girlwhowaited thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Hi guys, I am a new member. I have, however, been a regular visitor of DM since 2007 (yes, that long). I always wanted to participate in discussions but never had the gut to do so. So, today, after 6 long years, I've finally gathered the courage to start a topic.

So, here is my question: What are your thoughts on adoption? Is it only considered an option when you can't have a kid of your own? Or do you see it as a charity? Is adoption always justified? When is it not?

I, for one, have always supported the concept of adoption and have always wanted to adopt. There are so many children out there who have been deprived from a loving family and I would love to provide a child with love and care he/she deseves.

I would love to read what your thoughts are on this topic.

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

2.1k

Users

15

Likes

36

Frequent Posters

charminggenie thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: girlwhowaited

Hi guys, I am a new member. I have, however, been a regular visitor of DM since 2007 (yes, that long). I always wanted to participate in discussions but never had the gut to do so. So, today, after 6 long years, I've finally gathered the courage to start a topic.

So, here is my question: What are your thoughts on adoption? Is it only considered an option when you can't have a kid of your own? Or do you see it as a charity? Is adoption always justified? When is it not?

I, for one, have always supported the concept of adoption and have always wanted to adopt. There are so many children out there who have been deprived from a loving family and I would love to provide a child with love and care he/she deseves.

I would love to read what your thoughts are on this topic.


Hey yeah, Girlwhowaited, Big hello to you as well😊. I am sure the brilliant members would be thrilled to meet you! And a secret between us😉, don't think anyone here bites😆, so do drop in whenever you feel like😳!

Now to your question- Adoption is a very beautiful event in everyone's life. It is something very personal and intimate. I am of the opinion, that we should not label it with adjectives , just so it should be encouraged as any other normal form of parenting. The only thing that should be considered is the interest of the child involved. He should be welcomed by a loving , secure and conducive environment. So , advise to anyone looking to adopt, just be sure and be at a right mental state before taking this decision. A child is as much a responsibility as a blessing. And it goes for both natural or adoption. But considering the social outlook towards it , then we should be doubly assured of this decision and be sensitive to its influence on the kid. Don't look at it as some charity case or just a way to make the world a better place. Treat it like a Parent and a child relationship. Just that. Because there are other ways of spreading joy and happiness.
It doesn't need justification or accusations. I personally get offended only when people treat it as an accessory or a social cause. That is unfair to the kid and parenting.

Very noble thought, just be sure that you are ready for this big step of being a parent and all else would be well😳.
Edited by charminggenie - 12 years ago
girlwhowaited thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: charminggenie


Hey yeah, Girlwhowaited, Big hello to you as well😊. I am sure the brilliant members would be thrilled to meet you! And a secret between us😉, don't think anyone here bites😆, so do drop in whenever you feel like😳!

Now to your question- Adoption is a very beautiful event in everyone's life. It is something very personal and intimate. I am of the opinion, that we should not label it with adjectives , just so it should be encouraged as any other normal form of parenting. The only thing that should be considered is the interest of the child involved. He should be welcomed by a loving , secure and conducive environment. So , advise to anyone looking to adopt, just be sure and be at a right mental state before taking this decision. A child is as much a responsibility as a blessing. And it goes for both natural or adoption. But considering the social outlook towards it , then we should be doubly assured of this decision and be sensitive to its influence on the kid. Don't look at it as some charity case or just a way to make the world a better place. Treat it like a Parent and a child relationship. Just that. Because there are other ways of spreading joy and happiness.
It doesn't need justification or accusations. I personally get offended only when people treat it as an accessory or a social cause. That is unfair to the kid and parenting.

Very noble thought, just be sure that you are ready for this big step of being a parent and all else would be well😳.

-FreeSpirit- thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
In my opinion adoption is a very noble idea..so many kids out there who due to unfortunate circumstances have not been brought up by their biological parents...these kids have the rights to be well taken care of and adoption is a good idea...people who want to adopt should provide the best environment for the kid and consider the kid as their own... I don't think adoption should be considered as the only option when they cannot give birth to their own kids it should be a thing from within opening up your home to an adopted child and loving him like ur own
return_to_hades thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#5

My thoughts and feelings really echo Genie here.

I think adoption is a beautiful decision. People shouldn't consider adoption simply because they can't have children. You can adopt instead of having kids of your own or adopt instead of kids on your own (e.g Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie) Even single men and women can adopt if they feel they desire parenthood. (e.g Sushmita Sen). I think each and every person should at least try thinking about adoption at some point. You don't have to do it. Adoption may not be the right choice for everybody. But there are so many orphaned and abandoned children in the world. They all deserve someone who loves them and cares for them. The least we can do is think about it and see if we are ready for something like that. But it definitely shouldn't be charity or treated as a social cause. It should be personal, fulfilling, and enriching - it should feel like having your own child, a part of you.

girlwhowaited thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

A friend of mine recently told me that her parents had given her older sister for adoption when she was three years old. the sister was adopted by a foreigner. My friend said that the reason her sister was given for adoption is because her parents thought that the girl will have a better future in Europe than in her hometown, not that the family was poor but they couldn't have given the kid the facilities that she would get here.

This kind of made me feel...i can't word how I feel. I am not sure if I understand and agree with parents just giving their child away and someone adopting a baby who was already in a loving, albeit a little poor, family. I also find it frustrating that people (atleast people from my neighbourhood) mostly consider babies from poor families for adoption. They go to differents corners of the world to find such kids while abused/abandoned teenagers are usually left abandoned and hardly ever get adopted . This probably makes me a hypocrite because I know adopting to save a child from abuse is also not the right reason to adopt...


return_to_hades thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#7

Personally, I have always found giving up a child to be the worst thing ever. I firmly believe that if you cannot love a child and raise a child then you should not have a child. For me nothing is the sense of abandonment. No matter how much your adopted parents love you. No matter how much your birth parents love you. No matter how much it is for the best. You have the live your life knowing that someone didn't want you. If they actually wanted you, they would have changed the world around for you. It is just a personal emotion - but I know many will disagree. I know many parents are victims of circumstances and have no choice but to give up a child. Despite my personal emotions, I still empathize with that hopelessness that forces such decisions. But parents who are capable of raising a child, but still give them up - that I find is unforgivable.

Abused children and teenagers are a tricky situation. These children tend to be psychologically and sociologically damaged. Many are incapable of trusting, socializing and loving in a normal manner. Some even have reacted with violence, substance abuse, depression and other reactions. In the worst case scenario they have lost their moral compass becoming abusive themselves. All these situations need a lot of healing and undoing of damage before they can move on to be happy well adjusted kids who feel loved. This requires a whole lot of patience and sometimes specialized skill sets and psychological understanding to know the right way to react when things go wrong. Not many people have that patience and understanding. Not many people are capable of reacting correctly or knowing what to do. That is why people avoid adopting them. Even most adoption systems will place them only in specialized foster homes or juvenile facilities. While I wholeheartedly believe every child/teenager deserves a loving home and family - it is very very tricky with abused kids.

girlwhowaited thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: return_to_hades

Personally, I have always found giving up a child to be the worst thing ever. I firmly believe that if you cannot love a child and raise a child then you should not have a child. For me nothing is the sense of abandonment. No matter how much your adopted parents love you. No matter how much your birth parents love you. No matter how much it is for the best. You have the live your life knowing that someone didn't want you. If they actually wanted you, they would have changed the world around for you. It is just a personal emotion - but I know many will disagree. I know many parents are victims of circumstances and have no choice but to give up a child. Despite my personal emotions, I still empathize with that hopelessness that forces such decisions. But parents who are capable of raising a child, but still give them up - that I find is unforgivable.

Abused children and teenagers are a tricky situation. These children tend to be psychologically and sociologically damaged. Many are incapable of trusting, socializing and loving in a normal manner. Some even have reacted with violence, substance abuse, depression and other reactions. In the worst case scenario they have lost their moral compass becoming abusive themselves. All these situations need a lot of healing and undoing of damage before they can move on to be happy well adjusted kids who feel loved. This requires a whole lot of patience and sometimes specialized skill sets and psychological understanding to know the right way to react when things go wrong. Not many people have that patience and understanding. Not many people are capable of reacting correctly or knowing what to do. That is why people avoid adopting them. Even most adoption systems will place them only in specialized foster homes or juvenile facilities. While I wholeheartedly believe every child/teenager deserves a loving home and family - it is very very tricky with abused kids.


I couldn't have said that better. Knowing that your own family could've looked after you but yet they chose (albeit half-heartedly) to give you away to a stranger -someone they themselves didn't know well enough- simply because the stranger happened to have bigger fortune must make that child feel rejected.
girlwhowaited thumbnail
Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9


I'm sorry for not being clear. I didn't mean that they shouldn't be adopted. On the contrary really. I think after all they've been through they deserve a loving home. I think we've established that adoption shouldn't be a social cause, it is not like you see a poor child and you give him food, cloth and a roon in your house or you see a bruised child and you take her in because you pity the child. It is about the child and your bond with the child. However, when one does adopt, the adopted child is most likely to either come from a poor or an abusive background or is an orphan. You can't really go to a happy, stable family and take their child away just because you bond with him now can you? So that is why I feel like a hypocrite when I disagree with people adopting for a social cause.

Do I make any sense??

McNinja thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: girlwhowaited


I couldn't have said that better. Knowing that your own family could've looked after you but yet they chose (albeit half-heartedly) to give you away to a stranger -someone they themselves didn't know well enough- simply because the stranger happened to have bigger fortune must make that child feel rejected.


I have to disagree with that notion, that such children grow up feeling rejected or have a sense of abandonment. This is one possible scenario, but I think comes down to how the adoptive parents handle letting the child know of the adoption and the kind of life the kid had...not all adopted kids go on to have ideal, picturesque lives.

I know of someone who was given up by her parents due to certain situations, even though they could have raised her, and she tells me what she hates more than anything is people feeling pity or sadness for her, and assuming she feels some sense of emptiness or rejection when she doesn't harbor any of these feelings. Most of her peace comes from understanding the circumstances that played a role in the decision in the first place.

That's not to say that adopted kids don't feel these confused emotions or doubt their worth, but I think we assume these emotions play a larger role than they actually do.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".