~Nach Baliye 6- Judges Discussion Thread [JDT] #1~

Page

Next Last

@krystel21

Alumni

+ 5

Posted: 11 years ago

Nach Baliye Season 6

Judges' Discussion Thread #1 [JDT]

It has been observed that there are way too many topics on the forum that mostly discuss the judges and their judging of the performances in the show. Therefore, to avoid repetitive topics, the section DT has come up with the Judges Discussion Thread, henceforth known as the JDT.
All discussions related to the judges and their judging should now on be done in this thread. Any other topics opened will be merged with this one without question.
This thread is meant solely to comment and discuss the 3 judges and their judgement/marking of the contestants' performances. The following rules are to be followed AT ALL TIMES in all discussions

Rules:

You are allowed to appreciate and criticize the judges and their judgement in this thread. But, in no ways whatsoever is the criticism supposed to snowball into plain abusing/bashing/name-calling of the judges/participants/hosts of the show.
This is the thread for the judges of Nach Baliye 6, meaning Sajid Khan, Shilpa Shetty and Terence Lewis. There is no need to compare these 3 judges with the judges of the past seasons of Nach Baliye, or with judges of any other reality shows
Comparisons related to the marks received by contesting couples will be tolerated, as long as it is done in a civil and polite manner, without bashing/abusing/name-calling any contestants/fangroups
This thread is made exclusively to discuss the judges and their judgement of the performances. Any discussions about the contestants and/or their performances can be done in the EDT or in the respective ATs
Casual chit chat/Deviation from topic at hand WILL be allowed for about 3-5 pages ONLY. Please try and stick to the main purpose of the thread or the current topic of discussion at hand
Please follow the IF CoC India-Forums.com- Participation Guidelines & Rules and the NB6 Forum Rules Nach Baliye Season 6 Forum Rules-Read Before Posting at ALL times during discussions.

Edited by BalamPichkaari - 11 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Silence

@SecretKhabri420

Achiever

+ 9

Posted: 11 years ago

Thanks, I really wish Sajid to be replaced, as he is very biased and not fair...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

DivyaMala

@-MishtyBlue-

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Love Terrence Judging...He always point out the flaws of the contestants in genuine n technical way without taunting people...thats really a good nature of judging!!

Edit: Thanks for the Special thread for Judges!!

Edited by -Mrs.MasHGc- - 11 years ago

Quote

.Nikki.

@.Nikki.

Rocker

Posted: 11 years ago

Sajid needs to be replaced, i know many people who don't watch the show just because of Sajid.

Quote

Dina

@-DeeNaa-

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

I feel they really need to replace Sajid's Judging. He is always the one to let down the contestants! Shilpa normally gives positive comments and boosts them and Terrence is very good at giving constructive criticism when needed keeping in mind how they contestants feel, he always tells them in a good manner unlike Sajid, I feel he is the perfect judge !

Quote

golpokobita

@golpokobita

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Sajid Khan should be replaced.

He doesn't qualify to be a judge -legally, morally and technically.

Legally - In a competition, the examiner/ judge cannot openly declare his/her favourite. He can have a favourite but he is not supposed to declare it at the very beginning of the competition.

Morally - He is biased and already declared a winner. What is the point of his judging the show anymore?

Technically - God knows on what basis he judges the dance performances.. His opinion hardly matches with that of veteran dancer like Shilpa and veteran choreographer like Terrence.

Edited by golpokobita - 11 years ago

Quote

DhoniAddict

@BeingBlunt

Achiever

+ 31

Posted: 11 years ago

Just one Question?
"Agar Sajid ko concept samajh me hi nahi aata hai to wo judge kyon Bana?".

Edited by sscomp32 - 11 years ago

Quote

Jesmin

@...Jes...

Achiever

+ 5

Posted: 11 years ago

very disappointed the way Sajid less scored Bruna-Umar! 🤢

Quote

Mayee2217

@Mayee2217

Voyager

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

I am new to this forum..just came..because I really love this show and want the best couple to win.About judging,I fail to understand what is wrong with Sajid Khan.Come on man,you are a judge for crying out loud,you are NOT supposed to be so biased..In everyone else's performance,you come up with 'Gurmeet aur Debina to finalists hai hi',see I have no problem with Gurmeet and Debina,in fact I like them very much as dancers,but Sajid is seriously being very unfair to other couples who are doing brilliant dancing,for example Ritvik and Asha,Omar and Bruna..they have been dancing great recently,especially Omar and Bruna's under water performance was just out of this world!I am not saying it because it was visually breath-taking..they freaking danced holding their breath man,and what Sajid said?'You are supposed to be dancers,not swimmers' come on man,Terrence Lewis is sitting right beside you,he is saying that this type of great and unique dancing has not been performed in India ever before,and you are saying this😡Totally and utterly unfair.Today again,Ritvik and Asha danced on freaking sticks,and Sajid gave them just 7!again,completely unfair!I understand that he likes Gurmeet and Debina the most,but let them win it on their own talent man,you seriously dont need to belittle other couples to get them on top!If they really have it in them,people will definitely vote for them and they will win.Sajid,you should just stop being so unfair and focus on judging,not Fanboying over one particular couple😡