TheBlackJaguar thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Q1. Be objective and tell me , whose story really is 'Pyaar Ki Ye Ek Kahaani'? Don't go by what is written on the concept note or what you saw on billboards and posters. You've been seeing the show throughout. Who stands at the center of PKYEK as a saga?

Q2. Does Abhay somewhere still love Maithli? Am just curious . Or maybe i could never arrive on a clear cut conclusion. Yes, Abhay's soulmate is Piya and am not raising any suspicions on that. But will Abhay always have a soft special corner for Maithli? I mean, Abhay was not able to hurt Maithli even an inch inspite of knowing that she had kept him in the dark for 200 years? When Abhay was sinking , he had told Piya that him and Maithli could not kill each-other because when you love somebody you cannot kill that person. What exactly did Abhay mean? That he has chosen Piya but will never be able to release a certain part of himself from Maithli or that Maithli's memories will never leave him?

Why am I asking all this? JUST CURIOUS.

Love and luck always,❤️
GOD bless everyone. 🤗

Created

Last reply

Replies

60

Views

4.9k

Users

28

Likes

81

Frequent Posters

sonu.p thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
LOL...poco y so philosophical today?? :P
the pyaar ki ek kahani has always been about piya and abhay...atleast for me...i guess its only natural that abhay cannot find it in his heart to completely hate maithili after everything...lets not forget this is the woman he loved for like 200 years...its not easy to just kill someone you've loved for so long just like that...but after everything...even knowing that maithili was back, he chose to protect piya...
im kind of glad that abhay wasnt able to hurt maithili easily...otherwise it i would never have called what they used to have-true love...
if it had been that easy to hate someone u loved before..then u just didnt love them at all...so im glad they have atleast stayed true to their word of abhay having actually loved maithili in the past...
still, having said that, i do believe he now genuinely loves piya...maybe earlier i had doubts about the legitimacy of his attraction to her...whether it was just about the face...or more...but i would like to believe that the stage of thinking he likes her cos she resembled his past love is now gone...abhay definitley loves piya...for herself...not as a mirror to someone else...
but still...it is an intruiging thought, i will admit.. :)

Courageous_Leo thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Answers 2 our curious cat...😆😆😆..
Pehle prashn ka Jawab..Its Abhay's Ishtory...atleast 4 me...Kyunki me Abhay ki deewani hu...Bechare ne bahut kuch saha...So its his kahani...Par nhi uski zubani..bahut kam bolta hai..😆😆😆..
Doosre Prashn ka Uttar..Poco puttar...Yessh..he lobs Metz..Uski nashili aankho me phas chuka hai bechara Abhay...
Pehla pehla pyar hai
Pehli pehli baar hai...
Chah ke bhi na mara...
Aisa uska Pyar hai...
Hope uttar mil gaye...😆😆😆...
Edited by zoozoo123 - 14 years ago
heena_mehta thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
don't knw xcatly wat to say poco
here i m getting bit philosophical bt i think, one cn't forget his first love ...even if dat was betrayal...ofcourse pia is abhay's soul mate...bt mathali taught him wat falling in love means whereas pia ,she is d one who completes d meaning of true love...m i sounding stupid poco😆...??...

Edited by heena_mehta - 14 years ago
601348 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: PinkChocolate

Q1. Be objective and tell me , whose story really is 'Pyaar Ki Ye Ek Kahaani'? Don't go by what is written on the concept note or what you saw on billboards and posters. You've been seeing the show throughout. Who stands at the center of PKYEK as a saga?

>> obviously...whether u go by ur own brains or by logic or by posters - u will only realize that PKYEK is Abhay's story...he is the center of gravity which pulls everyone, b it Pia or Chandeena or Jeh or anyone 😆...its Abhiya story too but Pia is somewhere sidelined now (i personally feel that)...u can fail to notice Pia these days but can u fail to notice Abhay? NO ways!...or look it the other way, Abhay-Misha is given more focus than Jeh-Pia...so its Abhiya story but if u have to select one, then its def Abhay


Q2. Does Abhay somewhere still love Maithli? Am just curious . Or maybe i could never arrive on a clear cut conclusion. Yes, Abhay's soulmate is Piya and am not raising any suspicions on that. But will Abhay always have a soft special corner for Maithli? I mean, Abhay was not able to hurt Maithli even an inch inspite of knowing that she had kept him in the dark for 200 years? When Abhay was sinking , he had told Piya that him and Maithli could not kill each-other because when you love somebody you cannot kill that person. What exactly did Abhay mean? That he has chosen Piya but will never be able to release a certain part of himself from Maithli or that Maithli's memories will never leave him?

>> yes i think Abhay still loves Maithli somewhere or has a soft corner for her atleast...its not easy to forget someone u loved for 200 years afterall 😆...but u will find out this when Maithli comes back...and i m sure Maithli wont let go off Abhay so easily


Why am I asking all this? JUST CURIOUS.

Love and luck always,❤️
GOD bless everyone. 🤗

Edited by Nishi.Singh - 14 years ago
OriginalsFan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
No he stopped loving her moment he saw her in sid's arms!🤓
TheBlackJaguar thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: sonu.p

LOL...poco y so philosophical today?? :P

the pyaar ki ek kahani has always been about piya and abhay...atleast for me...i guess its only natural that abhay cannot find it in his heart to completely hate maithili after everything...lets not forget this is the woman he loved for like 200 years...its not easy to just kill someone you've loved for so long just like that...but after everything...even knowing that maithili was back, he chose to protect piya...
im kind of glad that abhay wasnt able to hurt maithili easily...otherwise it i would never have called what they used to have-true love...
if it had been that easy to hate someone u loved before..then u just didnt love them at all...so im glad they have atleast stayed true to their word of abhay having actually loved maithili in the past...
still, having said that, i do believe he now genuinely loves piya...maybe earlier i had doubts about the legitimacy of his attraction to her...whether it was just about the face...or more...but i would like to believe that the stage of thinking he likes her cos she resembled his past love is now gone...abhay definitley loves piya...for herself...not as a mirror to someone else...
but still...it is an intruiging thought, i will admit.. :)


Arre not philosophical at all. These are ways of improving story writing. 😊...Hmm. So, you think PKYEK is Abhay-Piya's story. Okay, i see where you are coming from. You mean that Abhay's love for Piya is true which it is but whatever he felt for Maithli was as epic and deep as the verbal declaration of a wait of 200 years. But you still didn't answer what i asked. Does Abhay somewhere still love Metz?
Ritzie thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: PinkChocolate

Q1. Be objective and tell me , whose story really is 'Pyaar Ki Ye Ek Kahaani'? Don't go by what is written on the concept note or what you saw on billboards and posters. You've been seeing the show throughout. Who stands at the center of PKYEK as a saga?


Abhay. I think he is the center of the story. I am not saying it because I love Abhay but because it seems like he makes everything/ everybody revolvearound him.

Q2. Does Abhay somewhere still love Maithli? Am just curious . Or maybe i could never arrive on a clear cut conclusion. Yes, Abhay's soulmate is Piya and am not raising any suspicions on that. But will Abhay always have a soft special corner for Maithli? I mean, Abhay was not able to hurt Maithli even an inch inspite of knowing that she had kept him in the dark for 200 years? When Abhay was sinking , he had told Piya that him and Maithli could not kill each-other because when you love somebody you cannot kill that person. What exactly did Abhay mean? That he has chosen Piya but will never be able to release a certain part of himself from Maithli or that Maithli's memories will never leave him?
Pinkoo, the love also has different intensities. Abhay is a very different kind of person - well he is The Hero. He loved Maithili where she was everything for him - so much that he couldn't even stay away from her look-alike. I think even now it will be hard for him to hurt her but that doesn't mean he loves her with that intensity. Still, if he has to choose, he will choose humanity over everything.

Why am I asking all this? JUST CURIOUS.
I am curious to see others answers too

Love and luck always,❤️
GOD bless everyone. 🤗

sanchita1410 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
archu u never fail a single chance to talk about sid. 😆 poco I also think abhay still has soft corner for maithili after all pehla pyaar to pehla pyaar hi hota hai.
TheBlackJaguar thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: zoozoo123

Answers 2 our curious cat...😆😆😆..

Pehle prashn ka Jawab..Its Abhay's Ishtory...atleast 4 me...Kyunki me Abhay ki deewani hu...Bechare ne bahut kuch saha...So its his kahani...Par nhi uski zubani..bahut kam bolta hai..😆😆😆..
Doosre Prashn ka Uttar..Poco puttar...Yessh..he lobs Metz..Uski nashili aankho me phas chuka hai bechara Abhay...
Pehla pehla pyar hai
Pehli pehli baar hai...
Chah ke bhi na mara...
Aisa uska Pyar hai...
Hope uttar mil gaye...😆😆😆...


Thank you, Zoozee. Are you being objective, really? Forget that you are a Abhay fan and then, tell me whose story PKYEK really is.

And you think that Abhay still loves Maithli somewhere?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".