The true cause of Sirius Black's death

im still super mad at Jo for killing Sirius.. hes gangsta.. why kill SIRIUS?

he is honestly my FAVORITE character besides Harry in HP!!

but she still hasnt explained how he died, he just fell behind the veil in the Department of Mysteries.. and hes dead guys, really dead, im still in denial i guess, but Jo says he aint alive!! 😭

but i was thinkng, and this theory is quite old, but for the sake of all those sirius fans out there who want answers, the veil is a portal to death i think, and once someone goes to where those who are dead are go, he cant come back. its like a one way ticket. thats why luna and harry were able to here voices from behind the veil.. the same reason why they could see the horses that pull the carriages (which i forgot what they are called)....

ya think so?

You are suggesting that the veil was a portkey to death? Quite interesting yeah..., but I wonder , if the veil itself was so powerful and magical that it could kill? Correct me , if I got your suggestion wrong here...I seem to giving out my thoughts at random...

It makes wanna believe that veil transports as you said to a place , where the person would be killed, as in to someplace , where Voldermort is and he would then jus kill.... Not too sure... but it seems to be more of a possession Voldy....

wow. ur smart,but i guess ur prob smarter than me cauz im only 13 so that could explain it, lol, jk...i liked sirius too and he was a really good friend to harry, i dont think JKR should have killed him he was the only family (friend) of harry's that was nice, u noe wht would be the perfect ending? killing voldemort and then whoever got hurt by the deatheaters or voldermort would come back alive or whtevr spell was on them would be broken ? wht do u think?

btw it was a very good explanation

i would like to agree with u...
but speaking as a hard core sirius lover, i would say

we have not seen his dead body and so

ALIVE UNTIL PROVEN DEAD!

i rest my case!!!

intresting theories 😃 i dont no wot i think but i wish sirius cud cum bk, but hes dead and now wen i read about him now, before he died it makes me think, none hv them wud hv thought that he wudnt be there much longer, it wasnt fair cos harry didnt get chance to get to no sirius for that long 😭 i agree with suga and spices theory thoe, portal to death but it seems they r still there behind the viel, but they cant cum bk, but u can hear voices rite, so i think yr rite 😊 😛

agree 100% with ysh,my best frnd n fellow sirius lover 😳
well c luna n harry were able to hear voices,agreed...but rmmbr wht else luna said? "theyll be back,harry!" !!!!!!!! 😳😳😳
and this one sentence is my biggest hope tht im clingin to 😳

ur askin me y i bliv luna 😆 bcos thts how jkr operates!! 😛 luna always makes d vaguest statements n belives in the strangest things,so its befitting tht smthin she says at d end of hbp will turn out true in hp7!!
this is nt exactly proof,but i still m hoping this hope very dearly 😳
so,ppl,in conclusion to this post,theres jst one thing id lyk to say~~!

I believe in crumple horned snorcacks!!! 😆😆😆

okok j/k bt my sirius is DEFINITELY NOT DEAD!! 🥳

Oh yes and i completely forgot to add: Sirius fanss...

Let's decipher book 7's title, shall we?

Hallows: im paraphrasing, but its like the time when the VEIL between the two worlds thin and the dead spirits walk the earth...

hmm which character is dead, and is connected to a veil??
SIRIUS!!

infact, any dead character for that matter, but most likely SIRIUS!!!

yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaa..i agree 😳
my sirius is so cumin back

Originally posted by: coolniyu

agree 100% with ysh,my best frnd n fellow sirius lover 😳
well c luna n harry were able to hear voices,agreed...but rmmbr wht else luna said? "theyll be back,harry!" !!!!!!!! 😳😳😳
and this one sentence is my biggest hope tht im clingin to 😳

ur askin me y i bliv luna 😆 bcos thts how jkr operates!! 😛 luna always makes d vaguest statements n belives in the strangest things,so its befitting tht smthin she says at d end of hbp will turn out true in hp7!!
this is nt exactly proof,but i still m hoping this hope very dearly 😳
so,ppl,in conclusion to this post,theres jst one thing id lyk to say~~!

I believe in crumple horned snorcacks!!! 😆😆😆

okok j/k bt my sirius is DEFINITELY NOT DEAD!! 🥳

dear niyu....

I am also a Sirius fan.... but the point is since JKR has said that he's dead.... it means he's dead.

tejas