Mystery Behind The Massacre

Seher's traumatic experience as a child caused her to block certain memories. The happy ones will come first then the bad ones.

My theory

I think she is the key to what happened after Dilshad left. I don't think Seher just ran out into the road and got lost. I think the Screaming and crying dilshad heard when looking for seher could have been Seher's crying for Mama.. or Sanam's cries mixed with Seher's. I think Seher went back in the house looking for her mama.

Somehow Tanu did not see her, but seher prob knows what went on in the house after it was on fire and what happened when the police arrived. As you know me.. I do not think Zoya is dead..

1. It's possible that Seher found her parents in the room before it caught on fire. Police and Firemen arrive as well as the ambulance. Maybe Zoya is checked and has a very faint pulse.. Asad too. Seher is screaming and is holding on to her mother while the police try to pull her away so they can be taken to the hospital. When they load them up in the ambulance, Seher is sent with a child protective services. Seher is distraught and while no one is looking, runs off in search for the ambulance. She gets lost and prob sleeps on the streets. The traumatic day, she got to block in her mind after awhile.

2. Sanam on the other hand saw who the culprit was. She was there when Tanu had just finished stabbing them for the last time and walked out. Put the two girls stories together.. you have their experience. Raziya would probably come in to say how is that possible. The police never found bodies. Maybe they are not dead. Now time to investigate post massacre. I'm really shocked that police did not find ANYTHING. Not a Body. THAT speaks Volumes to me.

Of course it could be that the whole thing was a set up as i previously said sometime ago.

Isn't it strange that when Zoya's dad entered the house to meet Zoya after two years, Raziya was not there with him? Is it possible that after Tanu's secret was out, Tanu realized that Raziya sold her out. After Siddique and Raziya leave the mansion after Zoya disowns her father two years go by and she contacts Raziya and threatens to destroy her, but promises to spare her if she helps her out. Raziya knows how dangerous Tanu is and decides to hear what she wants. Tanu tells her that she knows she was kicked out of the house by Zoya. She tells her they could get revenge. Raziya agrees for Tanu's benefit, but later tells Zoya's father of the conversation. Siddique contacts Asad and tells him about what was told to him. That Tanu was coming after them and probably how Tanu planned on killing them. Tanu always seemed to confide her plans into Raziya

Asad, who seems to have a good relationship with the police, always arriving at a moment's notice, contacts them. The police decides they have to do a drama. Let Tanu think she stabs them. Just imagine how it is done in the movies? Special blood packs attached in certain parts of the body so that when the knife goes in, it will appear it punctured flesh but only punctured the blood pack. Remember Tanu had only one eye, so she couldn't possibly see what she was doing properly. Maybe Zoya had initially the pink top on and changed it for some reason to set their plan in motion?

And where did the servants disappear too? Did Asad relieve them of their duty to get them out of the house for Tanu's arrival?

As I said before, the old man knew a lot. How come? Was he part of the police force 20 years ago and was involved in the set? Or was he one of the villagers who secretly hid ASYA until they could leaave the city? Did they leave the city or are they still in Bhopal?

There was a part where she stabbed Zoya in the foot. I do think that actually happened and was unexpected. I'm thinking that Dilshad probably knew about the plan, or maybe not. I don't know what about Tanu that they could never hold her long enough in jail but maybe they did not expect her to get away. Maybe the police were not close by. They could not cause alert to the people in the village, to Tanu and least of all Raziya and maybe Asad said that they would handle the situation (not expecting Tanu to set the house ablaze) . They probably did not trust her still so they could not give her details of their plan.

No one probably knew what time Tanu was coming but were waiting. Maybe they planned for Dilshad and the children to meet ASYA later, once things were safe. BUT when ASYA learnt that Tanu escaped they contacted dilshad maybe leaving a message, realising their lives were still at risk, deciding to tell her that, to protect the children, they have to stay "dead" forever.

Also, at the beginning, Seher was probably with them but they knew that if Tanu ever hunted them down again, Seher will not escape the next time. They decide painfully to have her put in the orphanage where Zoya had worked previously or maybe she was given to a trusted servant or friend. We think that she gave herself the name "Suneri" What if Zoya/Asad had her name changed to protect her in case Tanu knew her identity.

Something caught Seher's attention when she walked in the mansion to get that flashback. I do not think it's a WHO.. but a WHAT.

Please do not think i'm crazy as it may seem impossible but with the info we have been getting, I think red flags have been raised to make it possible.

Some may think that after revealing that Tanu killed their parents.. the story ends there. I think this revelation is FAR from over. Seher may only remember for a time up to when Dilshad and Sanam disappeared from her sight. Maybe she also remembers seeing SAHIL on the floor as she went back inside looking for them. To her they are dead. For awhile that is what she'll remember. But later on, she will get more flashbacks.. and is confused. She will probably get flashbacks of what happened after she finds her parents. Maybe of her with them after they left the mansion.

Once it is revealed that their parents maybe alive.. the next step in the story. The twins will want to find their parents. During all this rrevelation... Sahil story continues. If this is how I think the story is being played.. then I'm really excited as for months I have been thinking that ASYA are alive. I have seen so many fake death stories on soaps in my life that sometimes you could see one miles away. Too much details in the tragedy for it not to be real, right? Twist is approaching to catch you by surprise. I would like to see the girls find Zoya's laptop in the room. It was there in plain sight. I want them to turn it on and find a prerecorded message from their parents revealing the set up.. maybe Seher has the password hidden in her memory.

But I love the theory like seriously! 😳

I loved your write up. However, I do believe that AsYa are dead...

U know the back story of why AsYa had to die, I hope ...I mean the offscreen story.RV was roped into play Asad after KSG had to leave...and teh story was written for four months...They rushed all the tracks to finish off AsYa story..and had to finish them off...SJ and Amrapalii- Alka- Shalini are the only ones from the old cast...RV has said his goodbye formally- he will never be back as Asad...neither will KSG be.

I also feel the whole murder scene, though gory was a sadly beautiful ending to AsYa- they died holding their hands together, seeing Sanam with Dilshad...their spirits have guided their little girls back to Bhopal...That is how I see the story.😳

Seher had to be separated, because the whole idea behind twins is to have a Sita- Gita track.😊

It could not have been foreseen, because Najma and Siddiqui did die for real too.

I don't remember exactly what Raz told about the bodies...but I feel whatever logic it may or may not have is to just protect Seher. Tanveer does not know Zoya had twins, I think. Quite unlikely that Raziya knew too...She lost her daughter and her husband much before the massacre...Gafur died for her the day she decided to kill him...I think her story is true...she stayed homeless...and teh place burned down- she lost her hair. It was a mirror to Tanveer's public humiliation at Raziya's hands in Season One. It is to probably show us that the tables have turned!😊

Tanveer tries to count the bodies, since Sanam talks about an 'alive ' connection...she starts counting. Asad and Zoya are dead...Dilshad is in coma...In her near family, no one is left behind. Who is Sanam connecting to? Who did she- Tanveer- miss out on?👏 And Raziya never mentions there was a twin who could have survived...prob because she does not know. The fbs are there not because Raziya was there...she has heard about it...Tanveer has probably described it graphically to her...Just like Raziya herself described once how she kliled Zoya's mom...

Hi. I understand what you are saying., but I am sticking to my theory. They would not even have to show ASYA in a big way to show they are alive. A video tape recording done 20 years ago explaining to the children...or Maybe we'll see the back of a man... (Asad) and Surbhi will of course play a 46 year old Zoya for the scene. But they would NOT have to get back Raqesh or KSG to do it.

Raziya said no bodies were found. And the police did not let ANYONE get in the house. They took it over that day. The old man knew A lot. I do think there is MORE to this "massacre" than meets the eye. I have seen many of this type of stories on American Soaps. And the twist was, the characters were alive. faked deaths.

I think if they had no other choice, in regards of keeping them safe so that if Tanu finds them again, the children would not be around to harm them. Even though Zoya grew up without parents, she knows that her children's safety is more important. As I said, also, maybe they were supposed to meet up but could not. I think right now it's a wait and see as there seems to be more to this mystery than meets the eye.

Just my opinion.

Actually killing the lead/ s is the new fashion in Indian soaps!

Over the past one year a lot of couples have been separated / united by death...😊