Amanat284 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

I am hating her more and more with each passing day. For Sampooran, she can even kill others (or threaten to kill). She refuses to use logic and wisdom. In fact, she is more childish than Veera. She has no sense of right or wrong, is a biased pathetic character whose character arc refuses to grow. She is the most boring and one dimensional character who has nothing going on for herself.( And she wonders why Ranvi is more attached to Veera than her pffft )

When she grabbed a dagger to "kill" Nihal, it made her look like a pathetic joke. Whoever is writing her that way needs to stop. It's these kind of characters who are over the top and bad for today's society.

Seriously, when this serial ends, a lot of people (including me) may look back only to think Ratan is one of the worst dumbest female characters in the history of Indian serials. Right next to Bani Walia from Kasame se and Nividita from Chand Chupa Badal Mein.


Edited by Amanat284 - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

4.6k

Users

12

Likes

62

Frequent Posters

771779 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Ratan is most disgusting character on tv currently
Smileyfatemah thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
I ve seen characters worse than her currently on tv.
ScoopTroop thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Oh wow! So Ratan wouldn't have been a boring character had she agreed to marry Nihal and love him inspite of knowing that he hid the truth about her deceased husband from her??

Ratan never said that what Sampooran did was right. But her love for him is unconditional and above all his faults, so much that she forgave him easily. I don't know what "message" it's giving to you all, but that's how Ratan's character, and most of the Indian married women are. So if she refuses to marry anyone after her husband is dead, she cannot be called as dumb because she is still unable to move on. Isn't this natural?

Ratan had initially doubted Nihal but later placed her complete trust on him. When she realised that Nihal has been hiding some truth about her husband from him, she feels cheated and hurt because, I think we all agree on it that, she DESERVES to know the truth. People might find her threatening to kill Nihal OTT (I know there are a lot of Nihal pankhis here😆) but I think it's very natural of Ratan because that's how she is: fiery and impulsive.

Give some time to the show. Ratan would surely understand that Nihal didn't want to kill Sampooran and it was just an accident. She would eventually understand that Nihal loves her more unconditionally than Sampooran had, or would ever had!Such realisations don't happen within a blink of an eye. 😊
Bharti_k thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Ratan's char completely ruined... what was her first reaction on NJi after finding her beloved hubby's things..Haila weapon leke maarne chali..jaise saamne karthuor Bhaktawar khada ho..totally wrong..they would have showned her shocked...nahi per cv's r more on making Ratn ..punjab ki sherni...LOlz..this show is no more Bhai bahen ka pyar vyar..it's all abt raatn's struggle /fight..all the time...???
Edited by Bharti_k - 12 years ago
Dloves1D thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
Ratan is a totally blind Pati-vrata Patni who thinks sahi hai ya galat hai, par mera pati bhagwan hai.

Oh! plz Story writers gimme a break!
This is no longer a reality in today's society.
MrDarcyfan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Why is Ratan still dying over Samporan who was nothing but a cheat?
If a WOMEN had done what he did... Would everyone be OK with him waiting for his cheating wife to come home? Or once she is dead, refuse to move on with his life?? The answer is NO! So why the heck are they showing Ratan SO damned blinded by her love for a cheating and unreliable man??

WHY wont she give Nihal a chance to explain? At one point she was almost in love with him, and now she is acting like the thought of marriage to him is a sin for her? What are they trying to show??

WHERE is the NAYI SOCH SP? Or is it just another tag line for you people??


Edited by MrDarcyfan - 12 years ago
Amanat284 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Sayaani-Chidiya

Oh wow! So Ratan wouldn't have been a boring character had she agreed to marry Nihal and love him inspite of knowing that he hid the truth about her deceased husband from her??


Yes. *INSERT sarcastic face here*
And completely obvlious to the fact that she threatened to actually kill someone. How normal is that? Oh let's pick up a dagger shall we and go around threatening people because it's "not boring" and plus Ratan is the role model.

Ratan never said that what Sampooran did was right. But her love for him is unconditional and above all his faults, so much that she forgave him easily. I don't know what "message" it's giving to you all, but that's how Ratan's character, and most of the Indian married women are. So if she refuses to marry anyone after her husband is dead, she cannot be called as dumb because she is still unable to move on. Isn't this natural?

Because Sampooran is her child. That explains the unconditional love. "Yes, you can go cheat on me, I'm okay with it. Go screw lot of women and impregnate them, I will raise your illicit children as my own while I guard my own chastity for you because I'm a married woman now widowed, I have no right to move on and marry someone else. My purpose in this life is to be your doormat. Hamesha and Hamesha Kehliyeh."

Let start with India Forums shall we? Most of people on Indian forums are Asian. And it reading a lot of their posts, it seems they won't accept a cheating husband. And I've been to India many times where women are the complete opposite of Ratan. Yes, there will be a few but I would not generalise and say MOST women accept cheating husbands. And if they do, you will notice that they're much older than us. Say around in their forties-fifties. Most young women in India will not stand for this nonsense. They're getting educated and they prefer to be graduates rather than waste their live away being in a marriage with a cheat. We're not living in those times there everyone has arranged marriage like Ratan and Sampooran. Even some women in arranged marriages will not accept a cheating husband, educated or not. So that invalidates your generalisation that most indian women are like this when it's actually not.

Ratan had initially doubted Nihal but later placed her complete trust on him. When she realised that Nihal has been hiding some truth about her husband from him, she feels cheated and hurt because, I think we all agree on it that, she DESERVES to know the truth. People might find her threatening to kill Nihal OTT (I know there are a lot of Nihal pankhis here😆) but I think it's very natural of Ratan because that's how she is: fiery and impulsive.

No, had she done this to anyone else, I would strongly disagree too even if it was that cheat bag Sampooran- who I hate because he's a pathetic excuse of a man. So you might call people "Nihal Pankhis" but you cannot disagree that he's one of the most kindest characters in the serial. Better than a lot of the characters on there. Infact, this show was so boring before the entry of Nihal, do you know why? Because before his entry, Ratan had the most screen time moaning and sobbing about her pathetic husband. Ranvi and Veera only got two seconds of fame back then.

With Nihal in the pic, we saw brother and sister moments, we saw Nihal being a father to them albeit Ratan still being a miserable old woman with lesser scenes because Nihal, Ranvi and Veera were now shining in their scenes together like a real family (with Ratan excluded: only time she was with them was the Gold Temple pic)

I love them three together, eating icescream, hanging out. And funny how Ratan will make a big deal out of an accident which her husband ended up accepting death at the end so techniqually, Sampooran commited suicide, cuz he let go of Nihal's hand. But nooo, according to Ratan her hubby is a saint. Never could commit suicide.

😆

And yeah, because it's normal of her to hold up a dagger and try to kill someone in cold blood. I know a few people who are fiery and impulsive but have never broke the law. So you mean to say Ratan has a criminal streak which means kids are not safe.

Give some time to the show. Ratan would surely understand that Nihal didn't want to kill Sampooran and it was just an accident. She would eventually understand that Nihal loves her more unconditionally than Sampooran had, or would ever had!Such realisations don't happen within a blink of an eye. 😊

Nope. Nope and Nope. She had enough time. The actor Kapil is leaving for good. Probably got sick of acting as a background prop in most scenes with Ratan and Chaiji. Ratan and her son will hate Nihal forever. She can never realise how much Nihal loved her- eve more than Shampooran.Nihal is not likely to return and why would he? Only Veera loves him and no one listens to Veera when she wants Nihal Chachu to stay.

vidya0906 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Amanat284

And funny how Ratan will make a big deal out of an accident which her husband ended up accepting death at the end so techniqually, Sampooran commited suicide, cuz he let go of Nihal's hand. But nooo, according to Ratan her hubby is a saint. Never could commit suicide.

Hey Amanat, we dont know for sure whether Ratan will make a big deal out of Sampooran's accident ...they havent telecasted it yet...so why badmouth Ratan unnecessarily ? who knows after knowing the facts, she will realize Nihal is not guilty of any thing, except maybe of hiding the facts.
Edited by vidya0906 - 12 years ago
mugzzz thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

We could make an exception for Bansuri though 😆
I would love to see a cat fight over Nihal with those two. Doubt it would ever happen though LOL

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".