The Jury's in ... for me anyway!

Sb111 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1

I waited to write this post until I had watched today's episode.

First of all, for all of those who watched the episode and enjoyed it you have every right to your opinion as I have every right to my opinion.

I watch this show eagerly and loyally and have from the very first episode. Correction ... watched ... these days I can take it or leave it and even then I don't get the same sense of enjoyment that I used to. Over the course of the last year I fell in love with the love story of AsYa and have been greatly impressed by the talent of KaBhi. In fact, even when I wasn't totally happy with the story I still watched because of how much I appreciated the acting of Karan and Surbhi.

Was it a totally new and fresh concept? No. But it was definitely executed to perfection and always left me wanting more. I can watch old AsYa scenes over and over because they are that good and I can't say that about any other show that I watch.

Was it always logical? No. But I didn't have to make excuses for it either ... these days I have to make excuses for my own lack of intelligence for watching this nonsense. And no it is not all okay now just because they showed that the Zoya Ayaan marriage was a MU because it is still illogical! They both have cell phones and *wow* only use them to say "haan". What garbage. Ayaan could have stayed with Humera and called for help. Zoya should have called her fianc ... didn't she think of how worried he would be? Nooo logic to be found anywhere! And if they go on to legitimize things as some of the spoilers suggest ... ugh!

Was I going to give this story a chance ... just like the whole Billi fiasco? Yes. But OMG what a disappointment. This is beyond anything that I can justify. And I'm sorry but my optimism was all used up in the Billi track and I don't look for the silver lining, the symbolism, or give the writers the benefit of the doubt anymore. The success of this show to date has been the love story of AsYa and for the writers to switch gears now is just unacceptable to me. There is no turning back. In fact, ever since they decided to put the spot light on Tanveer and sidelined the potentially brilliant immigration officer track the show has not been the same for me. Only recently did we have some romantic AsYa scenes and even those were overshadowed by this upcoming track. And now I am left feeling like ... that was it???? That was all we'll get? Even if the end game is AsYa ... that's not good enough. An AsYa wedding on the last epi is not good enough. I would love to watch the AsYa relationship flourish and grow within marriage. There is so much potential there. The Guffar track takes on a whole new element if AsYa are married. Or is that just me?

I feel cheated as a viewer. I feel like an idiot for tuning in to a show that I lacks logic and sacrifices its winning formula (read AsYa) at the altar of the TRP's. My only hope now is that the TRP audience speaks loudly enough for the writers to understand that a tightly written script is more important than illogical twists and that it's not too late. For now, I'll watch when the mood strikes or not ...

Signed,

D3 (Depressed, Disillusioned and Done)

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

1.6k

Users

9

Likes

80

Frequent Posters

webuser7 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Well said. I was very disappointed with today's episode too.

Issues I had (you raised some too):
1. The Imam/Maulvi (sorry, I am non-Muslim, so don't know the difference) recognized Ayaan but did not ask him where his family is?
2. Coincidentally the original 7th bride's name is Zoya (although they spelt it in Hindi as Joya), so they assume she is the bride but the groom changed? No one questioned that? All names were on that list!
3. I thought they had to say Qubool Hai 3 times. I think they said "Haan" twice. In fact Ayaan's response sounded annoyed. No one questioned that?
4. Tanveer's goons couldn't recognize Zoya's outfit?!
5. Why didn't Ayaan call for help from the same room as Humeira?
6. Why not ask the people gathered there for help. The goons didn't have guns.
7. Why didn't Zoya ask Asad for help when she was talking to him?
8. Why didn't Ayaan ask Rashid to send cops to the place?

I am sure there will be more questions after tomorrow's episode as obviously something or someone makes Zoya move to SM! So, for me this is completely illogical as the Nikaah is void!
immigreat54 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: webuser7

Well said. I was very disappointed with today's episode too.

Issues I had (you raised some too):
1. The Imam/Maulvi (sorry, I am non-Muslim, so don't know the difference) recognized Ayaan but did not ask him where his family is?
2. Coincidentally the original 7th bride's name is Zoya (although they spelt it in Hindi as Joya), so they assume she is the bride but the groom changed? No one questioned that? All names were on that list!
3. I thought they had to say Qubool Hai 3 times. I think they said "Haan" twice. In fact Ayaan's response sounded annoyed. No one questioned that?
4. Tanveer's goons couldn't recognize Zoya's outfit?!
5. Why didn't Ayaan call for help from the same room as Humeira?
6. Why not ask the people gathered there for help. The goons didn't have guns.
7. Why didn't Zoya ask Asad for help when she was talking to him?
8. Why didn't Ayaan ask Rashid to send cops to the place?

I am sure there will be more questions after tomorrow's episode as obviously something or someone makes Zoya move to SM! So, for me this is completely illogical as the Nikaah is void!


So many loopholes u have pointed out, I can't understand how ppl don't see the illogical writing (so called twist) and praise the episode 😕
Ankahee thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
Can I just say exactly? 😛
mochhug thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: webuser7

Well said. I was very disappointed with today's episode too.

Issues I had (you raised some too):
1. The Imam/Maulvi (sorry, I am non-Muslim, so don't know the difference) recognized Ayaan but did not ask him where his family is?
2. Coincidentally the original 7th bride's name is Zoya (although they spelt it in Hindi as Joya), so they assume she is the bride but the groom changed? No one questioned that? All names were on that list!
3. I thought they had to say Qubool Hai 3 times. I think they said "Haan" twice. In fact Ayaan's response sounded annoyed. No one questioned that?
4. Tanveer's goons couldn't recognize Zoya's outfit?!
5. Why didn't Ayaan call for help from the same room as Humeira?
6. Why not ask the people gathered there for help. The goons didn't have guns.
7. Why didn't Zoya ask Asad for help when she was talking to him?
8. Why didn't Ayaan ask Rashid to send cops to the place?

I am sure there will be more questions after tomorrow's episode as obviously something or someone makes Zoya move to SM! So, for me this is completely illogical as the Nikaah is void!


👏

Exactly all the things that irked me about today's episode. Really disappointed. It was plausible, but not probable at all. In real life, people are smarter than this.

I'll add another one:

9. Why didn't Zoya find a closed room from which to call Mr. Khan? why automatically sit where the brides are?

It's just too much lack of logic. it's really getting ridiculous.
Sb111 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
For a whole week we were bombarded with "destiny this" and "destiny that" ... forget symbolism and foreshadowing ... we were hit over the head with it! And then what? Logic was nowhere to be found!!! And? The script was full of loopholes!!! End result: "I'm not buying what you're selling!"

Honestly, if I can't buy into the story and my heart is just not into it and I feel like an idiot for wasting my time ... then I'm wasting my time!!!!

*sigh*

... missing the days when I couldn't get enough of my favorite show and it left me feeling good.
mochhug thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Sb111

For a whole week we were bombarded with "destiny this" and "destiny that" ... forget symbolism and foreshadowing ... we were hit over the head with it! And then what? Logic was nowhere to be found!!! And? The script was full of loopholes!!! End result: "I'm not buying what you're selling!"

Honestly, if I can't buy into the story and my heart is just not into it and I feel like an idiot for wasting my time ... then I'm wasting my time!!!!

*sigh*

... missing the days when I couldn't get enough of my favorite show and it left me feeling good.


Same here... Mangalpur, BNHH, Dilshad's shooting, the factory raaz... those were the days... 😭
latanzia thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Oh thank God some one finally said exactly what i was thinking, all the time they are on the phone did either ask for help no.
The episode made absolutely no sense.
Sb111 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: mochhug


Same here... Mangalpur, BNHH, Dilshad's shooting, the factory raaz... those were the days... 😭



Yup!!!! It's not all about "lovey/dovey" stuff. I mean the scenes in Mangalpur ripped my heart out but what a script! And don't even get me started on the acting!!! And you know what? The last time, during the SR fiasco, I was able to watch the old epi's to get my AsYa fix. But this time, I don't know, it's hard to even watch old epi's because I feel like something (maybe hope) is lost somehow. Dumb ... huh?
mochhug thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Sb111



Yup!!!! It's not all about "lovey/dovey" stuff. I mean the scenes in Mangalpur ripped my heart out but what a script! And don't even get me started on the acting!!! And you know what? The last time, during the SR fiasco, I was able to watch the old epi's to get my AsYa fix. But this time, I don't know, it's hard to even watch old epi's because I feel like something (maybe hope) is lost somehow. Dumb ... huh?


Not dumb at all. The problem is that before we would re-watch to reminisce. Now we're re-watching to hold on to something that isn't there any more. We're expecting more from the old tracks now.. because the news one are sucking so much. 🥱
Edited by mochhug - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".