the present track is obnoxious

merrydock thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
i like Punar Vivah, and i love the relationship between Arti and Yash. but what are the makers trying to prove with the present track.
i get Akash is angry that he was delt crappy cards in life for no fault of his.
what i dont get is how can they show that his entire personality is so rottan and uncivilized just because he was brought up in poverty. why dont poor people learn manner or how to simply behave in a civilized manner in front of others.
his mother or more exactly the woman who brought him up was poor, so maybe she could not give him an english school education, but she must have give him some sort of education, she may not have had the money to throw lavish parties, of send him shopping, or to the movies every week, but she could provide food clothing and shelter. she could give him basic india values of how to respect your elders, be kind to people, be helpfull to others. return kind words and deeds in kind. you dont have to be brought up rich to learn such values.
so why is Akash blaming he uncivilized behaviour on the fact that he was not brought up by his rich family. that's stupid.
Akash is a person not an animal in the jungle, he was brought up in a society by other human beings, not in the jungle by a bunch of monkeys or wolf's that he does know how to behave in society.
or maybe the tridition of blaming your short commings on other and not on the choice you make runs in the Sindia/Gyatri blood. and Akash is doing exactly what his father did, blamed his lack of contron and small heartedness on others, rather then hold themselves responsible for their own actions.
no one can make you a criminal if you dont want to be one. no one can force you to lie and cheat if you choose not to.
the only sensible man in the sindia piravar is yash. papa sindia who was a strong pattriarch is nothing but a week man, who has no sense of morality, or remose. he persicuted Arti for a lie. wanted a marriage to brake and children to become motherless again, simply because his ego was to great that he fell for the lie that Arti's family told him about her marital status.
so what punishment should he give himself for cheating on his wife by sleeping with another woman and fathering a child with her.
this family is so flawed and yet they stand in judgement of others. it is sad.

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

1.8k

Users

6

Likes

25

Frequent Posters

ana56 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Akaash is behavng like that because since childhood he has been hearing the word illegtimate along with his name
for a child a father s name and mother s love is the most important things
he got the mother s love but he missed that father s name from his identity
in our society illegtimate childs are like a burden
no one cares for them and society blames the child instead of the parents who have committed the sin
akash s behaviour is justified according to me
but ya when aarti went to their house secretly she found some documents and she said that akash has completed his education in bhopal...
so that education matter will be unfolded later
pal_maan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
To a point you are correct. Correct that his behaviour was like an animal... But we must not forget that right now he's hurt, very hurt. And somewhere he took his father's genes of blaming others so that's what he's doing right now.
When Ansh was in his custody, he was never rude to him. this shows he's basically a nice man. So,its just the truth that has brought the animal in him. And we must also not forget that he was never a person who wanted a simple life, he wanted money and that was the reason he married Ishita also, so now when him being the son of Scindhiya's came to fore, he's angry for not living the life he always wanted to live...
To a point you are correct that he and SP are not behaving accordingly, but this is what happens in real life also...
Yash is a person with high morals and the person he is, he could have been happy even after living a poor's life...
All the five fingers cant be same, this is what PV has always shown.
yamunah79 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
i totally agree with ana56@ and paal_maan..to add to their points...

you got creatives point here, the variation of character that shown in sindia parivaar sons..yash is different because he also carries radha's gene..although g3 brought him up but he is so different from pankaj and pretik. however, aakash brought up by radha still for now he show more of sp behavior..so my point here is genenetic + enviroment you are brought up determines a persons behavior...

coming to aakash, the society that aakash grow up...chawl...does always give rises to this kind of gentlement?...as he is holding illegitimate son board in the hand..do you think, aakash has any oppurtunity to mingle with good kids or any decent kids from chawl? i hope you aware the chawl living society's mind set and limitation here?when, aakash since born mixing with those kids almost has same identity as his, of course he would automaticly follows their behavior..although radha tries hard to give her best for aakash, this not working out for him...boys always find their first ideal man is their father..but in aakash case, he could not do that so he looks for idealism outoff the house in the person he knows/likes. so majority off the person that willing to mix with him is what he is today.

another point, if radha had a baby girl she might be different because that gal might see her mother as ideal person in her life...then you would have seen another yash character there..

thanks for your post..join us...make more positive post..
Edited by yamunah79 - 13 years ago
pickachu thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Welcome to the forum!
some members have answered ur post!
Nice to see few people opening up!

saheli_behir thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
nice to hear ur opinion.. 😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".