I'm disappointed in Jalal today - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

2.9k

Users

14

Likes

87

Frequent Posters

sonia_1 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: preet_pal320


That's what disappointed me, that fact that he was ready to do it. I'm still waiting to see if anything else will happen at the end of this track, some kind of twist to redeem it. I do not want this kind of self-sacrificing Jalal; I want him to be the man who manages to get his way and shuts up his enemies all in one blow.


I expected the same 😕
preet_pal320 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Ariel

This is why Ruks was running around like a headless chicken begging everyone to save her marriage!!

I think she knew he was not going to do anything!

Sorry, the way this track has concluded made me so mad but I'm laughing now at how ridiculous this was!!

Almost as bad as blue vomit!

Great job CVs😡


Lol, for me it's worse than the blue vomit! The blue vomit was ridiculous but it didn't really mess with anyone's character (Except Khwaja Sera's, maybe). This is worse cuz by this point we know who Jalal is and what he's capable of but so far he's just been looking around like a lost puppy. Hope we get our clever Shahenshah back!
chyetta thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#23
please everyone give ekta a breathing space. i will say it again and again, the audience can never be satisfied. w hen jodha was not providing any solution to problems, u called her a dummy queen now she has helped jalal out of a mess, jalal is now the fool.
we all have forgotten that jodha is actually the person who will help jalal become great, how will she become the MARIAM if she cannot provide support or help her husband. We are forgetting here that jalal too is not a perfect human or a super man. He is man with flaws also.
Therefore people stop bashing characters in jodha akbar, try and enjoy the serial.jalal will become the great akbar through the help of jodha. Today jodha proved that she is a queen and a rajput at that
lashy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: chyetta

please everyone give ekta a breathing space. i will say it again and again, the audience can never be satisfied. w hen jodha was not providing any solution to problems, u called her a dummy queen now she has helped jalal out of a mess, jalal is now the fool.

we all have forgotten that jodha is actually the person who will help jalal become great, how will she become the MARIAM if she cannot provide support or help her husband. We are forgetting here that jalal too is not a perfect human or a super man. He is man with flaws also.
Therefore people stop bashing characters in jodha akbar, try and enjoy the serial.jalal will become the great akbar through the help of jodha. Today jodha proved that she is a queen and a rajput at that

There is a big difference between providing a solution in a convoluted matter and becoming a sitting duck and doing NOTHING
Jodha was unanimously praised when she gave Jalal that birthday gift and she was praised when she stood against MA and Ruqs... but, does it really depict any logic that a man who used his shrewdness in past affairs really didn't know how to handle this mess...
this wasn't some chanakya-neethi or Shakuni-ploy..it was quite straightforward and simple...a man who could investigate the fake pregnancy by himself and solve the ratanpur mystery by himself didn't know what to do at all?😕

It is the fact that Jalal is portrayed as a weak character irrespective of whether Jodha gave her advise or not... They could have shown Jalal at least actively taking some stance/thinking/discussing etc before just accepting defeat and sitting in that manner... the problem is not about Jo appearing strong..its about Jalal appearing weak and how will the pairing between a strong female and a weak male appear to the audiences?😕 or maybe that's how it is in all shows today...

Edited by lashy - 12 years ago
preet_pal320 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: chyetta

please everyone give ekta a breathing space. i will say it again and again, the audience can never be satisfied. w hen jodha was not providing any solution to problems, u called her a dummy queen now she has helped jalal out of a mess, jalal is now the fool.

we all have forgotten that jodha is actually the person who will help jalal become great, how will she become the MARIAM if she cannot provide support or help her husband. We are forgetting here that jalal too is not a perfect human or a super man. He is man with flaws also.
Therefore people stop bashing characters in jodha akbar, try and enjoy the serial.jalal will become the great akbar through the help of jodha. Today jodha proved that she is a queen and a rajput at that


I have never said a word against Jodha's character. I admire the way she's been handling things lately, and I love her discussions with Jalal. They speak to each other as equals now and their conversations are so intelligent. They both have good and bad qualities, and I'm happy to see both of these qualities come up to the surface, and I love seeing them both change each other for the better.

My issue is with this track. I was able to bear past ridiculous tracks because they were at least executed well and I was satisfied with the way they were solved. You're saying that Jodha is helping Jalal out of this mess; it's the MESS that I have issue with. I don't see the logic in this problem, and I don't see the logic in showing Jalal telling Ruqs to trust him, as if he has a plan, when he didn't have one at all. I'm perfectly fine with Jodha helping him with problems; that's what I've been wanting for a long time. But the problem should be something that's logical, and I find this track to be a mess. I've also said many times that my biggest problem with this track is that Jalal was ready to divorce Ruqaiya. This is him admitting defeat and sacrificing such an important relationship! It does not speak well on his character and it didn't sit well with me.
petrichorr thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#26
I don't think there is a soul who would've been proud of Jalaal today.
The problem is the way the past episodes were presented to us, we thought he had something going on in his mind... A proper solution...
But all those deep thinking moments... God only knows what he was thinking about.
Anycase perhaps the creative wanted to show us how they both complete each other. In Amer Jalaal sprung to action w.r.t fort and now when he was so bogged down by the issues, Jodha sprung to action.
While I don't have any issue with that, I have several issues with the way today's episode played out.
Ariel thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: prejudiced

I don't think there is a soul who would've been proud of Jalaal today.

The problem is the way the past episodes were presented to us, we thought he had something going on in his mind... A proper solution...
But all those deep thinking moments... God only knows what he was thinking about.
Anycase perhaps the creative wanted to show us how they both complete each other. In Amer Jalaal sprung to action w.r.t fort and now when he was so bogged down by the issues, Jodha sprung to action.
While I don't have any issue with that, I have several issues with the way today's episode played out.


Its ok for Jo to help. I agree with that. but the solution was right under his nose. In amer, he listened to her, but his solution was a master stroke. It was well thought of and unpredictable.

Here the problem was trivialized when it shouldn't have been, a mockery was made of a king and his marriage and the solution that was so obvious was completely ignored. Its not as plausible like the Amer track was. Jo raised the issue and then had no strategy to counter Adham like Jalal had a strategy for Ratanpur. Instead she had to listen to Ruks and her rants.

Jo unfortunately is not looking smart for coming up with the solution in the last minute and Jalal is looking dumb for not knowing what he was doing. No plan at all.
petrichorr thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: Ariel


Its ok for Jo to help. I agree with that. but the solution was right under his nose. In amer, he listened to her, but his solution was a master stroke. It was well thought of and unpredictable.

Here the problem was trivialized when it shouldn't have been, a mockery was made of a king and his marriage and the solution that was so obvious was completely ignored. Its not as plausible like the Amer track was. Jo raised the issue and then had no strategy to counter Adham like Jalal had a strategy for Ratanpur. Instead she had to listen to Ruks and her rants.

Jo unfortunately is not looking smart for coming up with the solution in the last minute and Jalal is looking dumb for not knowing what he was doing. No plan at all.

Yeah! However much I "try" to come up with reasons as to why the creative team would've come up with this approach - its not jiving...
It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure this solution...We all know that..
It also didn't seem like Jalaal was too distraught (going by the past episodes) with what was happening that he was incapable of thinking...
Mages thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#29
i am very disappointed...i can't believe that jallu was ready to divorce ruku...and he did not have any backup plan till jodha bring him out of the mess...the cvs totally mess up this track...and i am thankful...at last its ending...they really made jallu a dumb emperor...
i want to assume this track never existed...i want to isolate all the Ruqlal eternal love saga...and just make assume that jallu has issue a new law to ban child marriage...and jodha have helped him...the public punished adham...the eternal love saga...accusation...allegations...doesn't exist for me...

i am completely disappointed with the whole track...above all the cvs for making jallu look like a dumb...he had postpone his verdict...he could have crack his brains how to save his marriage rather than having a eternal love saga with his tantrum queen...the night could have used to crack a plan B...but he wasted on hugging...kissing...wiping tears...i can't believe that he did not nothing but ready to give a divorce if not for jodha...he would have done this blunder...and we would witness the love saga of Ruqkaiyya Akbar rather than Jodha Akbar

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".