Surbhi Jyoti - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

4k

Users

14

Likes

131

Frequent Posters

micshy thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#11
hey chillax... i dont think people are bashing SJ... the whole dress issue that was being discussed was that it was not appropriate fr a setting in Pakistani family... we dint call SJ vulgar o obsene or antything... "WE SURELY KNOW TO KEEP A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN CHARACTER AND AN ACTOR"

About SJ ... i really really like her... shes one of the most awesomest newcomer who acts so wonderfully... shes such an natural actor ... a pro at doing emotional scenes... they come off as so so natural dont look like shes acting them out... Although i do sometimes feel that she should give some input to the creatives as well... but anyways ,,,, i really like her and would defo look for anything she comes next in ...


about the car scene u hv mentioned that was a purely awesome scene... one of my favorite scenes among the whole QH time... and best fo the AsYa as well... infact i liked the whole track where Zoya shared the secret of Abbu with Asad and then how they connected more emotionally ... then Asad taking her to the grave was just brillinat and excellently enacted by SJ ... 👏👏👏
tejaswie thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#12
Thank you for making this post :) this girl surbhi has done double role since many months but all I saw was criticizing her characters in show , didn't see any appreciation post for her hardworking doing a double role on daily basis .. so this post made me happy .. she as a person is dedicated and loyal to her work irrespective of the story , scenes .. If she has some power she would not allow those many illogical murder attempts on her character sanam, do mujra dance , get treated by her hubby like a servant , got an almost slap by her hubby etc .. even after all these she always kept saying she love her role and her work .. I for one feel this girl at least deserve something for her loyality towards the show .. the best thing can be the love and support from fans .. may God bless her ..
thanks again for this post .. this is the only positive post I am seeing in the forum since many months ..
MrDarcyfan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#13
I guess the makers of these shows treat actors like models in clothes! Models show the clothes! They don't decide what it looks like or how it's preseted or the design! If they speak up, I guess they will be told to put on the clothes or walk away! (I remember a scene in PC's movie Fashion where a designer insulted her when she asked him to make a change to his design, but later when she had the power, she insulted him back).


But looks like in Indian TV industry even the actors with clout can't do anything much about story! So SJ being relatively new probably can't influence! But I think if everyone makes a point to speak up when needed, maybe the culture of terror will change! These awful PH's and producers think they can treat the actors in any way they like! Give them any crap to act, any dumb meaningless dialogues or illogical and sometimes cheap looking scenes etc! But they all have to bow down and do it, or they will be replaced! It is really awful and unfair!


I respect SJ! She is a good actress! Works hard and committed! Good qualities, but sometimes people "Abuse" these things! Looks like GK is taking advantage of her good will sometimes, and not thinking of how things impact SJ. Only about whatever BS she wants to show!


So I want to clarify, I like Surbhi and have no issue with her at all! It is because of her I stuck around for Season 2, even after the awful end to Season1. But this time even she can't hold me for long, if this story does not start to make sense! Coz right now it has SO many moving parts and lots of illogical things happening, and I can't even see where this is going? At least last season we knew the twins reuniting and Tanveer fall was the point! This time I have NO idea what the point is? I am a planner, so for me, to not known where I am going does not appeal that much!
Edited by MrDarcyfan - 10 years ago
SurbhikiPankhi thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#14
Thankyou for this post! <3 🤗
I'll agree as much as I love Seher, I'm really biast towards Zoya. She is what made me love Surbhi in the first place! But I'll have to say I think she kept up the twin thing for long enough! And that has got to tire out anyone! Kudos to her!
Male leads come and male leads go in Qh, SJ stays. 😆 (Not a very good idea but still.)!
Shailu.. thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#15
Post is too good she is a amazing person n a talanted actor n she is just awesome in acting i didn't feel for one time that she one person that playing 4 characters every time i see her as sanam n seher i feel like they are really twins n two different persons i just love her on screen and off screen she is a gem person
Actomyo thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#16
SJ is one actress of QH who has been bashed right from the beginning. Initial days of QH for being ugly, being manly, later on for not being 'Sita' of her co-star Ram/Rams in following vanvaas and now for 'allegedly' not speaking up against the ongoing tracks, for not being a rebellion bandit queen against the creatives' un-creative insane tracks!
How many of us know exactly what's going on the sets of QH? Are we present there to see whether one actor/actress disagrees or shows displeasure with a track/scene or not?
We know only what they speak on in front of the camera of a channel. Both her co-stars expressed displeasure on the camera when they had pretty much decided to quit or move out or bored and had options open outside. When they got on board QH they were all pretty established actors and they have confident that they can get anywhere. It's not the same for SJ, it's her first and if she walks out of the show or gives statements against the ph in her maiden show, she will earn negative points or come across as arrogant for other PHs too.
Above all Gul and Gorky are her mentor, she has said it many times, it's not easy or polite to talk against your mentors. When there was a rumor making headlines that SJ is throwing tantrums and she is likely to be replaced for the same, Gul came out in the open quickly and rubbished all. That shows the bonding/care they have. For KSG and KVB 4 lions are just another PH that they have worked but for SJ it's her maiden PH plus mentors.
Anyhow people are free to have opinions and I can't stop anyone from that, so just put forth mine.
I admire SJ, I can't say she is an amazing actress though she has been amazing in few scenes as TM mentioned, otherwise she is a decent actress but I love her offscreen persona from what I have seen in IVs and social networks. Hope she does the best and gets the best.
Actomyo thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: SurbhikiPankhi

Thankyou for this post! <3🤗

I'll agree as much as I love Seher, I'm really biast towards Zoya. She is what made me love Surbhi in the first place! But I'll have to say I think she kept up the twin thing for long enough! And that has got to tire out anyone! Kudos to her!
Male leads come and male leads go in Qh, SJ stays.😆(Not a very good idea but still.)!



Same here, I am a little biased towards her Zoya. Zoya will be SJ's best till she does another iconic character. I remember the days while traveling in bus daily, I would listen those gushing of Zoya and her Mr.Khan. I recently met a girl from the different state and she is called as Zoya by her friends because of her obsession to that character 😆
Also SJ looked fresh and beautiful as Zoya, now she is worked up so much, double roles was a real bad idea when it didn't serve any purpose to story finally, though I loved Seher.
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#18
SJ got a lot of flak for even that mini skirt scene.😆 I found her very very cute in it...😳 One of the few actresses who can make a mini look innocent.
U R talking about the graveyard sequence, I guess...SJ looked like an angel in white there...She looks like one now too, in the black burqa...just that she has lost a lot of weight.😭

On the forum bashing her...I guess some emotions went overboard...😊

Happens...Just like actors get bashed when they want to move on for better opportunities career wise, leaving fans of a couple in distress..Actresses get bashed when they decide to move on in reel life with a new guy.😉😆 Don't support or criticise either group so long as the emotions don't spill over.

In any case, SJ did not get half the criticism she received for moving on after KSG left...Or 1/ 10 of what another actress got when she decided to stick on with a love story being ended when the ML quit..

I am not saying it is OK to bash an actress...It is definitely not OK.

It is just that SJ was different- naive before.
She used to question the tracks before- not any more. She must be too tired. Or she doesn't care any more...
I guess fans are more frustrated with the storyline and wonder why the actors cannot do something to change that. KV quit because he had nothing to do for months, other than ill treat Sanam...SJ stayed on because she got a variety to play...the spotlight has never shifted from her. It is not fair to one actor- does not mean it is the fault of the other actor.

TBH, I feel the fan reactions are nothing compared to what I have seen in the past.

Totally agree with U. SJ is one of the most talented actresses around!👏👏👏
The girl is a dream to watch...I hope the script doesn't let her down.
It is already looking down, with re- enactment of Tanveer- Zoya scenes.🥱

Thank U for taking time out to appreciate SJ like this.😊

chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: MrDarcyfan

I know I said I was dissapointed with Surbhi for agreeing to do that scene! Because I think the scene sent the wrong messages about the situation that women was stuck in! Her clothes were never the issues, it is HOW her clothes were presented!


They did that on purpose so that she has to seek the help of Shaad to dress! They could have put her in a more covered outfit and that would not have been necessary! So the whole thing was a set up! What I objeted to was the fact that this women is in delusion that this man is her husband! So she let him hook her blouse and tie her dori! NOT a Liberty a women would allow ANY random man!


Then they show him actually doing up her blouse and trying to make it look like an intimate moment between a real couple! That was very irresponsible of the makers and I STAND by what I said, because it is true! They have dealt with this whole subject in a very casual and irresponsible manner! They just wanted to use that scene to show something "risky" between two strangers, when it was really not needed to further the narrative! So whatever I said,I stand by it!


As for SJ as an actress? She is very good and very talented! I also think maybe she dosen't want to quit coz this is her first show! Maybe she also deferes to the makers more than a senior actor would! They clearly protested against the story. (KSG did, KV did) but I don't know if SJ does! The other part was she came on the outtake segments and said she is "enjoying" doing these scenes and I think some people got mad when they heard that! I know what she meant, but it was a poor choice of words on her part, given the nature and context of the scene that they had just shot!

But as a performer I think she is great, and she has done very well indeed!


As for the BCC complaint stuff, most of us think this show has too much crap in general. Espeically violence! So some decided to complain about that! The scene didn't air, so that itself is no longer an issue! As for the Sanam being a "mujerewali?" I thought that was UTTER BS at the time and I said so! Personally that scene sucked! But that was STILL Sanam's choice! She chose to do that! Where as in the blouse hooking scene, she only "Chose" to invite Shaad to look at her and touch her, coz she was mislead! It is the lack of choice I objected to! If a women excersises her choice, whatever she is doing, then it is her decision. But if she is mislead, then it is not! The makers know the difference. They just choose to ignore it!


Mandy!!!

I get U perfectly.

You know that scene in IPK where Nanhe for a moment admired Khushi's back...

What was that scene for?

It was for ASR to burn...and he remedied the disgusting situation immediately.👏👏👏

This scene in QH...was utter carp. First of all, when does a couple get a hook scene?- When they have been physically attracted for months...or like in IPK, for a purpose. This hook scene was totally out of context..it served no purpose other than a WOMAN BEING HUMILIATED...and HUMILIATION it is, I feel. Though it is none of Sanam's fault.

Ideally, that scene would have been beautiful , had Sanam's hair tumbled down the instant he started staring at her back...and he looked away. Unfortunately, it sent the wrong message across.

And of all the things...Hooks😲...HOOKS!😆 What are these CVs smoking???🤢 A dori would have sufficed more than enough. None of SJ's heroes have gone down till the hooks so far...and this guy is a complete stranger!🤢

And SJ's choice of words..Yes , Poor...and Yes, interpreted in the wrong way. She didn't even mean this scene.

I hope this post and discussion clarifies what is the issue to at least people who REALLY WANT TO KNOW WHAT THE PROTEST WAS ABOUT!
Edited by chicksoup - 10 years ago
224529 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#20
I agree 100% with your post. I personally found the bashing; she and Jannat, got for the scene OTT. She was abused verbally and it was horrendous to read. But now it seems people have the case of short term amnesia because suddenly the whole thing is being played as being disappointed in the track and the scene when most of the posts were about how she was dressed as an item girl on a kotha(Brothel) entertaining clients. It was described as VULGAR, disgusting, "almost naked", sickening, cheap and trashy. I won't deny, I warred between deep amusement and deep disgust when reading such posts. No matter what people claim now, those above words were used to DESCRIBE the DRESS. It's understandable when you hit out at the Prod House for such scenes but to abuse the character as bimbo and stupid for that scene and the actress for acting out that scene is just terrible. As someone who works in this industry, let me tell you, an actor has no say in the scenes unless he/she is a really big shot. And that was a thing of the past. Nowadays there are actors dime a dozen outside the sets infact. If you speak out, you are labelled as a problem actor and accused of throwing tantrums before they kick you out. Not many prod house are willing to give you a chance after that.

And I personally found nothing wrong in that scene. It was there just to highlight that she feels disconnected to Shaad as a husband. That was all there to it. But it was blown out of proportion and everyone involved in that scene was abused horrifically. Well to each his own. People have different opinions and perceptions but even the members who had no problems with that scene were bashed as hormonal teenagers/aunties. It was moral policing out and out and thank god the mods took action on it.

Anyway, she is a wonderfully talented actress and I've never seen Zoya but I admit, Seher is my favorite character in the show so far.
Edited by In-Sanity-Metis - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Qubool Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: minakrish

7 months ago

💘Karan & Surbhi for ZOUK | Valentines 2025💘 [Added New Pics]

What a brilliant start to 2025, with Karan and Surbhi collaborating for ZOUK Bags for Valentines!💘 👜 Sharing photoshoot pictures here:

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".