I am with Piya.

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Neetz

@.Jane..

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 14 years ago

#51

Everyone, I would just say that it's easy for us to sit here and blame Pia. No one is even trying to put themselves in her shoes. Fair enough. I'm not exactly pro what Pia is doing. Leah never said that she thinks Pia is right, she only said that Pia is justified, which she is. It's easy for you guys to say that Pia knew all along then why is she shocked? I would like to quote two examples which I gave yesterday and day before.

One was of a tiger. We see a pic of a tiger and we see a live tiger inches away from us without any cave or barrier, is our reaction the same?

The second example which I hate giving again is that of my grandmother. She was ill and we all knew that she won't live long. Yet, when she passed away, we were shattered. Why?? We were prepared for her death right? We knew that anyday she would depart, it was expected, then why??

Coming to Abhay, totally it's heart breaking to see his condition, the way he's suffered in the past two years but I don't see how bashing Pia helps to sympathise with Abhay.

Leah, I suggest everyone's inclined to their opinion so let's not try and change it. No use in being overly defensive for Pia. We can't deny that she did overreact even if it was justified.

All said and done, I am with Pia and I support her actions completely!

Quote

Sonia

@sonia_92

Rocker

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#52

with all due respect to your point of view, i disagree completely.

you have mentioned in ur post quite a few times that piya reacted the way any NORMAL PERSON would have, well that is a completely impractical point to be discussed in my opinion because the story is unreal, it's not even close to NORMAL life so yeah since it is total fiction and it is upto to the writers as to how they mould the story, i'd say tht the way the story has been portrayed till now, piya's reaction was wrong.

practically speaking, Vampires dont exist so we cannot assume as to HOW piya should react as a normal person coz there really is no normality, and her reaction should be judged based on the logic and emotional connection the viewers find in the show

i think that logically and emotionally, both ways piya's reaction was unfair!

no offense

cheers

sonia

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

muskaan.

@muskaan.

Voyager

Posted: 14 years ago

#53

ok we agree on the point that her act was normal even i was expecting her to shiver🤣

but what was that she said on her bed, she was thinking logically at that time😳

i let him come close to me( he never asked you to do that)

he let me fall in love for him(he told her to stay from him)

n last but not the least she remembered all those times when they were almost at the kissable position(piya was more in other words despo for all those things but abhay controlled himself)

and he always asked her to hate him(though he loves her a lot) then how she is blaming him , she wanted to know his truth, he always warned her not to interfere in his personal life....

i mean i'm not on the abhay's side but how can you justify her act???

Edited by muskaan. - 14 years ago

Quote

Apoorva

@0o.Leah.o0

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#54

Originally posted by: Chill_Out
Everyone, I would just say that it's easy for us to sit here and blame Pia. No one is even trying to put themselves in her shoes. Fair enough. I'm not exactly pro what Pia is doing. Leah never said that she thinks Pia is right, she only said that Pia is justified, which she is. It's easy for you guys to say that Pia knew all along then why is she shocked? I would like to quote two examples which I gave yesterday and day before.
One was of a tiger. We see a pic of a tiger and we see a live tiger inches away from us without any cave or barrier, is our reaction the same?

The second example which I hate giving again is that of my grandmother. She was ill and we all knew that she won't live long. Yet, when she passed away, we were shattered. Why?? We were prepared for her death right? We knew that anyday she would depart, it was expected, then why??

Coming to Abhay, totally it's heart breaking to see his condition, the way he's suffered in the past two years but I don't see how bashing Pia helps to sympathise with Abhay.

Leah, I suggest everyone's inclined to their opinion so let's not try and change it. No use in being overly defensive for Pia. We can't deny that she did overreact even if it was justified.

All said and done, I am with Pia and I support her actions completely!

Chill ! You my friend, are amazing!

Brilliantly put. I am NOT supporting Piya. I am just saying she just acted like a NORMAL HUMAN BEING! Why doesnt anybody GET that?

What she did wasnt right. I completely agree. But what else can you expect a woman to do when her love, turns out to be a bloody sucking animal? Jump in his arms?

@ Grandmother - I am sorry about that. But that was a perfect example. You KNOW that the person is going to die. But you still are devastated in the end, when it actually happens. Natural.

Abhay went through a lot. And frankly, I think ABHAY was the one who had to be prepared, cause he knew it all along, that Piya was going to run away from him.

Poor guy.

She definately did overreact. I agree. But it was in a way, justified. We all overreact, dont we?

Quote

Apoorva

@0o.Leah.o0

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#55

Originally posted by: sonia_92
with all due respect to your point of view, i disagree completely.

you have mentioned in ur post quite a few times that piya reacted the way any NORMAL PERSON would have, well that is a completely impractical point to be discussed in my opinion because the story is unreal, it's not even close to NORMAL life so yeah since it is total fiction and it is upto to the writers as to how they mould the story, i'd say tht the way the story has been portrayed till now, piya's reaction was wrong.

practically speaking, Vampires dont exist so we cannot assume as to HOW piya should react as a normal person coz there really is no normality, and her reaction should be judged based on the logic and emotional connection the viewers find in the show

i think that logically and emotionally, both ways piya's reaction was unfair!

no offense

cheers

sonia

Of course, I dont take any offence. I put forth my views, and you are welcome to put in yours.😃

How else did you want Piya to react.

I personally, wouldnt have it any other way. I am glad the CVs have shown it like this.

The shower thing was overdoing it. But her running away from him was so totally expected. Abhay knew it too.

Originally posted by: muskaan.
ok we agree on the point that her act was normal even i was expecting her to shiver🤣

but what was that she said on her bed, she was thinking logically at that time😳

i let him come close to me( he never asked you to do that)

he let me fall in love for him(he told her to stay from him)

n last but not the least she remembered all those times when they were almost at the kissable position(piya was more in other words despo for all those things but abhay controlled himself)

and he always asked her to hate him(though he loves her a lot) then how she is blaming him , she wanted to know his truth, he always warned her not to interfere in his personal life....

i mean i'm not on the abhay's side but how can you justify her act???

Dont we all want to shift the blame on someone?

I think, Piya KNOWS that she brought all this on herself. And she is just searching for ways to shift the blame on Abhay.

She wants herself to believe that she didnt actually fall in love with a vampire.

Quote

@-HJ-

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

#56

hey TM!!!

its human nature no to think practically....

sometimes no one can be sensible enough to believe the truth.....people are stubborn so will never agree wid ur opinion...they will come wid weird questions...so let it be..

one thing is clear tht no1 can change ur view about anything...so let them say whtever they want...everyone is free to say wht they feel...

this is same wid many real life incidences..we r too rigid to change our mind wid time..its lik tht only..

Quote

Neetz

@.Jane..

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 14 years ago

#57

Thanks for your condolences, Leah!

Pia's reaction, or overreaction, whatever it is, is NATURAL. Right or wrong does NOT have a role to play here! Anyhow, as I said, it's easy to blame Pia because we people haven't been put in a similar situation! Jab khud par beetati hai, toh pata chalta hai! But I guess it will kill people to even try and keep themselves in Pia's place and try to understand her. I actually feel sorry for them. Pia is just a fictional character but this quality is essential in life.

Anyhow, I'm liking this track and to me that's all that matters. I'm just hoping that EK doesn't drag it too long because it KILLED me to see the Abhay I saw today!

Quote

Apoorva

@0o.Leah.o0

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#58

Originally posted by: honeybee211
hey TM!!!
its human nature no to think practically....

sometimes no one can be sensible enough to believe the truth.....people are stubborn so will never agree wid ur opinion...they will come wid weird questions...so let it be..

one thing is clear tht no1 can change ur view about anything...so let them say whtever they want...everyone is free to say wht they feel...

this is same wid many real life incidences..we r too rigid to change our mind wid time..its lik tht only..

True. I agree.

Infact, I myself am hell bent, on believing that Piya's actions were justified. And I still stick by that.

Quote

Apoorva

@0o.Leah.o0

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#59

Originally posted by: Chill_Out
Thanks for your condolences, Leah!
Pia's reaction, or overreaction, whatever it is, is NATURAL. Right or wrong does NOT have a role to play here! Anyhow, as I said, it's easy to blame Pia because we people haven't been put in a similar situation! Jab khud par beetati hai, toh pata chalta hai! But I guess it will kill people to even try and keep themselves in Pia's place and try to understand her. I actually feel sorry for them. Pia is just a fictional character but this quality is essential in life.

Anyhow, I'm liking this track and to me that's all that matters. I'm just hoping that EK doesn't drag it too long because it KILLED me to see the Abhay I saw today!

Yes, you are right. You gotta put yourself in the shoes of the characters to actually understand why they did it.

Right or wrong has no role to play here. Its natural. Simple.

I dont want EK to drag it to much too. Because it would be totally OOC if Piya would "hate" Abhay for so long.

But this track was definately needed. It will only help in bringing Abhay-Piya closer.

Quote

@-HJ-

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

#60

Its true that Piya already read on net & in books about vampire but she was not believing tht Abhay can be such a monster...she was sure tht he was an angel of her life & will save her everytime..she just wanted to throw off the mask he wore by behaving very suspicious everytime & not tellin her the truth...she always had a feeling tht he did hide many things frm her...

she was actually making herself believe tht Abhay is an angel but when she came to know tht whtever she read about vampires was true & Abhay is really a vampire she was shocked...rit now she is fighting wid her ownself..it wil definitely take some time to overcome tht..but I m sure something is goin to happen in those 24hrs..so lets be calm & wait for whts next..

Quote

1 ... 4 5 6 7 8

I am with Piya. - Page 6

Related Topics

Explore Topics