Calling on the Jai Brigade & Bani Brigade

kajolfan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

We all have a sneeking suspicion that Balaji/Zee have lurkers on the Board. That being said, I'd like to take this opportunity to point out something to both the Jai Brigade and the Bani Brigade. The majority of us are undoutably Jai and Bani Campers and we crib at the thought of their separation and other angles. However, that being said, we are in every which way responsible for fueling the Kreatives misguided notions of what the audience wants. As a friend of mine puts it:

"At any given time if someone goes through the posts on 3-4 pages of the forum, the general impression is that viewers think that Bani is the cause of all trouble in JW's life and that 'poor' guy is better off without her. And here I am not talking abt Pia supporters coz there are not that many. Majority of the ppl might claim to be J-B campers but the posts do not give that impression. Infact except the posts you make and all the ppl who post in that thread, most of the other posts are Bani bashing posts.

This was a feeling I have been having for some time but it was re-enforced when recently one of my friends joined IF and she told me that now she does not wonder why J-B have been seperated in the serial since most of the people don't want them together. If that is the impression an IRREGULAR member of IF gets, then wouldn't the creatives also get that impression and if they really consider it to be reflective of the majority of the viewers, they will give us that.

Sorry to say that the more 'pity parties for Buddha' (as simz put yesterday) are held on the forum, the more the impression goes out that he is the innocent victim in all this and needs to be made a martyr. And this victimization is at the hands of Bani as well. Which clearly means we will never get the love story of 2 strong characters which we want and which it was in the beginning."

That being said, is it any wonder why (apart from the obvious lack of creativity) the show has no story and they (the Kreatives) are continually messing around with Jai and Bani's relationship along with their respective characters?

Edited by kajolfan - 19 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

47

Views

2.4k

Users

21

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

aashyagh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
Rani, I need J&B together always! If we bash Bani for her kartoots (no offense), we also bash Jai when he is wrong, but we hv always made it clear that its Munni for Munna and vice versa and if they try to change the partners, then we call it quits!
EcliPSe_2010 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
agree with u--they will destroy one character to ressurect the other
character and viseversa---No we don't want that, yaar--cnt have that
happen--Its JB only forever as dysfunctional as ever......
Ap
smilecheese thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
I think both Jai and Bani make mistakes but in the end they are each other's!

We got mad at Jai for ONS and we got mad at Bani for her Alimony fiasco!

We change our bashings!

But in the end we want them together and TALKING!

NO more flashbacks! Have had enough of those!
-Pari
InduD thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
I agree with you. At glance, it seems that many do not like Bani and Jai would be well off without her in his life.

I think "Kreatives" assume that Jai is the "only" character that pulls of the show and hence they do all the stuff to gain sympathy and well they do succeed. Even though, they have butcher his character but not as such as they have done to other character from Bani to massi to Tarun. Some more, Jai gets great dialogues to show his feeling but other characters don't.

The more we start show symphaty to Jai, the more they will make him suffer.
Edited by Je_aime - 19 years ago
shahni4 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
Rani

Yes, JW was victimized but to me Bani was avicimized even more!!! She has been led to believe quite effectively, that JW loves Pia - Pia has always been his first choice. Unitl the truth was blurted out by Maasi and then apparently never brought up again by anyone in the pagal khanna she herself believed all the hateful things he hurled at her to bring her out of her zombie state!!!

It is obvious they love each other and although two bodies are one soul!!! In redeeming jW the Kreatives butchered Bani's character further by showing her with attitude despite knowing the truth but does that alte or alleviate her state of confusion!! I think she has every right to be torn in every direction!!!

She may feel if she goes back to him and they push Pia's baby under the rug that would be unfair to the innocent kid!!! Also, with pia's kid looming in every corner of their lices how can they live happily ever after with Krishan!! The kreatives hace not done a good job of portraying to the audience Bani's turmoil!!!

But as far as the question of do they belong together and should they reunite---HELL YES!!! These two duffers would never be happy without the other!!!! NEVER!!!

And we JB despos wouldn't and aren't happy to see them apart for so long either!!! We want to have a complete redemption of jW not the half hearted crap of him being drugged and forced on that's being shown to date!!!!

We,here on IF as a collective group, really need to show that we as the audience want JB together and the JP ONS/Baby fiasco dead and buried!!!!!


Nina
kajolfan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: aashyagh

Rani, I need J&B together always! If we bash Bani for her kartoots (no offense), we also bash Jai when he is wrong, but we hv always made it clear that its Munni for Munna and vice versa and if they try to change the partners, then we call it quits!

Ash,

I know that and you know that and so do the regular IF members. But if an "irregular" member gets an otherwise impression, same would apply to the lurking "kreatives." Fact is that no one can make a post these days without ending up bashing one or the other (though that may be entertainment, it fuels the Kreatives misguided notions of what we want). Hope that makes some level of sense.

Edited by kajolfan - 19 years ago
kubare thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 19 years ago
#8

Rani,

I am not a Jai camper or a Bani camper at all, nor do I mind bashing both Jai and Bani when they are worng or bash the so called creatives and Ekta too.

I am a JB fan and despo. They are the only reason that I love KS the only Indian drama that I have ever watched and am still watching after such nonsence. If not for Jai and Bani would have left this drama long time back.

What so annoying and frustrating is that the creatives are hell bent on destroying the two most important characters of the show, Jai and Bani.

I so miss the old Bani and Jai, and what do we have now after the whole Alimony and ONS fiasco, empty shells, with no subsatnce in ther characters at all.

If the creatives are lurking and are so stupid to think that we Pity Jai and blame Bani for all his troubles then what can I say except it proves one thing for sure they really are brainless creatures.

If they read everyones point of view, one thing is clear that we want the old Bani and Jai back and the golden days of KS.

When Jai bashers bash Jai for his deeds and mistakes it to show that they are not please with how the character is being protrayed as it is so out of his original charactrer and in the same way when Bani basher bash Bani it too is for the same reason the butchering that the creatives are doing to her character.

If one opens ones mind and eyes , one will note that both the characters have been butchered completely.

How does it sound to even think of a man like Jia Walia being raped ( a very sensitive issue made a mockery off) and that too by his sister-in-law.🤢 I hated him for succumbing to Pia and taking her to Dubai, etc and blamed him for his actions post ONS an pre revelation of the partial truth. Was also angry with him for being such a dumbo for not asking for a parternity test and blindly accepting the child as his when he did not remember doing the deed what so ever????

In the same way Bani too has been a duffer and dumboo in her dealings with her sister and hubby.

Thus if the so callled creatives are listening please make note that what we all want is the old KS baack with the same strong characters of Jai and Bani.

Meant no offense to anyone, be it Bani campers, basher, Jai campers or basher. Thats just my POV.

Love

Krishna

kajolfan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: kubare

Rani,

I am not a Jai camper or a Bani camper at all, nor do I mind bashing both Jai and Bani when they are worng or bash the so called creatives and Ekta too.

I am a JB fan and despo. They are the only reason that I love KS the only Indian drama that I have ever watched and am still watching after such nonsence. If not for Jai and Bani would have left this drama long time back.

What so annoying and frustrating is that the creatives are hell bent on destroying the two most important characters of the show, Jai and Bani.

I so miss the old Bani and Jai, and what do we have now after the whole Alimony and ONS fiasco, empty shells, with no subsatnce in ther characters at all.

If the creatives are lurking and are so stupid to think that we Pity Jai and blame Bani for all his troubles then what can I say except it proves one thing for sure they really are brainless creatures.

If they read everyones point of view, one thing is clear that we want the old Bani and Jai back and the golden days of KS.

When Jai bashers bash Jai for his deeds and mistakes it to show that they are not please with how the character is being protrayed as it is so out of his original charactrer and in the same way when Bani basher bash Bani it too is for the same reason the butchering that the creatives are doing to her character.

If one opens ones mind and eyes , one will note that both the characters have been butchered completely.

How does it sound to even think of a man like Jia Walia being raped ( a very sensitive issue made a mockery off) and that too by his sister-in-law.🤢 I hated him for succumbing to Pia and taking her to Dubai, etc and blamed him for his actions post ONS an pre revelation of the partial truth. Was also angry with him for being such a dumbo for not asking for a parternity test and blindly accepting the child as his when he did not remember doing the deed what so ever????

In the same way Bani too has been a duffer and dumboo in her dealings with her sister and hubby.

Thus if the so callled creatives are listening please make note that what we all want is the old KS baack with the same strong characters of Jai and Bani.

Meant no offense to anyone, be it Bani campers, basher, Jai campers or basher. Thats just my POV.

Love

Krishna

The KS team undoutably is aware that the audience is comprised of J&B campers, however, that apart, I genuinely believe that at some level, we are all responsible for fueling their misguided notions of what we want to see hence they're so confused at how to proceed and with what to proceed (it's reflective in the way the characters have shaped up and in the direction the story (whatever there is of one) is proceeding.

lonely14 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

So what happens to the people who can't stand bani with Jai, and really do think Jai is better off without her? Their desires will be left unfulfilled?

Shina

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".