Created

Last reply

Replies

60

Views

4.9k

Users

28

Likes

81

Frequent Posters

.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#11
A1: I'm not being objective, I ADMIT that, but for me, AbhIya is still the center of the show and if it isn't revolving around them, it's out of focus of me, even if it's been so from the beginning.
Off topic I'll have to go a bit to justify myself and my lack of objectivity 'coz if I have to look at it objectively, the only thing I see is how AbhIya fans got cheated because the development of their love story and screenspace was compromised most of the times for things which held no relevance. Sidetracks contribute to the main plot (which IMO was suppose to be AbhIya), or are suppose to anyway. Till date, I haven't seen even one side plot, except Danish-Maya's which did so. Months back when I got irritated with that track, I never knew that it would prove to be the only one which actually did something for AbhIya.
I know most people view this as Abhay's story and trust me, it's fair enough. I am not blaming you or other people who do that and it is totally natural 'coz I admit, Abhay has been getting way more screenspace and focus than AbhIya.
But then, why did they say it was AbhIya's love story? I know shows deviate from their main plot and what they say in the synopsis. All of them do ultimately but after they've reached a certain level in what they said. And the irony of the situation is that we, AbhIya fans, are STILL waiting for the story to shift it's focus to what is the main plot for us. Our attachment to AbhIya stays where it was in Dec'10 which is why we are not being able to see this as anything else.

A2: There is NO doubt that Abhay still loves Maithili. It was evident even before he couldn't kill her. Maithili's memories never left him and I never expected them to, either. I always said that Pia will ultimately create her own place in Abhay's heart but she will never be able to take Maithili's place and that was the ideal thing for me as well <33
TheBlackJaguar thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: heena_mehta

don't knw xcatly wat to say poco

here i m getting bit philosophical bt i think, one cn't forget his first love ...even if dat was betrayal...ofcourse pia is abhay's soul mate...bt mathali taught him wat falling in love means whereas pia ,she is d one who completes d meaning of true love...m i sounding stupid poco😆...??...


No, you are not sounding stupid, Heena. But am not asking if we think that first love can be forgotten or not. I am asking you to look at it from Abhay's POV. And his actions. Piya of course healed Abhay's life but alas, his destiny of wounds proved greater than Piya's love. You didn't tell me whose story PKYEK is as per you. 😊
sanchita1410 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Chill_Out

A1: I'm not being objective, I ADMIT that, but for me, AbhIya is still the center of the show and if it isn't revolving around them, it's out of focus of me, even if it's been so from the beginning.

Off topic I'll have to go a bit to justify myself and my lack of objectivity 'coz if I have to look at it objectively, the only thing I see is how AbhIya fans got cheated because the development of their love story and screenspace was compromised most of the times for things which held no relevance. Sidetracks contribute to the main plot (which IMO was suppose to be AbhIya), or are suppose to anyway. Till date, I haven't seen even one side plot, except Danish-Maya's which did so. Months back when I got irritated with that track, I never knew that it would prove to be the only one which actually did something for AbhIya.
I know most people view this as Abhay's story and trust me, it's fair enough. I am not blaming you or other people who do that and it is totally natural 'coz I admit, Abhay has been getting way more screenspace and focus than AbhIya.
But then, why did they say it was AbhIya's love story? I know shows deviate from their main plot and what they say in the synopsis. All of them do ultimately but after they've reached a certain level in what they said. And the irony of the situation is that we, AbhIya fans, are STILL waiting for the story to shift it's focus to what is the main plot for us. Our attachment to AbhIya stays where it was in Dec'10 which is why we are not being able to see this as anything else.

A2: There is NO doubt that Abhay still loves Maithili. It was evident even before he couldn't kill her. Maithili's memories never left him and I never expected them to, either. I always said that Pia will ultimately create her own place in Abhay's heart but she will never be able to take Maithili's place and that was the ideal thing for me as well <33


Neethi we are in the same boat. Everyday I read ur replies and see u exactly echoed my emotions. We abhiya fans waiting seems never end.
Ameres thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#14
Question one is confusing abit, for me that is. Hm if i think about it...its Abhay's love story. or more like life story. He is the central character. He is the saga you and everyone talks about. If it werent for him, Pia wouldnt be here and niether any of them. In short sab kuch uske ane ke baad hi tu start hua.
Q2. Well yes. Abhay does and will always love Matz. Just because she turned out to be a twisted self-centered person cant remove his feelings for her. What he felt was real. He hates what she has become but i dont think he can ever actually hate her. Again he may not love her like he did once a upon a time...but somewhere he will hold her close in his memories. The Abhay that loved Matz is still in him. So yeah Matz will be there.
I mean we all talk about moving on but is it that easy? There are certain things in life from which i would like to move on and then there are time when i think i have, but at times it all comes rushing back. And it makes me realize though i have grown up but a part of me is still there. Okay i must be sounding confusing now, but i guess one cant doesnt really fully move on. Its hard.
And just out of curiousity...i would love to know your thoughts on this too. :)
I-love-Roses thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#15
Even I want to know whats Metz's status in Abhay's heart.
janu1610 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: PinkChocolate

Q1. Be objective and tell me , whose story really is 'Pyaar Ki Ye Ek Kahaani'? Who stands at the center of PKYEK as a saga?
Ans:----Its story of Abhay nd his soul mate Piya.Its all about the LOVE ,which is in between supernatural nd human being ,with limited powers but still feel the magnetic pull towards her ,her love is so pious ,innocent ,serene . Deep down in his heart he wanted to feel that love ,she is his salvation,has power to enlighten his darkness with her love nd the only one who will love him to no end.This is story of beyond any imagination


Q2. Does Abhay somewhere still love Maithli? Am just curious . Or maybe i could never arrive on a clear cut conclusion. Yes, Abhay's soulmate is Piya and am not raising any suspicions on that. But will Abhay always have a soft special corner for Maithli? I mean, Abhay was not able to hurt Maithli even an inch inspite of knowing that she had kept him in the dark for 200 years? When Abhay was sinking , he had told Piya that him and Maithli could not kill each-other because when you love somebody you cannot kill that person. What exactly did Abhay mean? That he has chosen Piya but will never be able to release a certain part of himself from Maithli or that Maithli's memories will never leave him?
Ans:----He had admitted that once he was in love with this girl but now she has changed .Sid has changed her ,she is no more that Maithili ,once he loved so dearly .Now she has forgotten all humanity ,now she don't have heart of Gold .Thus she don't love her any more{if u remember that epi}And again he admitted that he'd not kill her b/c once he loved her but now Piya is in him nd she is his reason to live .
Maithili is no where near him now she is forgotten long ago .All he remember now is his true love his piya .

Why am I asking all this? JUST CURIOUS.
hope i make some sense.

Love and luck always,❤️
GOD bless everyone. 🤗
Same for you dear.😊

.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: --sanchita--

Neethi we are in the same boat. Everyday I read ur replies and see u exactly echoed my emotions. We abhiya fans waiting seems never end.


I know, man, Sanchu! I'm not into self-pity but I really feel bad for myself and fellow AbhIyaians! I haven't been to the AT in a while but you should see how depressed some of us are out there :(
And AbhIya getting sidelined even more with each passing episode, it seems like salt on my wounds! 😔

What the hell! I feel like a fool saying stuff like this for a fictional show as if my life depends on it but what should I do? I can't help it. I'm way too attached to AbhIya and this show for my own good🥺


Edited by Chill_Out - 14 years ago
heena_mehta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: PinkChocolate

Q1. Be objective and tell me , whose story really is 'Pyaar Ki Ye Ek Kahaani'? Don't go by what is written on the concept note or what you saw on billboards and posters. You've been seeing the show throughout. Who stands at the center of PKYEK as a saga?


i think poco its abhay's story...completely HIS...he is d centre of PKYEK...everything in this story starts frm him n ends at him...whether v take mathali or pia...sid or kabir, chand or haseena, n now misha, jeh , neel n deepu aunty...somehow they all revolve around abhay...pia loves abhay, mathali hates abhay, sid wanted to kill him, kabir hates him, same wid neel, jeh n deepu aunty they want to take revenge frm him n nw misha whether love or frndship bt wid abhay!!

Why am I asking all this? JUST CURIOUS.

Love and luck always,❤️
GOD bless everyone. 🤗

TheBlackJaguar thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#19

Thank you, Nishoo😳. I guess the writers wanted to create AbhIya and they did but it seems they ended up creating something so powerful in Abhay that they didn't even realize when Abhay started driving the story. Abhay still has 'something deep' for Maithli and when she comes back to claim him, i want to see how he is ripped apart. We must not forget that Abhay could not kill her and confessed to Piya before sinking that he did love Metz.
TheBlackJaguar thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Sidchu

No he stopped loving her moment he saw her in sid's arms!🤓


Archu, tu sudhriyo mutt life mein!😆...Abhay ne Metz ko Sid ki baahon mein dekha lekin tab bhi gadhe ko uspe pyaar hi aa raha tha.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".