So SHIV is ADOPTED

It is always better to let the child know about the truth. My own cousin was adopted & my uncle & aunt had themselves told it to him.. It doesn't afftect the relationships, we all have normal relations as if he was born in our family. Hiding such things doesnt create healthy relationships. Alok not able to disclose it to Ira at that time is understandable, but he should have told it sometime later.

I agree...once Shiv had become a teenager, Alok or Meenu could have told Ira...I am sure Ira would have managed and handled it well like a mature lady...And Shiv could have been told about it after he came into job...he would have realized how he was taken care of despite being adopted...

Sometimes Bollywood movies handle it in a better way than BV 😆 Few movies have stories of this type

Originally posted by: timepass

From today's episode it is clear that Shiv is adopted son of Ira and Alok.

Also Shiv is not Meenu's son because Meenu and IRA cannot deliver the baby on the same day, at the same time in the same hospital for the BIG SACRIFICE of swapping babies... it cannot be Meenu's otherwise don't you think we will hear stories of how MEENU and IRA experienced labor pain on the same day, got admitted together and delivered on the same day????

So what I guess is that when Alok and Meenu saw still birth of IRA, they acted together with some hospital help to swap a dead baby with healthy baby...that way Ira believed she delivered a healthy baby and dead baby was disposed off...only ALOK and MEENU know this swap...

So who is Shiv's mother / father?? That is a million dollar question. It can be anyone...and Anandi has to find out who is the biological mother of Shiv...IT IS MUST no matter how painful it turns out to be...

Here is USA adults come to know that they were adopted and then they are united with biological fathers...it gives a great feeling when someone meets their biological parents...

even i feel shiv is not meenu's child but she is just involved in this secret to confuse us...i like the USA system...it good if the child comes to know about it's adopted status when he/she is adult because the way they have shown in BV i don't agree with it much...adopted parents have to disclose to their children the truth after some years only...it means during childhood which i feel a child won't be able to handle

Shiv is meenus son bcoz when meenu was weeping in her room remembering her baby, mahi came and askd her "ye foto to tab ki hai na jab mai paida hone wala tha"...then meenu suddenly corrected him and said"tum nahi beta,tumharaa...(she said tumhara,not tumhari)

in mahavir track ds child was not dead he is alive and he is bhairon and ds's devarani gave her child basant to ds because devrani dont want his child basant to be spoil by his father mahavir

Originally posted by: surabhi01

in mahavir track ds child was not dead he is alive and he is bhairon and devarani gave her child basant to ds because devrani dont want his child basant to be spoil by his father mahavir

Well I guess since Ira didn't know the truth herself...its difficult to tell Shiv.