Is Nilima's perception right? It is !

Mitrashakti thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Who is a criminal ?

A person who commits a crime...Has Krishna committed a crime ? Yes he has.

I will not even go to the various incidents where he displayed his irrational behavior ...the various times he has verbally and physically manhandled Pratigya... the various times he has carried and used a gun...Does all these incidents fall into the category of being a criminal. Yes in the eyes of law and in a civil society ,it does.I am still going to disregard these incidents...just for the fact that he grew up in an uncivilized environment.

But saying that ,I cannot disregard the fact that he did kidnap an innocent girl and captivated her. Is kidnapping a criminal act ? Yes it is. His kidnapping of Sunaina is not only a criminal act but it is inhuman. This act alone makes him a criminal. He did cross the line. Kidnapping of an innocent person cannot be justified by simply saying that he did it for his dad.

This act alone makes him a criminal.

I hope Pratigya realizes this truth sooner or later. The sooner the better.
Edited by anusarkar - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

2.5k

Users

11

Likes

72

Frequent Posters

GunDaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
Nilimma did blamed Krishna unknowingly because she did'nt know what happened between them after their marriage...how he sucks the poison bagera bagera...

yaa i agree with you that Krishna is a Criminal...but if a criminal trying to improve to what he has done earlier without living in jail...then he should be forgiven once and would have given a one chance atleast...

in my Opinion Krishna is a Criminal earlier but now he is an innocent man...
Veena.S thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Krish has alwayz his own reasons in doing such things like kidnapping a girl r man handling on pratz... Yes all these r crimes under law... But krish is alwayz correct in his POV... Coz his intentions r not to harm with out any reasons... Once he realizes his mistake he alwayz stand by pratz n try to correct it... He is kind hearted n good at heart , itz a known fact... Even criminals will hav their own reasons for doing crime things n depends on the situation also... We can't judge a person by just 2,3 days observation, wat we see is alwayz not correct..., as a frnd neelima can show concern for pratz, but she don't hav any right to judge their married life only by few days observation...
Edited by Veena.S - 14 years ago
643898 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
Yes krishna is a criminal but a criminal who loves pratigya madly ,who saved her when angad was after her,who sucked poison to save her,who fought his father brother mother for her,who supported her when her own hypocrite family did not beleive her,who washed the coal from her face with a destroyed heart and was always for her even though she hated him and pratigya was the one whose hatred changed into LOVE for this criminal
Mitrashakti thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Amit_Mehra

Nilimma did blamed Krishna unknowingly because she did'nt know what happened between them after their marriage...how he sucks the poison bagera bagera...

yaa i agree with you that Krishna is a Criminal...but if a criminal trying to improve to what he has done earlier without living in jail...then he should be forgiven once and would have given a one chance atleast...

in my Opinion Krishna is a Criminal earlier but now he is an innocent man...



Hello Amit,

Today's world is very fast and progressive. In a lifetime we are lucky if we ever get a chance to undo are wrong doing... And Pratigya has given chances after chances to Krishna. He should have been a changed man without looking back the day Pratigya took a bullet for him. Well, I thought that is an ultimate sacrifice a wife can give ... But nothing changed after that either, on the contrary he abused her and through her out of the house ...well Amit, everyone is biased towards Krishna... But I am appalled by the fact that no one considers what P has gone through ... How does an educated, well behaved woman live in the TN conditions. She is the one who has sacrificed, not Krishna. Anyways, in such circumstances in real life does not stand... Love is not the only dominant factor in a marriage...ideals will come to play an important role.
Mitrashakti thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Veena.S

Krish has alwayz his own reasons in doing such things like kidnapping a girl r man handling on pratz... Yes all these r crimes under law... But krish is alwayz correct in his POV... Coz his intentions r not to harm with out any reasons... Once he realizes his mistake he alwayz stand by pratz n try to correct it... He is kind hearted n good at heart , itz a known fact... Even criminals will hav their own reasons for doing crime things n depends on the situation also... We can't judge a person by just 2,3 days observation, wat we see is alwayz not correct..., as a frnd neelima can show concern for pratz, but she don't hav any right to judge their married life only by few days observation...



Hello Veena,

Yes, even criminals have their own reasons... But only the wrong reasons. About Neelima judging their lives...I have only one thing to say... Neelima is Pratigya's college friend and she knows Pratigya way before K. If a person is capable of falling in love with someone at the first sight, then it's very natural and possible for Neelima to judge Krishna in 2 or E
3 days. The fact that Krishna does not let Pratigya answer any of the questions directed to her is an enough reason for her.
Mitrashakti thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: adib40

Yes krishna is a criminal but a criminal who loves pratigya madly ,who saved her when angad was after her,who sucked poison to save her,who fought his father brother mother for her,who supported her when her own hypocrite family did not beleive her,who washed the coal from her face with a destroyed heart and was always for her even though she hated him and pratigya was the one whose hatred changed into LOVE for this criminal

Oh dear, these are not good enough reasons for showing one's love. Please do not forget, Pratigya made the ultimate sacrifice... the poor girl took a bullet for him. If that did not change him...nothing will. That is the ultimate sacrifice a person can make. In return, he through her out of the house and signed the divorce papers.
GunDaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: anusarkar



Hello Amit,

Today's world is very fast and progressive. In a lifetime we are lucky if we ever get a chance to undo are wrong doing... And Pratigya has given chances after chances to Krishna. He should have been a changed man without looking back the day Pratigya took a bullet for him. Well, I thought that is an ultimate sacrifice a wife can give ... But nothing changed after that either, on the contrary he abused her and through her out of the house ...well Amit, everyone is biased towards Krishna... But I am appalled by the fact that no one considers what P has gone through ... How does an educated, well behaved woman live in the TN conditions. She is the one who has sacrificed, not Krishna. Anyways, in such circumstances in real life does not stand... Love is not the only dominant factor in a marriage...ideals will come to play an important role.

Anu di 'i am not biased at all,u can check my previous post,hv treated K And P both equally😃these are the thoughts which camed in my mind so i thought to share with u all😃
Veena.S thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: anusarkar



Hello Veena,

Yes, even criminals have their own reasons... But only the wrong reasons. About Neelima judging their lives...I have only one thing to say... Neelima is Pratigya's college friend and she knows Pratigya way before K. If a person is capable of falling in love with someone at the first sight, then it's very natural and possible for Neelima to judge Krishna in 2 or E
3 days. The fact that Krishna does not let Pratigya answer any of the questions directed to her is an enough reason for her.

no can't agree, there is no rule of having alwayz wrong reasons... Definitly depends on situation also... Neelima may find krish's every act odd n indecent, but she is frd of pratz, then she must be knew her frn right... Then Neelima should hav think once there must be something in krish which made her frn to love him n keeping her frn happy with him bfore coming 2 a conclusion... Am not saying krish is perfect... Ofcourse krish has to change alot... First he has to leave thakurs attitude n see the reality n has to bcome independant... Am not saying Neelima is completly wrong, her concern for pratz is ok n reasonable... But her judgement is wrong with little knowledge of wat she heard n wat she saw... She can clarify with her frn bfore coming 2 a conclusion...
Edited by Veena.S - 14 years ago
Mitrashakti thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Amit_Mehra

Anu di 'i am not biased at all,u can check my previous post,hv treated K And P both equally😃these are the thoughts which camed in my mind so i thought to share with u all😃

No Amit, I never meant you were biased. Your thoughts are right too. But you have to agree that ppl are biased towards K in this forum and to me that is fine. For me like some, I have never liked Krishna's character ...the very arrogant way he pursued P never appealed to me. No matter what it's not logical for a girl to go ahead and marry her stalker. Amit, a person does not have to be educated to be civil and well behaved. For instance, the new boy in TN is uneducated , but he is so well behaved.
If k really loves the way ppl presume he does, then he should have been a changed man after P took the bullet for him.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".