My Analysis on our Birthday Episode - Page 2

Originally posted by: kdsubs1

Edited (see, i do come back):

Aside from the fact that its very well written (which is a given, and u know who i would tell u to show this to) - very well analyzed, K.

As we discussed earlier, power corrupts - and SP is a manifestation of that. When a wonderfully strong character stoops, he/she finds new depths to sink to. If SP had told the truth to Gayu...if he had stood by Radha...if...if...the saddest word in the english language. And one for which others pay the price - as Akash and Radha have been doing, as the entire S family, but especially Yash and Gayu will now.

One parallel which came to mind when this track unfolded, and you touched upon it, is Ansh. Not just the parallels between Akash and Ansh which is obvious with the Radha-Arti team; but the parallels between Yash and Ansh. Both adored by their mothers, both adoring their fathers, both despicably let down by their biological fathers. Ansh had Arti and then Yash to steady him; Yash has Arti to steady him. But will that be enough? Has Yash progressed/grown sufficiently to be able to take on (which he will) and withstand the backlash, pain, ostracism coming his way?

Riveting character study of the lead - after a long time...

Originally posted by: Kittya_Cullen

Di you are certainly doing far better than I. (I do know who you would tell me to show this to? Are you sure? I can be really dense at times.)

As you've said, "If" is one of the saddest words in the English dictionary. There are so many times that this word could have changed the balance of things in the lives of the characters, in the storyline or in the overall execution of the show. I do believe we've lamented that enough though😉

Now to the interesting parallel you've highlighted. It's not something I noticed instantly, but now that you've brought it up. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Both males have been horribly let down by the men who should have their role models for the men they ought to have become. It is a credit to their respective mothers that they were nurtured into such amazing individuals, and hopefully, like Ansh found an imperfect yet perfect Yash, Yash will be able to find that imperfect yet perfect father in Suraj. The difference so far is that both make mistakes, but only one of them has learned to acknowledge it and learn from it, and later use it to improve as an individual.

@bold - and this is precisely what makes PV interesting to me again.

Originally posted by: jyoti06

Kadeen Its so good to see u pen down such fab take on this episode 👏... I agree that its Aarti's greatness not to draw the parallel here and tell Yash now u understand what dilemma I went through during Prashant case 😆 but I guess it was not the right time for Aarti to say it but I m not sure if in future Aarti does mention this point to Yash ...lets see 🤔...

Coming back to Yash , I feel after the Prashant fiasco where Yash had to go against his father only to discover that SP was innocent while Dubey was main culprit , there is a certain guilt in Yash's heart that he wronged his father in unfair way and even had doubts regarding Ansh ka kidnapping , reason why I see a extra protective Yash today in defence of his father .. Even after seeing DNA reports , somewhere Yash feels there must b a reason behind all this whicxh he dunno and so better I safeguard my father's dignity here .//. Its the previous guilt speaking here I feel 🤔

Originally posted by: kdsubs1

@bold - and this is precisely what makes P interesting to me again.

Originally posted by: Kittya_Cullen

P is a psychologist's dream. I intend to delve into that warped mind as much as I can with the few details we ever got. Would advise you watch the pre-Mumbai episodes to see him before he lost all his crackers, marbles and everything else inbetween.

Lol - i meant PV - the show, fat fingers i guess 😛. But yes, P has always been a fascinating character study for me.