maybe purely evil, i am still confused regarding this
Ofcourse with no second thoughts he had done wrong with sanam/jannat.
Maybe the cvs are at first trying to show him a bit positive and paving way for his future negative role when he gets to know jannat's true identity to which i think that they are failing miserably as he has already become a pain to the eyes
just hoping for the best
i guess this post was needed in the forum so thank you for making one😊
FazidaK18 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Honestly, the only good thing Shaad has ever done was protect Sanam from those goons in the beginning. Otherwise he has been extremely deceptive and dishonest and I honestly can't even buy his love for Jannat. It's quite pathetic. I can't believe how any good guy could even carry on with such a lie in the first place. I have come to really despise his character. He along with witchy annoys the hell out of me now.
Orla thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
Shaad Aftab Khan-His name is enough for me to curse him..Such a big idiotic,A*******,..
Edited by Enigmatic_Angel - 10 years ago
Ankudi15 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
shaad along with witch has become a pain

gud post ofcourse and a right one

why do they want such characters in their show or atleast kerp them without dumbing the leads

Is there any character whose action you can justify

aahil brought witch back in the house that too on no condition..he coukd haave atleast set a limit or condition for her but no (okay i get you wanted to bleach shaad but there are thousand tricks and ways to execute) why make aahil dumb??

Again he only cries seeing shaad not question him...why the hell is he so scared ...and what is wrong in questioniong

jannat chaemoflagues b/w sanam and jannat

shaad is shown mahaan like hell

you ppl try to fulfill all kind of wild fantasies thru your witch character...hell dishgusting

and a new entry...lol he was hilariously dressed

hey did anyone notice sk obsession with jacket lol it was funny how she wore it without mask and looks like the jacket is foldable ..howcome she carries it everwhere..ahaan superwoman
sanam 2 is witch
sk is superwoman
lol
cvs are funny
sahil333 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
Awesome post!
I just can't stand this shaad, Jannat and that witch anymore. So irritating they are.
Would be great if you link this thread to F-32, Zeetv and 4Lions.
Great comments everyone. 👍🏼

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".