How far can they save Pia? - Page 4

Originally posted by: Cute.Sadaf

Heart is Heart compells to go' fo' the thin' whiCh is either subsist or really doesn't .. Same Crucial Conditon state is with Piya .. But somehow she'll manifestly go with her heart . No matter what happens .. I Wish Abhay wouldn't expunged Piya's Memory .. But , although , i'm exCited to watCh the further .. 😃

Originally posted by: sanjna4

Sorry chillz now I will comment serious wala

So res :)
This is not spamming
---edited---

Okay chillz u knw even we were discussing about new Pia in the evening but we were discussing her wrong aspects not her mental state. You hold it right that everything around her is playing with her mind. Someone is feeding her with lies and someone is just using Abhay's name to torture her. I mean no1 is interested in her mental state bt now madhu and Arbab are discssing it was good to see that someone considering her mental state.

Yes, Sanju! That discussion we had in the CC, I realise, was all on the wrong lines. This issue required a change of approach in it's outlook. You have said it absolutely aptly. Unknowingly, everyone out here is playing around with Pia. Yes, Madhu and Arnab realise what her mental state is like but they also need to realise that keeping stuff from her is what will make it worse and not telling her.

Here i will also say that due to her usual detectivegiri she is also give her mind pressure alot. I mean she has decided to find the truth and for that she will do anything. So in a way she is playing with her mind. And to add up more problems these days her mind and heart are not working in sync manner. As in her heart says something else and her mind says something else.

Exactly!! Pia's detective work is putting further stress on her brain specially since her logic and her instinct are pointing in different directions.

So to sum up whole thing this time everyone around her including her is messing up with her mind. And chillz if I tell u truth I want this thing only asthis thing only will bring Abhay back and we want that only.

I want Abhay back to, Sanju and yes, maybe it's good if I look at it in the long run but as of now, Pia is getting tortured something which I find hard to ignore :(

Chillz chill maar i didn;t felt bad coz I knw u r lil emotional types😊

Aww! Thanks for understanding and you really don't need to apologise it wasn't your fault 🤗

@Emo: I still don't take that as a compliment but thanks a ton 😆

And thanks for replying :D

Originally posted by: reepicheep

Hi Neethi🤗 congrats on the superb result of your bro😃

Heyy, Himani! Thank you so much 🤗

Hope your mood is better now...pkyek is just so depressing these days na, its like a pall of gloom has descended over it, and everyone's caught in abhay's spell...only when that spell is broken will the show gain back its liveliness...

Yes, my mood is much better now and it has a reason for it. I do find the show depressing still but for reason other than Abhay's absence. It actually required a change of approach. The thing is, most people look at this from Abhay's PoV hence it's obvious that without him, there will be nothing left. Fair enough, that's their perception of the show and a few people like myself see it as AbhIya, hence Abhay as well. Again fair enough. Matter of opinion. But fact remains that this show belongs to Pia as much as it belongs to Abhay and now this track revolves around her and her inner turmoil. If you see, Sid's track majorly revolved around Abhay. Pia was given enough screenspace, yet, somewhere, when it came to 'role' it was reduced to a supporting character, not meaty enough for a lead. All these months, it was Abhay's story, now it's Pia's. No, it doesn't stop me from missing Abhay. I still miss him tons but this has somewhere down the line helped me accept PKYEK without Abhay and be less depressed about his absence. I haven't shared this so far on the forum but I wanted to share it with you because I don't like seeing my friends sad :(

Try and see if this works for you like it did for me :)

Well, I didn't watch yesterday's episode...and am glad that I didn't, since I read it was mostly crap and filler...as it is I was so worked up yesterday, that I ranted and raved like anything in almost every post and spammed your thread the most😆 hehe, now that its out of my system and having not watched the episode,am much calmer and accepted the fact, that Abhay most probably will come back only by the mahaepisode...I know too long a wait, but it seems to be going in that direction...

People found it crap and filler? Ok, maybe, I didn't really step out of my post into the forum yesterday. Lol! I kinda like it. I mean, it was filler, no denying there and some scenes were stretched a lot but I still liked it minus the fact that there was no Abhay, of course 😆

But yes, my thread is always open for raving and ranting. Feel free to express your displeasure :P

I also had myself prepared that I won't see chalta phirta real Abhay before the mahaepisode. I just hope it's not delayed further because I'm not prepared for that 😳

Now that we know Jay's agenda, he'll be pushing piya to remember more and more until she reaches the spot where abhay is frozen...I agree with you, I feel very sad to see pia in this state, that's why I didn't get angry with her kissing jay for a bet...poor piya, I don't know what in her has given the impression to people that she's this fragile, vulnerable lamb that has to be protected from the big bad wolf all the time...I find it very puzzling and contradictory at times that ,when she's been shown as such a strong,independent and self-sufficient girl,why this need for everyone to protect her so much?

I am not all that angry at Pia for the kiss either but I still don't approve of it. It was so avoidable! Nothing justifies that but yes, I do feel bad for her. People in a quest to protect her always somehow end up betraying her and that endangers her further.

Abhay always went overboard with his protection act on her, not that I blame him, he needed to keep her safe from the horrors of his world...and this last act of erasing her memory, that was understandable...I mean he himself being in a frozen and helpless state couldn't have saved her from metz's wrath, and pia even though she would have tried her best to free him...it could have taken months...so that seemed the only plausible solution,and,its ok except for the fact that its consequences are not what Abhay could have anticipated or imagined...one never can in these situations...

Exactly, Himani! You got it totally right. I really didn't approve of the memory erasing by Abhay but one really can't blame him! That was the best solution at that time. He obviously thought Pia will forget him and carry on with life. The state he was in back then, he didn't even have the time to stop and think that this can backfire.

It reminds me of your DOTW where we had discussed about intentions and actions...same scenario is being repeated again with pia...Dobriyals intentions are good by keeping the truth from her to protect her, but the consequences again will be unexpected...it again comes down to everyone underestimating pia's inner strength...she's capable of handling whatever horrors life can throw at her...what she dislikes is this hiding business...and when she comes to know the truth all hell will break loose for the dobriyals and abhay too...only this time I would like to see pia asserting herself,its time this hide and seek with her stops...its just cruel,and she can be manipulated so easily by others...sid manipulated her because abhay kept the truth and now jay is doing the same because dobriyals are keeping the truth...its enough to make a mess of anyone's mind,and moreover,with piya since she's in such a crisis like situation...

I feel Pia's strength has always been underestimated ever since the show started by people around her, by the audience and even by Pia herself.

I'm so glad you mentioned this because hardly anyone bothers to see the other side of the coin which justifies Pia. A lot has been hidden from Pia and those who can and want to obviously take advantage of it and manipulate her. Sid manipulated Pia because Abhay lied to her, she felt betrayed. Jay is manipulating her because her family is lying to her, yet, tomorrow when she feels betrayed by her family, people will once again blame her. 'Oh her family was only trying to protect her, she doesn't even appreciate that' *roll eyes*

This time, let's see what consequences come out of this. I'm really not liking the fact that Misha's lie coupled with Jay's trick yesterday has kind of made Abhay fall in Pia's eyes. That is just plain sad! All the more reason that I want Abhay back so that Pia can see what a sweetheart he is and not a 'loser' like Misha projects him to be or an 'a**h***' like Jay projected him to be

True about the DOTW though. Had I waited till now to open it, I would've definitely added these two as well. After all, it is her family's love for her which is leading to all the lies and betrayal. They're wrong, but who can blame them? Their intentions prevent me from having the heart to do that!

Its just a matter of time now, pia being pia will follow her heart and find out about abhay now through jay's goading...this is an aspect in Pia that I have always found fascinating to watch...her head over heart tussles, where her heart always wins😃

I like her head over heart tussles as well ya mainly because her heart always wins but this time, her heart will have to endure a lot before it wins simply because the mind won't know what the heart is talking about 😲

Originally posted by: Ayesha066

yes how long wil dey save pia frm her memories.. rather i dnt think dey wil b able to.. n on jay's part i think he hates dobriyal family n dat is y he is doing this n i think he has some connection wid abhay too...

Originally posted by: Chill_Out

Yes, my mood is much better now and it has a reason for it. I do find the show depressing still but for reason other than Abhay's absence. It actually required a change of approach. The thing is, most people look at this from Abhay's PoV hence it's obvious that without him, there will be nothing left. Fair enough, that's their perception of the show and a few people like myself see it as AbhIya, hence Abhay as well. Again fair enough. Matter of opinion. But fact remains that this show belongs to Pia as much as it belongs to Abhay and now this track revolves around her and her inner turmoil. If you see, Sid's track majorly revolved around Abhay. Pia was given enough screenspace, yet, somewhere, when it came to 'role' it was reduced to a supporting character, not meaty enough for a lead. All these months, it was Abhay's story, now it's Pia's. No, it doesn't stop me from missing Abhay. I still miss him tons but this has somewhere down the line helped me accept PKYEK without Abhay and be less depressed about his absence. I haven't shared this so far on the forum but I wanted to share it with you because I don't like seeing my friends sad :(

Try and see if this works for you like it did for me :)

Aww, Neethz you are such a sweetheart❤️🤗 Thanks, it did help...you are right, we have beeen thinking about abhay so much that we have forgotten that its pia's story too,and at the moment she's the one who's suffering more after all as crazy as I am about abhay am equally crazy about abhiya,and even if one of them is not there,it feels bad...and that's exactly what's happening here,pia is there but not there and abhay is actually not there...so we'll have to wait till pia finds her way back to abhay and that will take a little time since she has to break through the web of lies and follow her heart😃

People found it crap and filler? Ok, maybe, I didn't really step out of my post into the forum yesterday. Lol! I kinda like it. I mean, it was filler, no denying there and some scenes were stretched a lot but I still liked it minus the fact that there was no Abhay, of course 😆

But yes, my thread is always open for raving and ranting. Feel free to express your displeasure :P

I also had myself prepared that I won't see chalta phirta real Abhay before the mahaepisode. I just hope it's not delayed further because I'm not prepared for that 😳

Frankly, these days all episodes seem filler only...and its because they'll be dragging it out till the mahaepisode...I mean yeah we already know that jay has a thing against the dobriyals...so instead of showing more scenes of their enmity it would be nice if they showed him goading piya or piya getting restless and running in the jungles...and please at least let chandeena come back now,the entire vampire world is missing right now from the show...even I can't maintain my sanity on abhay's absence beyond the mahaepisode...

Lol, I do spam most in your thread...Thanks Neethz🤗

I am not all that angry at Pia for the kiss either but I still don't approve of it. It was so avoidable! Nothing justifies that but yes, I do feel bad for her. People in a quest to protect her always somehow end up betraying her and that endangers her further.

Exactly, it was avoidable, there are better ways to establish enmity between the two...and though I don't fully relate to the spunky piya...I wouldn't mind a little spunk in her, in fac t she needs that spunk to deal with her family and abhay later...to take her relationship with abhay on a equal footing...

Exactly, Himani! You got it totally right. I really didn't approve of the memory erasing by Abhay but one really can't blame him! That was the best solution at that time. He obviously thought Pia will forget him and carry on with life. The state he was in back then, he didn't even have the time to stop and think that this can backfire.

I feel Pia's strength has always been underestimated ever since the show started by people around her, by the audience and even by Pia herself.

I'm so glad you mentioned this because hardly anyone bothers to see the other side of the coin which justifies Pia. A lot has been hidden from Pia and those who can and want to obviously take advantage of it and manipulate her. Sid manipulated Pia because Abhay lied to her, she felt betrayed. Jay is manipulating her because her family is lying to her, yet, tomorrow when she feels betrayed by her family, people will once again blame her. 'Oh her family was only trying to protect her, she doesn't even appreciate that' *roll eyes*

This time, let's see what consequences come out of this. I'm really not liking the fact that Misha's lie coupled with Jay's trick yesterday has kind of made Abhay fall in Pia's eyes. That is just plain sad! All the more reason that I want Abhay back so that Pia can see what a sweetheart he is and not a 'loser' like Misha projects him to be or an 'a**h***' like Jay projected him to be

True about the DOTW though. Had I waited till now to open it, I would've definitely added these two as well. After all, it is her family's love for her which is leading to all the lies and betrayal. They're wrong, but who can blame them? Their intentions prevent me from having the heart to do that!

Abhay and Pia's situation reminds me of Dumbledore and Harry's relationship at times...Dumbledore kept many secrets from Harry and in book 5 he absolutely kept a distance from Harry and never revealed anything...leading Harry to become frustrated and take the impulsive action of going to save Sirius...same scenario played out in the entire sid-metz scenario leading to a memory wipe...and now Dobriyals are pushing piya towards taking some rash action...

I too wish Misha stops badmouthing abhay...because even when she does that it doesn't look convincing from her end, coz,she knows how much abhay loved piya...I wonder what the story is in her case, we never saw how dobriyals dealt with the aftermath and what they thought about abhay..or did they know the truth about him...why this insistence on hiding only abhay's memories from piya...why not worry about whether pia will remember that horrific night? as far as I can understand panchi,misha weren't even aware of abhay's presence on the scene, so why all this protection from abhay's memories? I mean for a girl who's lost her memory due to something traumatic doesn't it make more sense to hide that horrific night instead of a so called break up...there's something there which has to be figured out or maybe my imagination is too wild😆

I like her head over heart tussles as well ya mainly because her heart always wins but this time, her heart will have to endure a lot before it wins simply because the mind won't know what the heart is talking about 😲

Sigh, yes Piya will have to endure a lot of emotional atyachar this time but am counting on Dr. Abhay to heal her😉