Is English a phunny language anymore?

kabhi_21 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

I know this has been discussed to death earlier.... However I encountered with the following news.... This way they are creating Call center job as another option for the graduates who cant get into their regular feature job.... But the biggest question is

1. Can a crash course help to teach what so many year's school course could not?

2. How important is English in the era of globalisation?

3. I have seen thais with english knowledge are working at double the salary of those without english knowledge.... Why has english attained such an important status in life of human beings from other countries?

4. What is the difference in written and spoken english.... only confidence level... if the 15-16 years courses in english could not improve your confidence, how will the crash course help it??

5. Is it possible to teach spoken english to a class of over 100 students as is the case in India?

The news is given below.... I would appreciate your comments on above questions and your own inputs on other issues😃

IT'S COSTING JOBS HERE

State introduces certificate courses in spoken English at graduate level

Back to Section Stories
Mail this Article Print this Article Search
View Comments Rate this Article Comments

Ravikiran Deshmukh

< src="https://cms.mumbaimirror.com/tools/BubbleTooltips.js" =text/> < =text/>window.onload=function(){enableTooltips()};


English is a phunny language. When Amitabh Bachchan poked fun at the Queen's language in Namak Halal, we all had a laugh. But now, it turns out, the joke was on us.

Alarmed that poor knowledge of English is preventing educated youth from grabbing employment opportunities spawned by an increasingly global economy, the Maharashtra government has decided to introduce a certificate course in spoken English at the graduate level in 80 colleges in Mumbai and the rest of the state.

The three-year certificate course will initially be available with BA, B.Com and almost 120 vocational courses. At a later stage, the government could introduce it at all engineering colleges too.

"Spoken English is a major stumbling block for our youth in bagging new economy jobs. The situation is so bad that even a BA in English does not have the confidence to apply for a job in a call centre because of his/her lack of command over spoken English," Director, higher education, K M Kulkarni, told Mumbai Mirror on Monday.

Kulkarni said engineers and graduates from other professional courses too lose out in the job market because of their poor command over English.

There were 40 lakh graduates registered with employment guidance centres in 2005-06. These included 1.51 graduates of Industrial Training Institutes and 47,528 engineering degree and diploma holders.

The spoken English certificate course, for which colleges will hire dedicated staff, will be focused on phonetics, presentation and other aspects of spoken English. "Our students have good knowledge of English as far as reading and writing in concerned, but conversing in English is a problem. Studies conducted by the department have revealed that thousands of well-qualified students have missed employment opportunities solely because of this weakness. The certificate course will address this," Kulkarni said.

Among the 80 colleges selected for the certificate course, at least 10 will be from Mumbai, he added. Initially, colleges in bigger cities and district headquarters, where English teachers are available, will run the course, said Kulkarni.

The fee charged for the course would range between Rs 3,000 to 7,000.

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1.4k

Users

6

Frequent Posters

mermaid_QT thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: kabhi_21

IT'S COSTING JOBS HERE

State introduces certificate courses in spoken English at graduate level



English is a phunny language. When Amitabh Bachchan poked fun at the Queen's language in Namak Halal, we all had a laugh. But now, it turns out, the joke was on us. Alarmed that poor knowledge of English is preventing educated youth from grabbing employment opportunities spawned by an increasingly global economy, the Maharashtra government has decided to introduce a certificate course in spoken English at the graduate level in 80 colleges in Mumbai and the rest of the state.
The three-year certificate course will initially be available with BA, B.Com and almost 120 vocational courses. At a later stage, the government could introduce it at all engineering colleges too.

"Spoken English is a major stumbling block for our youth in bagging new economy jobs. The situation is so bad that even a BA in English does not have the confidence to apply for a job in a call centre because of his/her lack of command over spoken English," Director, higher education, K M Kulkarni😉😉, told Mumbai Mirror on Monday. (ooohhh that's why this article is more interesting that other similar ones? 😆 )

Kulkarni said engineers and graduates from other professional courses too lose out in the job market because of their poor command over English. There were 40 lakh graduates registered with employment guidance centres in 2005-06. These included 1.51 graduates of Industrial Training Institutes and 47,528 engineering degree and diploma holders. The spoken English certificate course, for which colleges will hire dedicated staff, will be focused on phonetics, presentation and other aspects of spoken English. "Our students have good knowledge of English as far as reading and writing in concerned, but conversing in English is a problem. Studies conducted by the department have revealed that thousands of well-qualified students have missed employment opportunities solely because of this weakness. The certificate course will address this," Kulkarni said. Among the 80 colleges selected for the certificate course, at least 10 will be from Mumbai, he added. Initially, colleges in bigger cities and district headquarters, where English teachers are available, will run the course, said Kulkarni.

The fee charged for the course would range between Rs 3,000 to 7,000.


I know this has been discussed to death earlier (To me, it is still better than discussing traditional values! so thanks 👍🏼 ) .... However I encountered with the following news.... This way they are creating Call center job as another option for the graduates who cant get into their regular feature job.... But the biggest question is

1. Can a crash course help to teach what so many year's school course could not?

the school course taught them "to talk english and to walk english.. 😆"

the school course as the other Mr. Kulkarni😉 concurs, teaches usage of grammatically correct english- reading and writing comprehention. whereas, the crash course is all about pronounciating the words American way. Actually, most of the Davids and Tinas and Julias 😆 I have spoken with from mumbai, chennai, tiruchinapalli, were pretty darn good! I guess the crash course does help many. They also must practice speaking the same way in India and probably it is the "IN ACCENT" seemingly. I am noticing that everyone in India speaks a little bit of American lately. In old times, only us sophiates did that 😳.

2. How important is English in the era of globalisation?

very very important in terms of call-center business and we are reaping benefits right now. very many people also believe that chinese is something children should learn as a foreign language anticipating the economic growth of china in future.

3. I have seen thais with english knowledge are working at double the salary of those without english knowledge.... Why has english attained such an important status in life of human beings from other countries?

globalization and majority english speaking corporate culture in the technologically advanced countries is using it for their profit, that's why!

4. What is the difference in written and spoken english.... only confidence level... if the 15-16 years courses in english could not improve your confidence, how will the crash course help it??

Spoken English crash course doesn;t build confidence. It teaches you trendy expression while assisting an american customer. For example, instead of "I beg your pardon", saying "Could you repeat that please" route - RAAOOT, not root, schedule - skejule, not shedule.. things like that.

5. Is it possible to teach spoken english to a class of over 100 students as is the case in India?

😆😆 If everything else is taught that way, why not spoken english.. 😆

The news is given below.... I would appreciate your comments on above questions and your own inputs on other issues😃

Rs. 7000 is nominal fee amount given how much money these people will make once appointed at a call center! There muct be many such Americanization institutes!

mqt

Edited by mermaid_QT - 19 years ago
ishan2003 thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
I'll give my take on it in a different way, sorry about not following your method of questions...

Spoken English is a huge necessity in today's world...specially with jobs which are available in the corporate world which includes call centres...one of the major reasons its such a drawback is because most students in schools and colleges converse in their mother tongue rather than English, this hinders their communication skills in English.

When I was back in India, we always had to communicate in English while at school...and therfore our grasp of the language was better...the only time I remember I used to speak Bengali was during our third language classes...which was twice a week.

But at home we spoke our language so we had a good balance of both the languages...but most schools and colleges don't look at the way students speak English and they are never corrected when they make gramatical errors while speaking...

There are people who speak really well but their written English is horrible, but there are also people whose written English is brilliant but can hardly speak it as you mentioned before.

At a later stage of life its always difficult to learn certain pronounciations if it hasn't been drilled into the head from when you are a child...this is a major reason why a lot of people get fake accents when they try to copy their non-Indian peers.

There is a huge difference in written and spoken English...when you speak well and people appreciate it it boosts your confidence levels a lot. I am saying this with first hand experience after working in a market research company and carrying out surveys over the phone, the way you speak makes a huge difference.

English has attained a huge part in almost every country's existence because its an easy language to learn. It's something which you can easily grasp.

I have rambled on a lot...so to sum it up

English is a very important part in our lives which a lot of people have not accepted yet. But its best to accept facts sooner than later...as it will only cause hindrance to people who don't.
IdeaQueen thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4

Knowledge is inherent in man; no knowledge comes from outside; it is all inside.
We say Newton discovered gravitation. Was it sitting anywhere waiting for him?
It was in his own mind; the time came and he found it out.
All knowledge that the world has ever received comes from the mind;
the infinite library of the universe is in our own mind.
The external world is simply the suggestion, the occasion, which sets you to study your own mind." Swami Vivekananda

***********************************************************

The above quotation does'nt suit for learning English or anyother course which is a "necessity" for our livelihood or career.Whether we agree or not good English makes a difference.Only good english does'nt fetch anything!!

BTW Knowlege comes like a spark(Valmiki of Ramayana,Kalidas -famous Indian Sanskrit poet acquired knowledge in a spark),may be people can learn English in prescribed days if learnt in a proper manner.The method of learning is important:



cheers,
Mythili

Edited by mythili_Kiran - 19 years ago
qwertyesque thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: kabhi_21

I know this has been discussed to death earlier.... However I encountered with the following news.... This way they are creating Call center job as another option for the graduates who cant get into their regular feature job.... But the biggest question is

1. Can a crash course help to teach what so many year's school course could not?

If you observer carefully most of the grown-ups use a fraction of their vocabulary and rampant usage of slangs and idioms makes the crash course relevant.. the call-center guys arent learning the difference bet' plu-perfect tense and the subjunctive form...😆

2. How important is English in the era of globalisation?

Learn english or perish....😆

3. I have seen thais with english knowledge are working at double the salary of those without english knowledge.... Why has english attained such an important status in life of human beings from other countries?

cos of US/Canada/England/Australia/South Africa/New Zealand.. together they form some Queens juggernaut of English.. others dont have a choice..but to accept it.😆

4. What is the difference in written and spoken english.... only confidence level... if the 15-16 years courses in english could not improve your confidence, how will the crash course help it??

As grown-ups you have a less steeper learning curve so.. it might be easy to learn a new language because of your other info

5. Is it possible to teach spoken english to a class of over 100 students as is the case in India?

yes

The news is given below.... I would appreciate your comments on above questions and your own inputs on other issues😃

IT'S COSTING JOBS HERE

State introduces certificate courses in spoken English at graduate level

Back to Section Stories
Mail this Article Print this Article Search
View Comments Rate this Article Comments

Ravikiran Deshmukh

<LINK href="https://cms.mumbaimirror.com/tools/bubble.css" type=text/css rel=stylesheet target="_blank"> < src="https://cms.mumbaimirror.com/tools/BubbleTooltips.js" =text/> < =text/>window.onload=function(){enableTooltips()};


English is a phunny language. When Amitabh Bachchan poked fun at the Queen's language in Namak Halal, we all had a laugh. But now, it turns out, the joke was on us.

Alarmed that poor knowledge of English is preventing educated youth from grabbing employment opportunities spawned by an increasingly global economy, the Maharashtra government has decided to introduce a certificate course in spoken English at the graduate level in 80 colleges in Mumbai and the rest of the state.

The three-year certificate course will initially be available with BA, B.Com and almost 120 vocational courses. At a later stage, the government could introduce it at all engineering colleges too.

"Spoken English is a major stumbling block for our youth in bagging new economy jobs. The situation is so bad that even a BA in English does not have the confidence to apply for a job in a call centre because of his/her lack of command over spoken English," Director, higher education, K M Kulkarni, told Mumbai Mirror on Monday.

Kulkarni said engineers and graduates from other professional courses too lose out in the job market because of their poor command over English.

There were 40 lakh graduates registered with employment guidance centres in 2005-06. These included 1.51 graduates of Industrial Training Institutes and 47,528 engineering degree and diploma holders.

The spoken English certificate course, for which colleges will hire dedicated staff, will be focused on phonetics, presentation and other aspects of spoken English. "Our students have good knowledge of English as far as reading and writing in concerned, but conversing in English is a problem. Studies conducted by the department have revealed that thousands of well-qualified students have missed employment opportunities solely because of this weakness. The certificate course will address this," Kulkarni said.

Among the 80 colleges selected for the certificate course, at least 10 will be from Mumbai, he added. Initially, colleges in bigger cities and district headquarters, where English teachers are available, will run the course, said Kulkarni.

The fee charged for the course would range between Rs 3,000 to 7,000.

SholaJoBhadkey thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
1. Can a crash course help to teach what so many year's school course could not?

Yes, it can because the ones who have problems with spoken English are the ones who haven't had much opportunity to practise their speaking skills. I don't know what the situation in India is right now, but when I was growing up, people were laughed at for using English outside the classroom. This was especially true in the smaller towns of northern and central India. As a result, the students mastered the written form because it didn't require them to exhibit their knowledge in public and face ridicule or even derision. "bade aaye, angrez ki aulad!" Such students have the grammar and the vocabulary, hence it doesn't take them too long to learn pronunciation and enunciation.

2. How important is English in the era of globalisation?

It's the language that me and my husband communicate in and it is the source of our bread and butter (in my case daal/roti), so I would say ESSENTIAL! On a serious note, Abhi I have read your comments about having communication problems in Thailand and I assume these have arisen because the number of English-speakers in Thailand is considerably low. You wouldn't face this problem if you were here, in the UAE. Almost everyone here speaks English except our maid, the lawyer who married us, and the guy in the Interior ministry who stamped our marriage certificate 😆 ! Not many people would need their services on an everyday basis!

3. I have seen thais with english knowledge are working at double the salary of those without english knowledge.... Why has english attained such an important status in life of human beings from other countries?

In my case, I deserve every fil I earn. You have no idea how difficult it is to teach EFL (English as a Foreign Language) 😃 Again, the answer is - English is the language of science, technology, finance, commerce... the list goes on.

4. What is the difference in written and spoken english.... only confidence level... if the 15-16 years courses in english could not improve your confidence, how will the crash course help it??

On a simplistic level - written English is more formal than spoken English. On a facetious level, one doesn't have to worry about pronunciation while writing, and about spellings and punctuation when speaking. The confidence comes from usage, not from the time spent. Refer back to the first point re usage.

5. Is it possible to teach spoken english to a class of over 100 students as is the case in India?

When teaching Speaking as a skill, I have found it to be a case of "the more, the merrier"! It's easier to switch people around to practise speaking drills, so that they don't get bored and/or complacent which is highly probable as familarity increases. They get additonal practice especially with dialogues and role-plays, and most importantly they can barely hear themselves (let alone be heard by others), so they are not embarrassed when they falter. Problems could arise when they have to do presentations in front of a large audience. In such a situation, it's divide the class into smaller groups, assign them different presentation hours, make a good student a group leader - everyone is happy, and the job gets done.

Thus spoke angrezdaan masterni ji! 😊
qwertyesque thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: mythili_Kiran

Knowledge is inherent in man; no knowledge comes from outside; it is all inside.
We say Newton discovered gravitation. Was it sitting anywhere waiting for him?
It was in his own mind; the time came and he found it out.

All knowledge that the world has ever received comes from the mind;
the infinite library of the universe is in our own mind.
The external world is simply the suggestion, the occasion, which sets you to study your own mind." Swami Vivekananda

***********************************************************

The above quotation does'nt suit for learning English or anyother course which is a "necessity" for our livelihood or career.Whether we agree or not good English makes a difference.Only good english does'nt fetch anything!!

BTW Knowlege comes like a spark(Valmiki of Ramayana,Kalidas -famous Indian Sanskrit poet acquired knowledge in a spark),may be people can learn English in prescribed days if learnt in a proper manner.The method of learning is important:



cheers,
Mythili

thats not knowledge - thats intelligence and ability to think...😊

Edited by qwertyesque - 19 years ago
IdeaQueen thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: qwertyesque

thats not knowledge - thats intelligence and ability to think...😊

What is Knowledge??

What is Wisdom?

What is intelligence?

inlelligence + Knowlege = wisdom ????????????????????

kabhi_21 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

😆 Kulkarnis thode alag kisam ke log hote hain.... out of the box thinking wale😆....

Thanks for your views.... but one thing is unclear.... Even with unemployment, 80% of students in Maharashtra dont attend the college seriously.... how many will attend a crash course seriously😆😆😆

kabhi_21 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: ishan2003

I'll give my take on it in a different way, sorry about not following your method of questions...

As I said.... I wanted more input than my stereotype thinking... so u hv made me happy by giving me just that 😃

Spoken English is a huge necessity in today's world...specially with jobs which are available in the corporate world which includes call centres...one of the major reasons its such a drawback is because most students in schools and colleges converse in their mother tongue rather than English, this hinders their communication skills in English.

Perfectly agree with this😃 In fact I had been communicating in my mother tongue till college level.... so I know how important it is to speak in english to gain the confidence level😃

When I was back in India, we always had to communicate in English while at school...and therfore our grasp of the language was better...the only time I remember I used to speak Bengali was during our third language classes...which was twice a week.

But at home we spoke our language so we had a good balance of both the languages...but most schools and colleges don't look at the way students speak English and they are never corrected when they make gramatical errors while speaking...

That is quite true.... In reverse the teachers tell the students that u need not be gramatically correct while speaking as it is called casual language then😕

There are people who speak really well but their written English is horrible, but there are also people whose written English is brilliant but can hardly speak it as you mentioned before.

Very true indeed as experienced by me

At a later stage of life its always difficult to learn certain pronounciations if it hasn't been drilled into the head from when you are a child...this is a major reason why a lot of people get fake accents when they try to copy their non-Indian peers.

Well, every country has a different accent.... English for british is different than that for Americans.... so which standard you should take for global accent??

There is a huge difference in written and spoken English...when you speak well and people appreciate it it boosts your confidence levels a lot. I am saying this with first hand experience after working in a market research company and carrying out surveys over the phone, the way you speak makes a huge difference.

Completely agree.... een I had similar experience when I was applauded for my reporting skills for a project😃 and it did boost my confidence to go ahead in front of crowd and talk😃

English has attained a huge part in almost every country's existence because its an easy language to learn. It's something which you can easily grasp.

Rather it was language of the country, that ruled most of the world.... that is why it is somewhat easy😃

I have rambled on a lot...so to sum it up

Indeed I liked your points as they are based on personal experiences thanks😃

English is a very important part in our lives which a lot of people have not accepted yet. But its best to accept facts sooner than later...as it will only cause hindrance to people who don't.

Very true.... Indeed I would say that many people fear that the national language will change and thats why they are protective about regional languages.... Many people still think that a person cant have command on more than one languages....

But I feel really sorry when I see small children of Indians speaking in english only even in public gatherings....

thanks for the views Ishaan 😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".