Could Aamir have done MNIK?

Frequent Posters

Sophz

@Sophz

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#21

He could but it would still be bad because the whole sucked!

Quote

Sanjeeda

@.Sad.But.True.

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: Mr.KaminA
FreshDaisy
I haven't seen EARTH, coz that film is made for Critics only, they loved it. That is not the kind of film or i say Aamir film i enjoy watching in Cinema Halls. That movie couldn't even excite me 2 watch it.

Regarding -ve role, Hands Down to SRK for doing such roles, Darr is phenomenal, no contemporaries from his time can even come near 2 what he does in those kind of roles. Next stars come close him are Ajay Devgn (Deewangi, Omkara) & Saif Ali Khan (Omkara).

Aamir was such a big let down in Sahir's role. Samar i can still give OK after re-watching the movie, but 1st introduction shot of Aamir coming down the bank n making that look... big 👎🏼

I mentioned Earth cause you said Aamir cant do negative role which isnt true as Earth proves that.
Coming to SRK in negative role then yeah he did great too. Noone's taking away credit from him.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Lukha Khiladi

@Sultan.Mirza

Achiever

+ 5

Sarcastic Chatterbox

Posted: 12 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: FreshDaisy

No. I didnt bring Salman cause you are Salman's fan. I just brought him to explain my point. You all are always indirectly hinting how Aamir in D3 was epic fail which is actually not true for many. What I wanted to say was that critics' reviews arent everything. If Aamir was so unacceptable then the movie wouldnt have done 'this' good business. This shows that audience accepted him. I didnt even criticise Salman. His audience loves him too. Infact I like Salman 😊

Who is questioning what D3 earned at BO here? or Audience loved it or not? In fact i made a thread on why Dhoom 3 was not selected for Screen Awards ignoring the same audience's love for that movie which gave it 275 Cr business.

I or some other hinting or saying how Aamir in D3 is epic fail is just the same way ppl trash all Salman's past 5 blockbusters. It doesn't reflect on what actual audience or Bo collection was.

I just gave my view on 2 character roles which i think 1 actor will do good or not.