Don't you dare take it away from them. - Page 15

Created

Last reply

Replies

211

Views

15k

Users

71

Likes

950

Frequent Posters

armaanasya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Assuming I watch it ONLY for Karan, that in itself means no insult to the crew.
Assuming I watch it ONLY for Surbhi, that in itself means no insult to the crew.
Assuming I watch it for the plot, that in itself means no insult to anybody.

It's an opinion and I think everybody is entitled to one. I appreciate you acknowledging the talents and efforts of the ones behind the camera, but if you ask me I wouldn't appreciate this post solely cause of the manner in which it was put. Seemed more like a post confused as to whether to appreciate the crew or bash the fandom(s). Either way, indulging in the latter is wrong.

I haven't come here to bash anyone but I have to state that the biggest irony here is that you demand respect for the entire crew, but fail to somehow reciprocate the same while addressing the members.

Problem.C thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: armaanasya

Assuming I watch it ONLY for Karan, that in itself means no insult to the crew.
Assuming I watch it ONLY for Surbhi, that in itself means no insult to the crew.
Assuming I watch it for the plot, that in itself means no insult to anybody.

It's an opinion and I think everybody is entitled to one. I appreciate you acknowledging the talents and efforts of the ones behind the camera, but if you ask me I wouldn't appreciate this post solely cause of the manner in which it was put. Seemed more like a post confused as to whether to appreciate the crew or bash the fandom(s). Either way, indulging in the latter is wrong.

I haven't come here to bash anyone but I have to state that the biggest irony here is that you demand respect for the entire crew, but fail to somehow reciprocate the same while addressing the members.

Exactly
there's nothing wrong with ur point
bt the manner in which ur expressing it
Rockerchic thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
Sigh.

I knew we'd eventually disagree. 😆

Bias is human nature VH.

The audience are not the academy awards who's aim is look at every aspect of a product.

I will watch a movie with my favourite actor in it even if it's shitty. But if the movie is good, ofc I'll praise the director etc but I'll always say the picture was a hit because so and so was in it.

People watch for different reasons. Maybe people do watch only for KSG/SJ. It's their predicament.

For me, I watch for the banner 4lions and care two hoots if KSG and SJ are replaced.

Like that some people are here for the actors.

It's just a show people watch for 20mins and honestly don't think about it's finer aspect beyond the actors playing it.


That's how it works. That's how people think.

Take Lootera. Finest piece of Indian cinema. No one cares. Verdict Ranveer doesn't have BO pull.

The audience will only recognise the actor. That's how it is. Very few people care about what happens behind the scenes.

Let it be.
...MonaCo... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
Actual I take it back. I thought I read Alkaji and Shalini also won.
.BainGan. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Okk if I'm saying I watched 3 idiots for aamir that means I'm disrespecting other cast??😲
Its totally on my choice n I'm not going to say this to hirani or any other crew member that your movie worked because of aamir..but for me aamir was catalyst n without that catalyst i never go for that movie...
N one simple point follows every where jo dikhta hai whi bikta hai...😊
Who cares for the worker who build taj every one admire its beuty n gives credit to shahjahan not those workers whose hands cut down by that king...😊
N please don't call me insensitive because I know all feelings which you mentioned in your post but you can't change every ones opinion..😊



Rockerchic thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
Obtuse and insensitive?

Welcome to the real world.

I love the Pirate of the Caribbean series. Do I know who created the awesome costumes? Nope. But I do know Orlando Bloom and Johnny Depp were in it.

Harry Potter love it. Do I know who was the casting director who did such a phenomenal job? Nope. Doesn't even cross my mind.

YJHD. Do I see anything beyond Ranbir and Deepika? Nope.

The Vampire Diaries. Is there anything else I want to acknowledge other than sexyy Damon? Nope.

Sad sad truth of the world VH.

I fail to see the point of your post. The audience is insensitive. But this post or any Post or anything isn't going to change the disposition.
Problem.C thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: MrDmglover

Okk if I'm saying I watched 3 idiots for aamir that means I'm disrespecting other cast??😲

Its totally on my choice n I'm not going to say this to hirani or any other crew member that your movie worked because of aamir..but for me aamir was catalyst n without that catalyst i never go for that movie...
N one simple point follows every where jo dikhta hai whi bikta hai...😊
Who cares for the worker who build taj every one admire its beuty n gives credit to shahjahan not those workers whose hands cut down by that king...😊
N please don't call me insensitive because I know all feelings which you mentioned in your post but you can't change every ones opinion..😊



Wt about the ppl who din like 3 idiots?
Is tht disrespecting the cast??😲
Opinion ppl
and as the user above said u can't change everyone's opinion
Edited by Problem_Child - 12 years ago
Problem.C thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Rockerchic

Obtuse and insensitive?


Welcome to the real world.

I love the Pirate of the Caribbean series. Do I know who created the awesome costumes? Nope. But I do know Orlando Bloom and Johnny Depp were in it.

Harry Potter love it. Do I know who was the casting director who did such a phenomenal job? Nope. Doesn't even cross my mind.

YJHD. Do I see anything beyond Ranbir and Deepika? Nope.

The Vampire Diaries. Is there anything else I want to acknowledge other than sexyy Damon? Nope.

Sad sad truth of the world VH.

I fail to see the point of your post. The audience is insensitive. But this post or any Post or anything isn't going to change the disposition.


Exactly thank u👏

Btw yea dude Pirates was awesome Johnny Depp Nd Orlando
i watched the last one din like it half as much bt i watched it coz of JD

am yet to see YJHD bt basically am gona watch it coz of them😆

Yep Damon is the only one i see😆
Cup-Of-Chai thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
Vicky, As much as i like your posts on this one i would have to disagree a bit.

I know what you're trying to say that QH is a team effort and people can't give credit to only one person for the whole show i understand that but over the internet you can't change someone's mind so easily. After reading your post people might try making it obvious on the forum but in real they really won't change their opinion.

I think everyone is entitled to their opinion, even you. But telling someone what they should do and they shouldn't do is kind of weird Don't you think?

People would read your post and i don't think they will start giving credit to the whole team because of reading few words. I watch Movies for my favorite actors. Hell I even watch sports because of my favorite player. As long as we are watching that even if it's because of an extra character we're still watching the show.

As long as it has viewers for no matter what reason i think it should be cool. Old people watch it for Alka and others i don't think they would be giving credit to KSG either or Surbhi maybe. People in this world are different.

Anyways i just said what i thought. 😃
Edited by Cup-Of-Chai - 12 years ago
GoodyTwoShoes thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
i think there is nothing wrong with having fav and watching something for them only...i totally understand..and i am sure vick agrees with this...
but yes crediting them for whole success and even their co star's success is unfair to others.and this is not very complicated thing to understand..its simple fact...
people watch a show/movie for different reason and they are totally entitled to their opinions...they are free to love their fav ,appreciate their work,watch and tolerate something they do not like for those fav..is completely ok..as RC we all are biased and thats human nature.
i understand all are not bothered about people behind the camera...but i am..and i will not force anyone to follow my opinion...but at least do not take credit who are part of your success on camera...its completely ok if you do not want them to give credit..no one can force anyone to do it...you can give full credit to your fav ones..and you are very much free to do...but giving them credit for other's success is unfair...
its childish that people think one person makes the show...and here i am not even talking about people behind the camera...so according to me credit for a successful show can not be given to only one person even though,you ,me and others watch it for their fav...
i will not generalise all fans on the basis of some post which said karan is responsible for SJ's popularity and vice versa...
but having an opinion does not mean degrading other's and appreciating your fav does not mean humiliating others..
and its my opinion completely my opinion that stardom can bring some fan-base...and it may help at the time of launch...but there is no way a show can run on the basis of someone's stardom only...and its not about only karan its about gul ,4 lions and even Sj..
i for the matter did not know gul khan before QH...was not a fan of Karan and id not know who is SJ...i was not on IF...and most of the TRP givers are like me...most of the people did not start watching show because of one person ..but yes over the period of time they tend to addict to some factor,be it actors,story or anything else.
anyways i think i am diverting from topic...😆
i just meant to say appreciate your fav...credit them for their success,do not mention others ifyou don't want...but at least don't give them credit for other's success completely..they might be part of it..but if you want sole credit for your fav..others might also want the same

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".