Freedom for Jai & Bani Walia

EcliPSe_2010 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
Disclaimer: This is a plea, a prayer, a cry for the freedom of Jai and Bani
Walia to their Creator, who is responsible for their current state of being,
to please release them from the bondage that is the "Pia Claim Game".
This is a post for the Freedom of Jai and Bani Walia. I would encourage all
the persons who have complete faith in Jai and Bani Walia to share their
ideas, recollections and sentiments of what Jai and Bani Walia mean to
them and what they both stand for.

The Case for the Emancipation of Jai and Bani Walia

Once in a while, something happens in Life-an indescribable feeling
envelops us. Similar to the kind of feeling one experiences when looking
at an outstanding work of art, reading a great poem/novel, listening to an
amazing song, seeing a spectacular performance on stage, or on
celluloid. It is a feeling that is felt collectively, communicates with its own
unique language to the world. A feeling that lives one in wonderment.
Kasam Se was in that category, it left me in wonderment. Wow. This
show was from India, made me proud. The characters of Jai Walia and
Bani Dixit were a Wow. He was the first Indian male character that could
stand up and be compared to the best of the West. It was his ability to
transgress the cultural, traditional and ideological boundaries that made
him a modern character, a character of Today. Bani Dixit was a single,
young female taking care of her two sisters in her mother/parent role.
She was independent yet upheld the moral, ethical, and cultural values.
These two characters are interdependent of each other. The credit
definitely goes to their creator, Ms. Ekta Kapoor for bringing us these
characters, however, it is entirely the actors, Mr. Ram Kapoor and Ms.
Prachi Desai, who gave them a face, a voice and brought them to life in
our living rooms every night. Mr. Kapoor and Ms. Desai took Jai Walia and
Bani Dixit Walia to an almost iconic status.
They made us fall in love with them and made us have tremendous
respect for them. Even though he was fallible, Jai Walia was man of
principles; he took care of his family. He performed his dharma. Similar
to the character of Bain Dixit. She always performed her dharma.
Ms. Ekta Kapoor has accused him of a crime that he is incapable of
committing-- it's against his inherent nature. Firstly, his married sister
in law drugs him and makes him a victim of male rape;
secondly the crime of
fathering his married sister in law's child lies on his head. I refer to this
as a
crime because it is a crime to force his character into committing an act
that is against his fundamental nature. Pure ignorance on the part of his
Creator, She has made him a victim of a cruel, unjust, monotonous,
formulaic, dragging, overkill storyline. He is trapped. For now, Jai Walia
is imprisoned and deceived by his Creator (oh Brutus, How could you?)
and for the future, a question- how will this character survive with the
knowledge that he is responsible even unwillingly for stripping his own
wife of off her dignity and self respect? The identity and the right of self
determination of this character is at stake here, because he will never be
able to reconcile himself if he is not released of this crime. He will
forever be an Oedipus, blind and wandering around with a falsified guilt,
however, he is not Oedipus. He is or rather was Jai Walia.

The Evidence Regarding He is Not the Father of Pia's Child:

1) His medical condition- due to him suffering from Diabetes and high
blood pressure, on that particular disgusting Dubai night when the act in
question supposedly took place, Jai Walia had a mixture of unlimited
amount of alcohol and an unknown drug/date rape drug in his
bloodstream. According to legitimate, professional Doctors' diagnosis,
he would have gone into a diabetic coma immediately, thus inhibiting his
organ functions (that includes the organ used for procreation).

2) Numerous times the viewer was made witness to the fact that when Jai
Walia gets drunk, he passes out.

3) The ONS cd is strong evidence that nothing happened on that night in
question. We have been witness to the edited version; an unedited
version exists in the hands of the Creator. Request the court to order
release of that evidence.

4) Karuna, his cousin was a witness to Pia drugging him and she found
out what drug it was. Currently, Karuna is a witness for the prosecution
and has been able to reveal only a half-truth.

5) Investigation needs to take place immediately to find the person
behind the camera recording the act.

6) Visually implied that the next Dubai night Pia had spent with her own
husband, Pushkar.

7) Visually and verbally implied that Pushkar feels closer to the child.


(I am only stating the above reasons as evidence for this case, if anyone
has more please free to state them)

The truth and the only truth is that there is not one iota of single
evidence against this defendant to claim him as Pia's child's father, we
have only the unreliable testimony of a delusional character, Pia, that in
itself is highly questionable.

My humble request to his Creator is to be reasonable and review the
evidence without passion, come to a decision and release the defendant,
Jai Walia, his wife Bani Walia and his unborn child from "Pia's Claim
Game". Most Viewers like myself, his wife Bani Walia, have undying faith
that he is not the father of his married sister-in-laws child. We go on
every single day with this faith that he is Completely, Absolutely Innocent
beyond a reasonable doubt.
Remember, Ms. Kapoor this freedom is not only for Jai Walia
it is for his wife Mrs. Bani Walia, his unborn daughter, Krishna and
for most viewers like myself. In his freedom, lies our freedom.

(PS: Thank You Rani, SC, Rivs and Rose)
Edited by aperture - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

54

Views

3.8k

Users

20

Frequent Posters

GoodGoneWrong thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 18 years ago
#2

Bavie...👏

First of all, thank you for taking this up on yourself to put this up. Like you, I am sure there are tons of us who absolutely hate this track that has been dragged, stretched and pushed to the extent that none of the characters that we initially fell in love with are recognizsable anymore.

I just hope that all our requests are being heard/read by someone.

I personally have a lot of other issues with the show and its mis portrayal of a lot of other things:

1. Regressive behavior towards women: Bani who started out such a strong woman, has now turned into a meek, crying wife and mother. Her initial character has been shred. Rano, and her current state of widowhood had so much potential for portraying a strong willed single woman and parent.

2. Deplorable depiction of medical conditions: Rashi is apparently suffering from Cancer, yet she has the thickest crop of hair amongst all. Pia, was able to concieve within months of an abortion and the resulting ovarian complications. JW is a 40 years old, diabetic, hyper tensive person who consumes alcohol as no mans business. Dont even get me started on the miraculous 3 month pregnancy or the unbelivable flat stomachs of would be mommas.

3. Complete disregard for Laws: How can a man marry another woman while his current wife is still alive? How come no one seems to know that a wife can sign off the papers to give her husbands illegitimate child legitimate rights? And divorce is such a joke.

At this point it would just be a start if we can clear JW of this whole disgusting track and then maybe (if they want to continue this serial) revive the main characters to their initial glory.

Rivs

Edited by rivya - 18 years ago
kajolfan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

Bavie,

I think if you (we) reiterate it enough, maybe someone will pay heed to same.

I must say that this is very well written...very much like legal briefings with an introduction, body coupled with evidence, opinion and conclusion. I really do admire your passion on this particular topic wherein you have repeatedly chanted your slogan, "Free JW from R 🤢 Claim Game."

And haan, I do agree that Jai Walia and Bani Walia are interdependent. And the thought of a man fathering two children from two sisters is indeed gross and revolting (albeit the circumstances).

Edited by kajolfan - 18 years ago
EcliPSe_2010 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: kajolfan

Bavie, I think if you (we) reiterate it enough, maybe
someone will pay heed to same. I must say that this is very well
written...very much like legal briefings with an introduction, body coupled
with evidence, opinion and conclusion. I really do admire your passion on
this particular topic wherein you have repeatedly chanted your slogan,
"Free JW from R 🤢 Claim Game."


And haan, I do agree that Jai Walia and Bani Walia are interdependent.
And the thought of a man fathering two children from two sisters is
indeed gross and revolting (albeit the circumstances).




Rani
I hope so--we see an end to this repto claim game--
As long as we had to bear this disgusting ONS trk and the aftermath and
the force feeding of repto tadpole--we have to keep going with this--bc
the characters are being distorted everyday its not the developing of
characters rather the slaughtering of them...the dialogues that JB speak
have to be thought out but lately its been just 🤢 and why should the
viewer suffer if they don't have their act together? esp. with the tadpole's
father issue. It seems they are still testing the waters for a JP gene and
you know what that is a force feed to the viewer bc of what we have been
visually shown--Nothing Happened on that disgusting Dubai Nite
between JP. They have to close/shut this ONS raaz case.
(JW fathering two sisters children, he doesn't deserve this, Bani doesn't
deserve this nor does the viewer...
Edited by aperture - 18 years ago
EcliPSe_2010 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
(At this point it would just be a start if we can clear JW of this whole
disgusting track and then maybe (if they want to continue this serial)
revive the main characters to their initial glory.Rivs)

Exactly, Rivs. At this point, the most imperative thing for the characters
is to free them of the "Repto claim game"--The lingering of the ONS trk.
Its overkill-they need to decide where they wnat to go with this show bc
the concept of having JW as the father of two sisters children is absolutely
in contradiction to the character of JW. I mean its really sad bc not only is
JW caught up in this trap, but so is Bani, their unborn child and the
viewer. 🤢 😡
Edited by aperture - 18 years ago
shahni4 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
Baxie
Very aptly put and very well laid out case in defense of JW....

So Kreatives heed our demands......bring back our beloved characters and please please resolve this "who's the father" issue and fully and completely redeem JW!!!

Bring KS back to the early glory days and please no more body doubles!!!

Plan honeymoons for the characters when actors are not able to shoot together but don't torture the audience with bod doubles...the chemistry is just not there and its torture for the audience to watch!!!

BTW, Kreatives don't let anything happen to Krishna Walia (JB's child) --- she is the hope for the future of JB and KS!!!!

Kreatives, use the medium given to portray issues in an intellectual manner so as to educate the audience - don't push regressive tracks like the one currently with Raashi forcing Rano to marry Ranveer with the bull crap that she needs a "sahara"!!! Stop the BS and give us back the magic!!!

Lets see what tomorrow brings!!!
Ok enough of my ramblings!!!
Nina
EcliPSe_2010 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
(Very aptly put and very well laid out case in defense of JW....
So Kreatives heed our demands......bring back our beloved characters and
please please resolve this "who's the father" issue and fully and
completely redeem JW!!!
Bring KS back to the early glory days and please no more body doubles!!!
--------shahni4)

Nina
JW has to be set free. and Bani as well from the "repto claim game" in
order for KS to restore to its glory days--and the force feed of JP gene to
the veiwer will be worst than the ONS trk not only for the characters but
for the veiwer as well. Any work of fiction has to progress and with this
force feed thay will be stagnant JW will be neither here nor there similar
to Bani...most important thing is that these two characters are
interdependent..progress, movement is wht makes anything dynamic and
here due to the repto claim game JB will be stuck and the only character
moving will be the reptile--why?
zerobstolerence thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
Very well said. This B-J-P track has been so 🤢 and have been beaten to death. I'm absolutely uninterested in Jai and Pia!
majumdar thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
The problem is that the story has reached a practical dead end. If J-B unite there is nothing else to show, and if they dont unite, we have to put up with reptile.

I think the kreatives should have stuck to their track of JW doing the vanishing act after the shradh, becoming a complete recluse and broken man. Being baizzat buried. 5-6 years leap. Then Bani and Krishna healing his wounds and getting him back to Life. That would have given us 2-3 months of wonderful KS back to the original days perhaps.

Rgds,

Pri
sangitadas thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
Personally I feel KS is over and they dont have anything to show us.

Its strange that nowadays I feel so impatient while watching the serial, waiting it to end and for me to be freed of the misery. I think I will give up watching KS and concentarte on something else like mating programmes of bees and birds and frogs. 😡

Bavie, I agree with all the points you mentioned and also those of Rivya's. As if these are not enough, they keep on shredding whatever little is left of JW and BW and make them do insane, inane things on a regular basis. Now they know that making P a vamp plot has back-fired, so they are trying to do something (???) to retrace her character. And at what cost? Of course Bani, making her sprout stupid dialogues and what not.

I will be so happy when KS finally slips out of the 20 position in the TRP list and Zee removes it from its prime slot. With Sandeep Sickand being thrown out of Sony and KS off the air, perhaps we in the Forum can all come together and fund SS to contract RK and PD and create another magical story. And this time, it will NOT go haywire. Simply cos we will handle it.
Edited by sangitadas - 18 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".