Parallels of Aarthi and Yash's characters - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

2.9k

Users

15

Likes

81

Frequent Posters

padma_17 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#21
I completely agree with u star...
U were rite in pointing out tat yash needs aarti more than aarti needing yash...
Ansh gets all his wishes fulfilled has only one lacking tats the fathers face,on the other hand Payal and Palak miss their mother a lot compared to ansh missing his father...

U nailed it when u said aarti might have lots of difficulty in loving yash compared to he having to love her coz he tasted the bitterness of love and yash tasted the sweetness though he lost it the hurt is minimal than the betrayal aarti faced coz of prashant...

spoorthi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#22
awesome post👏
what left 2 say -u said it all👍🏼
great analysis
amourfouGC thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#23
well analysed n strong points point outed from the stery line which should be considered in the society n all these issues should be discussed in a very good way through that show ...
NightStarr thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: urworstnitemare

SO I haven't been on IF for AGES! Nor have I posted anything but your 'yupping' kinda made me :P Notice the quotation marks- I didn't think you were 'yupping' at all, in fact, I enjoyed reading your post!

I think your analysis is bang on there! But I don't know if Aarti is looking for or needs a companion, maybe that's just the feminist in speaking. I feel like she is at a very vulnerable spot right now and is content being what she is, a mother.
And I can see why these two are so against the whole concept of remarriage, especially Aarti- remarriages can either be really good or very very horrid! Kudoos to the gal if she DOES agree to marry again- I would never be able to do that if I went through a betrayal like hers. Like you said, Aarti and her son don't seem to be needing a man in their life per say as much as Yash needs a mother for his kids...and I don't see Aarti being emotionally blackmailed by her MIL into a serious commitment like that either- in fact, I don't want Aarti to be blackmailed!

The show is going very well so far, but like you pointed out, its been like 3+ years, and the guy still doesn't know how to comb his daughters hair? I don't know, but that really bugged me. Maybe it shows how reliant he is on others when it comes to raising his daughters but...gah! He should be more independent! He should man up and learn how to not just claim that he is capable of taking care of his daughters, he needs to buck up and do it!

Woah! Talk about a being all over the place there! haha. Thanks for sharing your thoughts!!!!



Aww first of you put a BIG smile on my face by your kind words of how much you liked my analysis :) so Thank you for That!!!

Now in regards to your feminist side speaking I know exactly what you mean!!! When I posted the differences between Aarthi and Yash I didn't mean to say one if more difficult than other or vise versa. I was going more along the lines of how society judges a woman compared to a man and how even if the situations were to be reversed Aarthi would still hear some nasty remarks from others due her not having a husband in her life and Ansh not having a father. I think Aarthi has done the best she could with the situation she is presented with. She is a dotting mother, a loving daughter-in-law and a working woman. That's what made me like her even more that even though life has really kicked her and made her fall she didn't stay on the ground but has managed to not only pick herself up but also to built a life where if one looks on the surface they would never think that she needs someone's help to manage things. I think she needs Yash more as father figure than a husband at this point in her life because it seems like while she is still hurting from her husband's betrayal and still think about him, she has learned to move on in her life and keep things to herself. So from an emotional point of view she does need someone to simply lay her head at the end of the day and tell them about her day and ask them about their day but contrary to societal view she doesn't need a man to support her on basic needs.

Yash on the hand, true has a different situation and a difficult one as that but he seems to still suffer from the loss of his wife to fully dedicate himself to his children. But when I was comparing the two characters I was focusing more on the fact that if the roles were to be reversed Aarthi would still be taunted on not having a husband and Yash might will probably receive sympathy as having his wife walk out on him. So, while the situations are different, and both characters are presented with very different and difficult situations- Aarthi seems to have things under control both inside and outside the house. Where as Yash not so much and we can list many reasons as to why but I think the main reason is he is still suffering and trying to cope with losing his wife and is not able to fully dedicate himself.

362035 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#25
awesooome...
fab..
superb..
loved d post...👏
NightStarr thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: -enchanted-



Agree with the points. Yash's situation is actually a bit more difficult and complex than Aarti. There is of course the fact that even today Mother is considered the 'nourisher' and father the 'provider'. Taking care of kids comes naturally to mother esp,when they are so young. But that's not all that is to it. Yash can learn the ropes too with a little support and patience from his family and daughters. But that seems to be lacking. In Aarti's case.she shares a very beautiful bond with her son, and even Ansh seems mature in his own way. He writes that he misses his Dad in letters,but never says it outright to Aarti,in a way that could hurt her. Whereas in case of Yash as soon as he wasnt able to do his daughter's hair properly,his daughters spoke outright,that Dad doesnt know a thing and why dont they have a mother. And it did hurt him,you could see it in his defeated expressions.His smile just vanished. Ansh, on the other hand,it seems somehow,has better understanding of the situation. Maybe because his world revolves only around his mother as he has no siblings. Whereas Palak and Payal, it seems are more involved with teasing or fighting with each other while their father,fades into background.

Then of course Yash cant be there all the time for his girls,as he has a job to do. We dont know if Aarti,has one too. But even if she has there are Ansh's grandparents to take care of him. In Yash's case it his Bhabhi has her own family to look after and would be her first priority. His mother has to run the house. So despite their best intentions they may not be able to give Payal and Palak,the attention the require.



Totally agree with both of your points!!!! I was not in any way saying one situation is easier than the other but was more so focusing on the fact the way society sees and judges a man and woman in their situations. I feel like both situations are equally hard. You feel like Yash's situation is hard as he has lost his loving wife and a mother to his children and many other great reasons that you have listed above but I feel like similar things could be said about Aarthi's situation because not only she lost the love her life as she did have a love marriage, she lost her life partner, someone she depended on, the father of her child but all the pain of this aside she had to deal with people taunting her, abusing her with their words and judgments, she not only had to live with her pain of losing her husband and being left with an unborn child but also deal with society. So, I don't think one could say one situation is more difficult than the other but rather how society misjudges a woman regardless of the situation she is in. Aslo, in regard to Yash and the reasons you listed for him not being able to care for his children the best he could because of the interference from his family but I personally feel like he is still suffering and coping with the fact that he lost his wife/love of his life and bother of his children and is not able to fully devote himself to his children even though that is the only thing he wishes to do.
NightStarr thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Allbut1

Lovely analysis...Agree with everything you pointed out! Especially the part where you said that Yash will be needing Aarti more in his life than Aarti will be needing him.

I hadn't really thought about this before, but you raise some wonderful points and provide a bang on reasoning behind all of them, I really enjoyed reading them. After reading your post and then rewatching the episode, there is definitely no doubt that Yash's life is spiraling more out of control than Aarti's. Since Aarti is a mother, she has that natural instinct of taking care and nurturing Ansh, but Yash doesn't have that. He still struggles to do the smallest tasks for his daughters, and since they're two of them it becomes even harder to take care of them.

That's why I have been thinking that Aarti will have a mush easier time bonding and getting close to the girls than Yash will have with Ansh. But either way, watching how the relationships form between Aarti, Yash and the kids is basically the crux of the show, and I for one can't wait to see how they deal with that!



Thank you and glad you loved the analysis 😊
And yes your totally right. I think Aarthi naturally is very mother like and the fact that she already has a son of her own makes her perfect mother material. I think she will bond with the girls in no time, not mention she would be caring for them and would probably be more home even if she is working outside as opposed to Yash, so would be able to spend more time with girls and bond with them.

And yes, I loved the concept of the show and the reality aspect that's shown so far is very appealing not mention the issues its tackling I think is very big in our society and needs to be discussed more and not tiptoed around.

NightStarr thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: ksnforums

I like the post .
Ur r right of the two Aarti seems to be more stronger and with her ma in law support she seems to be doing a decent job of of living her life and raising her child.

Yash on the other hand seems to be missing his wife a lot is living in the past.
Will be interesting to see how the two get along with the daily conundrums of living together but without the emotional and physical connect.



Totally agree with you!!! Yes I feel like Yash is still living in the past and suffering the loss of his wife and that stops her from fully devoting himself to his children even though he wants to! I can't wait for them to get married and watch the small awkwardness between the two and how the two of them deal with daily things 😊

NightStarr thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#29
Thank youuu everyone for you response to my analysis!!! I didn't think anyone would even bother reading it as it was reallly long and I was rambling and rambling 😆

Glad you guys liked and loved the discussion it started. I absolutely love the show simply for tackling such an issue that society usually has people tiptoeing around even though it is 21st century and people should be more open minded and open to new things. I can't wait to see the them married and see how they deal with daily struggles as well as societal stereotype and expectations of them failing or not loving each other because their each other's second husband.wife.


Love
Star

Edited by NightStarr - 13 years ago
NightStarr thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: maanddy

loved Aarthi and her mother- in law both changing into night gown/comfortable cloths for sleeping- my biggest problem with other shows where they sleep a ton of make up and double that jewelry) I agree, I really never understand why these people sleep with heavy sari and ornaments ON? Isn't it irritating? I can hardly breathe when I wear this kind of heavy sarees and Jewellery...Though I have worn sari for only 3 times...😆



Haha I knowww!!! I could never understand that. I mean in all these other shows all the women go to sleep all decked up with a ton of make up, jewelry, and uncomfortable clothing like their getting ready to go out or some kind of wedding

I honestly don't see much difference between the way they are daily and when they get ready for something special 😆 LOL

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".