What's wrong in positive criticism ?

Page

geek2

@geek2

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

I just wonder why forum members get so offended by the criticism of the story line or acting of the actors?
I think that is the democratic way of improving anything, that includes a tv show too!

Quote

Frequent Posters

deepa1122

@deepa1122

Trailblazer

Posted: 12 years ago

Positive criticism is fine

But some are not positive they are downright negative comparing

Calling actors not good actors etc and 99% such comments are made by season 1 guys looks like they can not believe this show is doing great

Yes there is freedom speech but not bashing saying negative stuff etc

If some are against this show go to ur forum say whatever the heck they want

I think none from this forum will go there --- hey why are u writing this ------- stuff

Edited by deepa1122 - 12 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

mary78613

@mary78613

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

Positive criticism is welcomed but BASHING is not..

We don't want the show compared to the 1st season. Even i loved the 1st season but this show for me, shares nothing with the first season except the title. I have a special image of the 1st season and it can never be compared. Every show has its own USP and does Ek Baar Phir

We just want to enjoy the show!

Quote

---Nisha---

@---Nisha---

Voyager

+ 7

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: deepa1122
Positive criticism is fine
But some are not positive they are downright negative comparing

Calling actors not good actors etc and 99% such comments are made by season 1 guys looks like they can not believe this show is doing great

Yes there is freedom speech but not bashing saying negative stuff etc

If some are against this show go to ur forum say whatever the heck they want

I think none from this forum will go there --- hey why are u writing this ------- stuff

Last time I checked negative stuff is included under freedom of speech. I think you mean IPKEBP forum rules do not include saying negative things, but freedom of speech definitely includes it.

And have fun in a forum where there is no contradictory opinion. It will be a freakin boring place if everyone just keeps saying all good things.

What is the point of having a forum if that is all we are allowed to do.

Not to mention, nothing will ever improve if you dont point out the faults.

Oh well they are the forum rules no matter how crazy I think they are. I can't change them.

P.S. In my opinion it is ridiculous to say you are not allowed (not to mention I hate being told what I can and cant do) to compare IPK and IPKEBP since umm look at the title. I am not the one who made the connection between those 2 shows. The people who created it choose the same title as the first season. Plus everyone here keeps saying there are no similarities between the shows. Maybe I am weird then because I see a lot of similarities.

Edited by ---Nisha--- - 12 years ago

Quote

Shreya

@avinashrubina.

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Junebug
Well I don't know where this whole freedom of speech comes into a forum dedicated for fans.
It's a forum filled with FANS.
You say something bad, they will react. It doesn't take a genius to figure it out.
In spite of knowing that you come on to a forum, say negative stuff, then you're a troll. No two ways about. Harping on freedom of speech for something as silly as this shows the maturity level.
On YT/FB/Twitter that's your person personal zone, rant away. No one stops freedom of speech.
Coming to a place, knowing is filled with fans, to complain, shows that the person is dead bored and has nothing better to do other than rile up fans.
Well I say now that's immaturity. Not the fans' reaction.

@TM People don't like criticism. I don't know what you were expecting. Ofc by all means give criticism. But don't expect people to like it. Obviously when someone criticizes on a platform full of people who are fans, then they must be equally prepared for flame.

WELL said totally agree with you...

Quote

Wrong

What's wrong in positive criticism ?

Related Topics

Explore Topics